Genocide is the crime of crimes, and the law has struggled to stop it due to an inflexible and sometimes narrow definition established in 1948. The central issue in this legal problem is specific intent or dolus specialis, which requires evidence of a deliberate intention to annihilate a protected group either as a whole or in part. This thesis posits the question of the stability of the notion of genocide, which is essentially still contentious eight decades after its establishment, specifically in how the lack of official recognition often paralyzes international action. The study uses a comparative case study of the 1994 Rwandan Genocide and the 1995 Srebrenica massacre to examine the pivotal point where mass violence and legal classification intersect. The study, in the Rwandan context, finds that the absence of clear terminology and political indecisiveness led to the disastrous delay of humanitarian aid. On the other hand, the Srebrenica case study shows how the legal battles entailed in the classification of localized atrocities in the wider scope of the 1948 Convention were complicated. By assessing past reactions, the study aims to determine proactive legal and diplomatic measures to prevent future incidents of mass violence. The research finally holds the position that an effective peace process is not possible based solely on punitive judicial consequences. Instead, it has to integrate a sound rights-based strategy, which emphasizes human dignity and the active involvement of civilian populations in restoring the social order.

Genocide is the crime of crimes, and the law has struggled to stop it due to an inflexible and sometimes narrow definition established in 1948. The central issue in this legal problem is specific intent or dolus specialis, which requires evidence of a deliberate intention to annihilate a protected group either as a whole or in part. This thesis posits the question of the stability of the notion of genocide, which is essentially still contentious eight decades after its establishment, specifically in how the lack of official recognition often paralyzes international action. The study uses a comparative case study of the 1994 Rwandan Genocide and the 1995 Srebrenica massacre to examine the pivotal point where mass violence and legal classification intersect. The study, in the Rwandan context, finds that the absence of clear terminology and political indecisiveness led to the disastrous delay of humanitarian aid. On the other hand, the Srebrenica case study shows how the legal battles entailed in the classification of localized atrocities in the wider scope of the 1948 Convention were complicated. By assessing past reactions, the study aims to determine proactive legal and diplomatic measures to prevent future incidents of mass violence. The research finally holds the position that an effective peace process is not possible based solely on punitive judicial consequences. Instead, it has to integrate a sound rights-based strategy, which emphasizes human dignity and the active involvement of civilian populations in restoring the social order.

The Persistent Contestation of Genocide (Historical Development, Conceptual Tensions, and Comparative Case Study Analysis)

AGHAYEV, TURAL
2025/2026

Abstract

Genocide is the crime of crimes, and the law has struggled to stop it due to an inflexible and sometimes narrow definition established in 1948. The central issue in this legal problem is specific intent or dolus specialis, which requires evidence of a deliberate intention to annihilate a protected group either as a whole or in part. This thesis posits the question of the stability of the notion of genocide, which is essentially still contentious eight decades after its establishment, specifically in how the lack of official recognition often paralyzes international action. The study uses a comparative case study of the 1994 Rwandan Genocide and the 1995 Srebrenica massacre to examine the pivotal point where mass violence and legal classification intersect. The study, in the Rwandan context, finds that the absence of clear terminology and political indecisiveness led to the disastrous delay of humanitarian aid. On the other hand, the Srebrenica case study shows how the legal battles entailed in the classification of localized atrocities in the wider scope of the 1948 Convention were complicated. By assessing past reactions, the study aims to determine proactive legal and diplomatic measures to prevent future incidents of mass violence. The research finally holds the position that an effective peace process is not possible based solely on punitive judicial consequences. Instead, it has to integrate a sound rights-based strategy, which emphasizes human dignity and the active involvement of civilian populations in restoring the social order.
2025
The Persistent Contestation of Genocide (Historical Development, Conceptual Tensions, and Comparative Case Study Analysis)
Genocide is the crime of crimes, and the law has struggled to stop it due to an inflexible and sometimes narrow definition established in 1948. The central issue in this legal problem is specific intent or dolus specialis, which requires evidence of a deliberate intention to annihilate a protected group either as a whole or in part. This thesis posits the question of the stability of the notion of genocide, which is essentially still contentious eight decades after its establishment, specifically in how the lack of official recognition often paralyzes international action. The study uses a comparative case study of the 1994 Rwandan Genocide and the 1995 Srebrenica massacre to examine the pivotal point where mass violence and legal classification intersect. The study, in the Rwandan context, finds that the absence of clear terminology and political indecisiveness led to the disastrous delay of humanitarian aid. On the other hand, the Srebrenica case study shows how the legal battles entailed in the classification of localized atrocities in the wider scope of the 1948 Convention were complicated. By assessing past reactions, the study aims to determine proactive legal and diplomatic measures to prevent future incidents of mass violence. The research finally holds the position that an effective peace process is not possible based solely on punitive judicial consequences. Instead, it has to integrate a sound rights-based strategy, which emphasizes human dignity and the active involvement of civilian populations in restoring the social order.
Genocide
Intent
Bureaucracy
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Aghayev_Tural_2121546.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 2.47 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
2.47 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118184