The characterization of temperate Super-Earth exoplanets orbiting M-dwarf stars is one of the primary objectives of modern observational astronomy. LHS 1140 b has emerged as a high-priority target in this context, owing to its position at the transition edge of the Radius Valley and the quiet nature of its host star. This thesis presents a comprehensive atmospheric investigation of LHS 1140 b, com- bining an analysis of current James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations with a benchmark of the upcoming Ariel mission’s performance. The first part of this work presents a joint retrieval analysis of the 0.68–5.2 μm transmission spectrum, combining NIRISS (Single Object Slitless Spectroscopy (SOSS)) and NIRSpec (G235H, G395H) data. The joint retrieval yields a Bayes factor of ∆ ln Z = 3.56 ± 0.16 between the best-fit scenario and the Bare Rock null hypothesis, indicating a strong preference for an atmospheric model over an airless surface. While the data are consistent with a high-mean-molecular-weight secondary atmosphere (μ ≈ 28), this value is fundamentally shaped by the choice of N2 as the fill gas used for model closure. I also identify tentative percent- level constraints on H2S, hinting at a potentially reduced volcanic state, though present noise levels preclude a decisive chemical identification. Other results include tentative upper limits on molecules such as PH3 in some scenarios, and a consistently unconstrained T-P profile across all scenarios, indicating that current JWST data cannot resolve the vertical temperature gradient for this class of planet. The second part of the thesis benchmarks the predictive capabilities of the Ariel mission using the ArielRad simulator where I aim to define Ariel’s capabilities in resolving the atmosphere of temperate Super-Earths through the evaluation of illustrative Venusian and Bioworld scenarios as synthetic stress tests . The results show that Ariel’s Tier 1 (Survey) mode operates at an ambiguity floor, where the atmosphere is statistically indistinguishable from a bare rock (∆ ln Z < 1). At Tier 2, I test both an "optimal" integration time of 20 transits as well as the integration time required to reach the mission’s target SNR ≈ 7 (43 transits); even at 43 transits, the Bayesian evidence remains a statistical tie with the null hypothesis. This outcome follows directly from the Bayesian complexity penalty: the marginal improvement in fit to the 30-ppm spectral features is insufficient for the average likelihood over the high-dimensional prior volume to outweigh the simpler Bare Rock model. These findings carry a clear implication for the Ariel mission: SNR = 7 marks the ambiguity threshold for this planet class, and the tests performed here fail to produce decisive evidence for an atmosphere or to resolve molecular signa- tures, suggesting that cold Super-Earths are poorly suited to Ariel observations. Ultimately, this work maps the limits of current transit spectroscopy and out- lines a technological roadmap toward next-generation facilities – such as LIFE and HWO – designed to probe regions of the spectrum inaccessible to transit spectroscopy.

The characterization of temperate Super-Earth exoplanets orbiting M-dwarf stars is one of the primary objectives of modern observational astronomy. LHS 1140 b has emerged as a high-priority target in this context, owing to its position at the transition edge of the Radius Valley and the quiet nature of its host star. This thesis presents a comprehensive atmospheric investigation of LHS 1140 b, com- bining an analysis of current James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations with a benchmark of the upcoming Ariel mission’s performance. The first part of this work presents a joint retrieval analysis of the 0.68–5.2 μm transmission spectrum, combining NIRISS (Single Object Slitless Spectroscopy (SOSS)) and NIRSpec (G235H, G395H) data. The joint retrieval yields a Bayes factor of ∆ ln Z = 3.56 ± 0.16 between the best-fit scenario and the Bare Rock null hypothesis, indicating a strong preference for an atmospheric model over an airless surface. While the data are consistent with a high-mean-molecular-weight secondary atmosphere (μ ≈ 28), this value is fundamentally shaped by the choice of N2 as the fill gas used for model closure. I also identify tentative percent- level constraints on H2S, hinting at a potentially reduced volcanic state, though present noise levels preclude a decisive chemical identification. Other results include tentative upper limits on molecules such as PH3 in some scenarios, and a consistently unconstrained T-P profile across all scenarios, indicating that current JWST data cannot resolve the vertical temperature gradient for this class of planet. The second part of the thesis benchmarks the predictive capabilities of the Ariel mission using the ArielRad simulator where I aim to define Ariel’s capabilities in resolving the atmosphere of temperate Super-Earths through the evaluation of illustrative Venusian and Bioworld scenarios as synthetic stress tests . The results show that Ariel’s Tier 1 (Survey) mode operates at an ambiguity floor, where the atmosphere is statistically indistinguishable from a bare rock (∆ ln Z < 1). At Tier 2, I test both an "optimal" integration time of 20 transits as well as the integration time required to reach the mission’s target SNR ≈ 7 (43 transits); even at 43 transits, the Bayesian evidence remains a statistical tie with the null hypothesis. This outcome follows directly from the Bayesian complexity penalty: the marginal improvement in fit to the 30-ppm spectral features is insufficient for the average likelihood over the high-dimensional prior volume to outweigh the simpler Bare Rock model. These findings carry a clear implication for the Ariel mission: SNR = 7 marks the ambiguity threshold for this planet class, and the tests performed here fail to produce decisive evidence for an atmosphere or to resolve molecular signa- tures, suggesting that cold Super-Earths are poorly suited to Ariel observations. Ultimately, this work maps the limits of current transit spectroscopy and out- lines a technological roadmap toward next-generation facilities – such as LIFE and HWO – designed to probe regions of the spectrum inaccessible to transit spectroscopy.

