A plastic footprint quantifies the plastic that a product or activity releases to the environment over its life cycle, and the impact that release causes. For marine plastic it usually stops one step earlier, at a leakage inventory. That inventory counts the mass of plastic reaching the sea, whether macroplastic or primary microplastic, and for a lost fishing net that mass is the netting itself. Impact assessment starts one step further on, from microplastic described by polymer, shape and size. The secondary microplastic formed as lost netting degrades connects the two, and current assessments assume it rather than derive it. This thesis presents a scenario-based approach to that step for 1 kg of polymer used in fishing nets, over the twelve months following loss. The degraded mass is derived from published data, and its conversion into microplastic is retained as an explicit assumption. Eight scenarios pair a net type, which fixes polymer and loss rate, with one of three exposure layers. The inputs are gear loss rates from a meta-analysis, a depth-corrected field exposure of rope, measured particle characteristics, and the characterisation factors of the Marine Impacts in Life Cycle Assessment initiative. Monte Carlo simulation propagates the uncertainty of the four parameters for which a distribution can be built from published data, and grouped Sobol indices locate the dominant sampled sources of that uncertainty. Emissions range from 1.2 to 9.4 g of secondary microplastic per functional unit. The scenario rankings by emitted mass and by characterised impact differ. At the baseline, with the water-column characterisation factors used here, the order between the two polymers reverses: polyamide scenarios lead by mass and high-density polyethylene scenarios by impact. Purse seine nets emit the most microplastic; bottom trawls carry the highest impact. Among the sampled parameters, the uncertainty is dominated by the characterisation factor and the particle-size assignment, while the loss rate within the selected source contributes little. The simulated 90 % intervals are wide, the 95th percentile exceeding the 5th by 41 to 130 times, and they overlap for every pair of scenarios, so the exact order is uncertain. The order also depends on the polymer assigned to each net type, the loss-rate source, the use of one fragmentation factor for both polymers, the water-column characterisation factors and how particle size is represented. With particle size weighted by mass instead, the difference between the polymers narrows and purse seine nets rank first by both mass and impact. The fragmentation factor is fixed at unity, an upper bound rather than a measurement, so no figure is an expected emission. The particle characteristics come from mechanically abraded rope rather than from passive degradation. Sediment abrasion is not represented and could increase emissions from seabed-contact gear; the direction of the overall modelling bias remains uncertain.
A plastic footprint quantifies the plastic that a product or activity releases to the environment over its life cycle, and the impact that release causes. For marine plastic it usually stops one step earlier, at a leakage inventory. That inventory counts the mass of plastic reaching the sea, whether macroplastic or primary microplastic, and for a lost fishing net that mass is the netting itself. Impact assessment starts one step further on, from microplastic described by polymer, shape and size. The secondary microplastic formed as lost netting degrades connects the two, and current assessments assume it rather than derive it. This thesis presents a scenario-based approach to that step for 1 kg of polymer used in fishing nets, over the twelve months following loss. The degraded mass is derived from published data, and its conversion into microplastic is retained as an explicit assumption. Eight scenarios pair a net type, which fixes polymer and loss rate, with one of three exposure layers. The inputs are gear loss rates from a meta-analysis, a depth-corrected field exposure of rope, measured particle characteristics, and the characterisation factors of the Marine Impacts in Life Cycle Assessment initiative. Monte Carlo simulation propagates the uncertainty of the four parameters for which a distribution can be built from published data, and grouped Sobol indices locate the dominant sampled sources of that uncertainty. Emissions range from 1.2 to 9.4 g of secondary microplastic per functional unit. The scenario rankings by emitted mass and by characterised impact differ. At the baseline, with the water-column characterisation factors used here, the order between the two polymers reverses: polyamide scenarios lead by mass and high-density polyethylene scenarios by impact. Purse seine nets emit the most microplastic; bottom trawls carry the highest impact. Among the sampled parameters, the uncertainty is dominated by the characterisation factor and the particle-size assignment, while the loss rate within the selected source contributes little. The simulated 90 % intervals are wide, the 95th percentile exceeding the 5th by 41 to 130 times, and they overlap for every pair of scenarios, so the exact order is uncertain. The order also depends on the polymer assigned to each net type, the loss-rate source, the use of one fragmentation factor for both polymers, the water-column characterisation factors and how particle size is represented. With particle size weighted by mass instead, the difference between the polymers narrows and purse seine nets rank first by both mass and impact. The fragmentation factor is fixed at unity, an upper bound rather than a measurement, so no figure is an expected emission. The particle characteristics come from mechanically abraded rope rather than from passive degradation. Sediment abrasion is not represented and could increase emissions from seabed-contact gear; the direction of the overall modelling bias remains uncertain.
APPLICATION OF PLASTIC FOOTPRINTS FOR THE ANALYSIS OF PLASTIC NETS DEGRADATION IN MARINE ENVIRONMENT
TUFAN, EGEMEN
2025/2026
Abstract
A plastic footprint quantifies the plastic that a product or activity releases to the environment over its life cycle, and the impact that release causes. For marine plastic it usually stops one step earlier, at a leakage inventory. That inventory counts the mass of plastic reaching the sea, whether macroplastic or primary microplastic, and for a lost fishing net that mass is the netting itself. Impact assessment starts one step further on, from microplastic described by polymer, shape and size. The secondary microplastic formed as lost netting degrades connects the two, and current assessments assume it rather than derive it. This thesis presents a scenario-based approach to that step for 1 kg of polymer used in fishing nets, over the twelve months following loss. The degraded mass is derived from published data, and its conversion into microplastic is retained as an explicit assumption. Eight scenarios pair a net type, which fixes polymer and loss rate, with one of three exposure layers. The inputs are gear loss rates from a meta-analysis, a depth-corrected field exposure of rope, measured particle characteristics, and the characterisation factors of the Marine Impacts in Life Cycle Assessment initiative. Monte Carlo simulation propagates the uncertainty of the four parameters for which a distribution can be built from published data, and grouped Sobol indices locate the dominant sampled sources of that uncertainty. Emissions range from 1.2 to 9.4 g of secondary microplastic per functional unit. The scenario rankings by emitted mass and by characterised impact differ. At the baseline, with the water-column characterisation factors used here, the order between the two polymers reverses: polyamide scenarios lead by mass and high-density polyethylene scenarios by impact. Purse seine nets emit the most microplastic; bottom trawls carry the highest impact. Among the sampled parameters, the uncertainty is dominated by the characterisation factor and the particle-size assignment, while the loss rate within the selected source contributes little. The simulated 90 % intervals are wide, the 95th percentile exceeding the 5th by 41 to 130 times, and they overlap for every pair of scenarios, so the exact order is uncertain. The order also depends on the polymer assigned to each net type, the loss-rate source, the use of one fragmentation factor for both polymers, the water-column characterisation factors and how particle size is represented. With particle size weighted by mass instead, the difference between the polymers narrows and purse seine nets rank first by both mass and impact. The fragmentation factor is fixed at unity, an upper bound rather than a measurement, so no figure is an expected emission. The particle characteristics come from mechanically abraded rope rather than from passive degradation. Sediment abrasion is not represented and could increase emissions from seabed-contact gear; the direction of the overall modelling bias remains uncertain.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tufan_Egemen.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
1.78 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.78 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/116668