Abstract Predator culling is increasingly used in conservation when threatened prey species decline under anthropogenic pressures. In British Columbia, Canada, many mountain caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou) herds are listed as threatened under the Species at Risk Act, and wolf (Canis lupus) reduction has been implemented as part of recovery efforts (Species at Risk Act, 2002). However, lethal predator control raises ethical concerns involving biodiversity conservation, animal welfare, human interests, and responsibilities toward future generations. This master’s thesis applies the Ethical Matrix to examine these conflicts in a structured framework. The analysis adopts a top-down approach, using the general ethical principles of well-being, autonomy, and fairness to examine moral conflicts among interested parties. From a conservation perspective, culling may support the well-being of caribou populations by reducing predation pressure. At the same time, it directly harms individual wolves and may disrupt wolf population autonomy and natural ecological processes. Prioritizing caribou recovery can be ethically justified under conservation obligations, yet fairness concerns arise if wolves are treated as management tools rather than morally considerable animals. Human stakeholders also differ in their value demands, with some prioritizing caribou recovery, ecosystem protection, and future biodiversity while others oppose lethal intervention due to concerns related to animal welfare, cultural values, or ecological considerations. The conflicts identified through the Ethical Matrix are further examined from the perspectives of traditional, new, and compassionate conservation. This comparison shows how different conservation frameworks assign different importance to the same competing value demands. This comparison demonstrates that the ethical assessment of wolf culling changes according to whether greater emphasis is placed on biodiversity and ecological processes, human interests and fairness, or the welfare of individual animals. These findings demonstrate that the trade-offs involved cannot be resolved through biological effectiveness alone. Rather than treating wolf culling for mountain caribou conservation solely as a technical wildlife-management issue, the Ethical Matrix allows competing ethical considerations to be compared more transparently, clarifying where conservation goals conflict with animal welfare and social justice concerns.
Abstract Predator culling is increasingly used in conservation when threatened prey species decline under anthropogenic pressures. In British Columbia, Canada, many mountain caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou) herds are listed as threatened under the Species at Risk Act, and wolf (Canis lupus) reduction has been implemented as part of recovery efforts (Species at Risk Act, 2002). However, lethal predator control raises ethical concerns involving biodiversity conservation, animal welfare, human interests, and responsibilities toward future generations. This master’s thesis applies the Ethical Matrix to examine these conflicts in a structured framework. The analysis adopts a top-down approach, using the general ethical principles of well-being, autonomy, and fairness to examine moral conflicts among interested parties. From a conservation perspective, culling may support the well-being of caribou populations by reducing predation pressure. At the same time, it directly harms individual wolves and may disrupt wolf population autonomy and natural ecological processes. Prioritizing caribou recovery can be ethically justified under conservation obligations, yet fairness concerns arise if wolves are treated as management tools rather than morally considerable animals. Human stakeholders also differ in their value demands, with some prioritizing caribou recovery, ecosystem protection, and future biodiversity while others oppose lethal intervention due to concerns related to animal welfare, cultural values, or ecological considerations. The conflicts identified through the Ethical Matrix are further examined from the perspectives of traditional, new, and compassionate conservation. This comparison shows how different conservation frameworks assign different importance to the same competing value demands. This comparison demonstrates that the ethical assessment of wolf culling changes according to whether greater emphasis is placed on biodiversity and ecological processes, human interests and fairness, or the welfare of individual animals. These findings demonstrate that the trade-offs involved cannot be resolved through biological effectiveness alone. Rather than treating wolf culling for mountain caribou conservation solely as a technical wildlife-management issue, the Ethical Matrix allows competing ethical considerations to be compared more transparently, clarifying where conservation goals conflict with animal welfare and social justice concerns.
An Ethical Matrix Analysis of Wolf Culls for Mountain Caribou Conservation in British Columbia, Canada
BODIROGA, MAJA
2025/2026
Abstract
Abstract Predator culling is increasingly used in conservation when threatened prey species decline under anthropogenic pressures. In British Columbia, Canada, many mountain caribou (Rangifer tarandus caribou) herds are listed as threatened under the Species at Risk Act, and wolf (Canis lupus) reduction has been implemented as part of recovery efforts (Species at Risk Act, 2002). However, lethal predator control raises ethical concerns involving biodiversity conservation, animal welfare, human interests, and responsibilities toward future generations. This master’s thesis applies the Ethical Matrix to examine these conflicts in a structured framework. The analysis adopts a top-down approach, using the general ethical principles of well-being, autonomy, and fairness to examine moral conflicts among interested parties. From a conservation perspective, culling may support the well-being of caribou populations by reducing predation pressure. At the same time, it directly harms individual wolves and may disrupt wolf population autonomy and natural ecological processes. Prioritizing caribou recovery can be ethically justified under conservation obligations, yet fairness concerns arise if wolves are treated as management tools rather than morally considerable animals. Human stakeholders also differ in their value demands, with some prioritizing caribou recovery, ecosystem protection, and future biodiversity while others oppose lethal intervention due to concerns related to animal welfare, cultural values, or ecological considerations. The conflicts identified through the Ethical Matrix are further examined from the perspectives of traditional, new, and compassionate conservation. This comparison shows how different conservation frameworks assign different importance to the same competing value demands. This comparison demonstrates that the ethical assessment of wolf culling changes according to whether greater emphasis is placed on biodiversity and ecological processes, human interests and fairness, or the welfare of individual animals. These findings demonstrate that the trade-offs involved cannot be resolved through biological effectiveness alone. Rather than treating wolf culling for mountain caribou conservation solely as a technical wildlife-management issue, the Ethical Matrix allows competing ethical considerations to be compared more transparently, clarifying where conservation goals conflict with animal welfare and social justice concerns.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Bodiroga_Maja.pdf
embargo fino al 28/09/2027
Dimensione
893.91 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
893.91 kB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/115866