The Atmosphere of LHS 1140 b: Possibility of Biosignatures in a Secondary Atmosphere

IVANOVSKI, MARKO
2025/2026

Abstract

The characterization of temperate Super-Earth exoplanets orbiting M-dwarf stars is one of the primary objectives of modern observational astronomy. LHS 1140 b has emerged as a high-priority target in this context, owing to its position at the transition edge of the Radius Valley and the quiet nature of its host star. This thesis presents a comprehensive atmospheric investigation of LHS 1140 b, com- bining an analysis of current James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations with a benchmark of the upcoming Ariel mission’s performance. The first part of this work presents a joint retrieval analysis of the 0.68–5.2 μm transmission spectrum, combining NIRISS (Single Object Slitless Spectroscopy (SOSS)) and NIRSpec (G235H, G395H) data. The joint retrieval yields a Bayes factor of ∆ ln Z = 3.56 ± 0.16 between the best-fit scenario and the Bare Rock null hypothesis, indicating a strong preference for an atmospheric model over an airless surface. While the data are consistent with a high-mean-molecular-weight secondary atmosphere (μ ≈ 28), this value is fundamentally shaped by the choice of N2 as the fill gas used for model closure. I also identify tentative percent- level constraints on H2S, hinting at a potentially reduced volcanic state, though present noise levels preclude a decisive chemical identification. Other results include tentative upper limits on molecules such as PH3 in some scenarios, and a consistently unconstrained T-P profile across all scenarios, indicating that current JWST data cannot resolve the vertical temperature gradient for this class of planet. The second part of the thesis benchmarks the predictive capabilities of the Ariel mission using the ArielRad simulator where I aim to define Ariel’s capabilities in resolving the atmosphere of temperate Super-Earths through the evaluation of illustrative Venusian and Bioworld scenarios as synthetic stress tests . The results show that Ariel’s Tier 1 (Survey) mode operates at an ambiguity floor, where the atmosphere is statistically indistinguishable from a bare rock (∆ ln Z < 1). At Tier 2, I test both an "optimal" integration time of 20 transits as well as the integration time required to reach the mission’s target SNR ≈ 7 (43 transits); even at 43 transits, the Bayesian evidence remains a statistical tie with the null hypothesis. This outcome follows directly from the Bayesian complexity penalty: the marginal improvement in fit to the 30-ppm spectral features is insufficient for the average likelihood over the high-dimensional prior volume to outweigh the simpler Bare Rock model. These findings carry a clear implication for the Ariel mission: SNR = 7 marks the ambiguity threshold for this planet class, and the tests performed here fail to produce decisive evidence for an atmosphere or to resolve molecular signa- tures, suggesting that cold Super-Earths are poorly suited to Ariel observations. Ultimately, this work maps the limits of current transit spectroscopy and out- lines a technological roadmap toward next-generation facilities – such as LIFE and HWO – designed to probe regions of the spectrum inaccessible to transit spectroscopy.
2025
The Atmosphere of LHS 1140 b: Possibility of Biosignatures in a Secondary Atmosphere
The characterization of temperate Super-Earth exoplanets orbiting M-dwarf stars is one of the primary objectives of modern observational astronomy. LHS 1140 b has emerged as a high-priority target in this context, owing to its position at the transition edge of the Radius Valley and the quiet nature of its host star. This thesis presents a comprehensive atmospheric investigation of LHS 1140 b, com- bining an analysis of current James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) observations with a benchmark of the upcoming Ariel mission’s performance. The first part of this work presents a joint retrieval analysis of the 0.68–5.2 μm transmission spectrum, combining NIRISS (Single Object Slitless Spectroscopy (SOSS)) and NIRSpec (G235H, G395H) data. The joint retrieval yields a Bayes factor of ∆ ln Z = 3.56 ± 0.16 between the best-fit scenario and the Bare Rock null hypothesis, indicating a strong preference for an atmospheric model over an airless surface. While the data are consistent with a high-mean-molecular-weight secondary atmosphere (μ ≈ 28), this value is fundamentally shaped by the choice of N2 as the fill gas used for model closure. I also identify tentative percent- level constraints on H2S, hinting at a potentially reduced volcanic state, though present noise levels preclude a decisive chemical identification. Other results include tentative upper limits on molecules such as PH3 in some scenarios, and a consistently unconstrained T-P profile across all scenarios, indicating that current JWST data cannot resolve the vertical temperature gradient for this class of planet. The second part of the thesis benchmarks the predictive capabilities of the Ariel mission using the ArielRad simulator where I aim to define Ariel’s capabilities in resolving the atmosphere of temperate Super-Earths through the evaluation of illustrative Venusian and Bioworld scenarios as synthetic stress tests . The results show that Ariel’s Tier 1 (Survey) mode operates at an ambiguity floor, where the atmosphere is statistically indistinguishable from a bare rock (∆ ln Z < 1). At Tier 2, I test both an "optimal" integration time of 20 transits as well as the integration time required to reach the mission’s target SNR ≈ 7 (43 transits); even at 43 transits, the Bayesian evidence remains a statistical tie with the null hypothesis. This outcome follows directly from the Bayesian complexity penalty: the marginal improvement in fit to the 30-ppm spectral features is insufficient for the average likelihood over the high-dimensional prior volume to outweigh the simpler Bare Rock model. These findings carry a clear implication for the Ariel mission: SNR = 7 marks the ambiguity threshold for this planet class, and the tests performed here fail to produce decisive evidence for an atmosphere or to resolve molecular signa- tures, suggesting that cold Super-Earths are poorly suited to Ariel observations. Ultimately, this work maps the limits of current transit spectroscopy and out- lines a technological roadmap toward next-generation facilities – such as LIFE and HWO – designed to probe regions of the spectrum inaccessible to transit spectroscopy.
Exoplanets
Atmospheres
Transit Spectroscopy
Infrared
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Ivanovski_Marko.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 31.41 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
31.41 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/114557