Corn silage (CS) is the predominant forage used in dairy cattle diets, but its production is increasingly constrained by high water and input requirements, making it vulnerable to the water scarcity and rising cultivation costs associated with climate change. Sorghum silage (SS) has been proposed as a viable alternative, owing to its greater drought tolerance, lower irrigation and fertilizer demand, and adaptability to marginal growing conditions, while offering comparable fiber and energy content. However, evidence on the extent to which cow parity modulates the productive and technological consequences of this substitution remains limited. This study evaluated the effect of complete replacement of CS with SS on feeding behaviour, milk yield and composition, milk fatty acid profile, metabolic status, and cheesemaking properties, and tested whether these responses differed between primiparous and secondiparous Holstein-Friesian cows. A 2×2 crossover design was applied on a commercial dairy farm (Verona, Italy) using 242 lactating cows in mid-lactation fed either a corn silage (CS)-based or sorghum silage (SS)-based diet in two consecutive 1-month periods. Diets were formulated to be isoenergetic and isonitrogenous. Behavioural traits, milk yield and composition, blood metabolic profile, milk fatty acid profile, and coagulation traits were analysed using linear mixed models accounting for parity order, diet, days in milk (DIM), temperature-humidity index (THI), and their interactions. Neither the production nor the concentration of β-hydroxybutyric acid in the cow’s blood was significantly influenced by the diets, thus suggesting that full replacement did not affect productivity nor worsen the metabolic state of the animals. However, compared to corn silages, cows receiving Sorghum silage showed a decrease in rumination and increase in the rest time, along with decreased standard yield, protein content, and casein. Moreover, milk obtained from cows that received Sorghum silage needed more time for technological curd firmness (k20), as well as exhibited a smaller curd firmness potential (CFP). The differences according to parity became statistically significant but were insignificant in absolute values; thus, the productivity of milk was nearly the same. This means that complete replacement of Corn Silages by Sorghum Silage is nutritionally feasible without any impact on milk output or the well-being of the cows; however, this results in parity-dependent differences in milk composition (protein, fat), as well as coagulation parameters. This also implies that suggestions on silage type selection have to be done on a parity-specific basis, especially where the cheese production potential is a concern. The obtained findings may serve as a good basis for developing sustainable and climate-resilient strategies of forage selection for dairy farms. At the same time, additional studies have to be performed to develop parity-specific feeding programs, as well as to understand the mechanisms behind parity-by-diet interactions found in this study.
L'insilato di mais (CS) rappresenta ancora il foraggio principale nella dieta delle bovine da latte. Ciononostante, tra elevati fabbisogni idrici e costi d'irrigazione in aumento per via del cambiamento climatico, la sua coltura è sempre più a rischio. Una valida alternativa è l'insilato di sorgo (SS): resiste meglio alla siccità, richiede meno fertilizzanti e si adatta a terreni marginali, garantendo un apporto energetico e fibroso del tutto simile. Resta però da chiarire quanto l'ordine di parto (primipare vs. secondipare) possa influenzare la risposta produttiva e tecnologica del latte a questo cambio di dieta. In questo studio abbiamo quindi testato la sostituzione totale del CS con SS su comportamento alimentare, resa del latte, profilo in acidi grassi, assetto metabolico e attitudine alla caseificazione in vacche Holstein-Friesian primipare e secondipare. La prova è stata condotta in un allevamento commerciale del veronese su 242 vacche in medio-lattazione con un disegno 2×2 crossover, su due periodi di un mese. Le diete (a base di CS o SS) erano isoenergetiche e isoproteiche. Attraverso modelli misti lineari abbiamo analizzato i parametri comportamentali, produttivi, metabolici ed ematici, includendo nel modello l'ordine di parto, la dieta, i giorni di lattazione (DIM), l'indice microclimatico (THI) e le relative interazioni. Dati alla mano, la produzione e la concentrazione di β-idrossibutirrato ematico non hanno subito variazioni significative tra le diete: la sostituzione completa non ha quindi penalizzato i volumi né peggiorato lo stato metabolico delle bovine. Con la dieta SS si è evidenziata tuttavia una riduzione dei tempi di ruminazione (a favore del riposo), insieme a un lieve calo della resa standardizzata, della proteina e della caseina. Il latte da dieta SS ha richiesto più tempo per la formazione del coagulo (k20) e ha mostrato una minore consistenza potenziale (CFP). Le differenze legate alla parità sono risultate statisticamente significative, ma ridotte nei valori effettivi, lasciando la produzione complessiva sostanzialmente allineata. Sostituire del tutto l'insilato di mais con quello di sorgo è dunque fattibile sul piano nutrizionale e sicuro per la salute animale. Vanno però messe in conto variazioni nella composizione del latte (grasso e proteine) e nelle sue doti di coagulazione a seconda che si tratti di primipare o pluripare. Ciò suggerisce di pianificare la scelta dei foraggi tenendo conto del gruppo di parità, specialmente negli allevamenti a vocazione casearia. In prospettiva, questi dati offrono una solida base per impostare strategie foraggere resilienti al clima, anche se serviranno ulteriori approfondimenti sui meccanismi alla base dell'interazione dieta-parità.
Impact of the Complete Substitution of Corn Silage with Sorghum Silage on Milk Production, Composition, and Quality in Dairy Cows
AIYANDRA NANDA KUMAR, DIANA
2025/2026
Abstract
Corn silage (CS) is the predominant forage used in dairy cattle diets, but its production is increasingly constrained by high water and input requirements, making it vulnerable to the water scarcity and rising cultivation costs associated with climate change. Sorghum silage (SS) has been proposed as a viable alternative, owing to its greater drought tolerance, lower irrigation and fertilizer demand, and adaptability to marginal growing conditions, while offering comparable fiber and energy content. However, evidence on the extent to which cow parity modulates the productive and technological consequences of this substitution remains limited. This study evaluated the effect of complete replacement of CS with SS on feeding behaviour, milk yield and composition, milk fatty acid profile, metabolic status, and cheesemaking properties, and tested whether these responses differed between primiparous and secondiparous Holstein-Friesian cows. A 2×2 crossover design was applied on a commercial dairy farm (Verona, Italy) using 242 lactating cows in mid-lactation fed either a corn silage (CS)-based or sorghum silage (SS)-based diet in two consecutive 1-month periods. Diets were formulated to be isoenergetic and isonitrogenous. Behavioural traits, milk yield and composition, blood metabolic profile, milk fatty acid profile, and coagulation traits were analysed using linear mixed models accounting for parity order, diet, days in milk (DIM), temperature-humidity index (THI), and their interactions. Neither the production nor the concentration of β-hydroxybutyric acid in the cow’s blood was significantly influenced by the diets, thus suggesting that full replacement did not affect productivity nor worsen the metabolic state of the animals. However, compared to corn silages, cows receiving Sorghum silage showed a decrease in rumination and increase in the rest time, along with decreased standard yield, protein content, and casein. Moreover, milk obtained from cows that received Sorghum silage needed more time for technological curd firmness (k20), as well as exhibited a smaller curd firmness potential (CFP). The differences according to parity became statistically significant but were insignificant in absolute values; thus, the productivity of milk was nearly the same. This means that complete replacement of Corn Silages by Sorghum Silage is nutritionally feasible without any impact on milk output or the well-being of the cows; however, this results in parity-dependent differences in milk composition (protein, fat), as well as coagulation parameters. This also implies that suggestions on silage type selection have to be done on a parity-specific basis, especially where the cheese production potential is a concern. The obtained findings may serve as a good basis for developing sustainable and climate-resilient strategies of forage selection for dairy farms. At the same time, additional studies have to be performed to develop parity-specific feeding programs, as well as to understand the mechanisms behind parity-by-diet interactions found in this study.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
AiyandraNandaKumar_Diana.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
833.21 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
833.21 kB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117894