This thesis examines how the over-responsibilization of non-governmental organizations within humanitarian governance contributes to the reproduction of dependency, deferred rights, and asymmetrical power relations in the response to Syrian displacement in Lebanon. It is argued that their disproportionate role must be understood within a broader governance structure in which the Lebanese state does not fully guarantee refugee rights and protection, while humanitarian actors are increasingly required to assume responsibilities related to welfare, service provision, and everyday refugee management. In this context, assistance comes to function not as a complement to rights, but as a substitute for them. The thesis is grounded in a decolonial and critical humanitarian framework. Drawing on the concepts of coloniality of power, epistemic hierarchy, humanitarian reason, and humanitarian governance, it argues that aid cannot be understood as neutral, since it operates through unequal relations of authority, legitimacy, and representation. Using Lebanon as an empirical site to examine these broader dynamics, the aim of this research is to analyze how refugee governance has developed in a setting marked by political fragmentation, legal ambiguity, limited state protection, and strong reliance on humanitarian actors. It discusses that NGOs have become central intermediaries in the organization of refugee life, yet without the authority to provide durable protection or resolve the structural conditions that produce exclusion. Their over-responsibilization is therefore not simply an institutional burden, but a defining feature of a humanitarian system that manages survival while leaving rights deferred. The thesis contributes to critical debates on humanitarianism by showing that dependency is not merely an unintended consequence of aid, nor solely the result of NGO practice, but a structural outcome of a governance arrangement in which responsibilities are displaced onto humanitarian actors in the absence of substantive rights and state protection. In doing so, it positions the Lebanese case as a revealing site for a broader critique of humanitarian governance, NGOization, and the management of precarious refugee lives.

NGO Over-Responsibilization, Humanitarian Governance, and Dependency in Lebanon’s Response to Syrian Displacement

GUIMARAES VIZZOTTO, BIANCA
2025/2026

Abstract

This thesis examines how the over-responsibilization of non-governmental organizations within humanitarian governance contributes to the reproduction of dependency, deferred rights, and asymmetrical power relations in the response to Syrian displacement in Lebanon. It is argued that their disproportionate role must be understood within a broader governance structure in which the Lebanese state does not fully guarantee refugee rights and protection, while humanitarian actors are increasingly required to assume responsibilities related to welfare, service provision, and everyday refugee management. In this context, assistance comes to function not as a complement to rights, but as a substitute for them. The thesis is grounded in a decolonial and critical humanitarian framework. Drawing on the concepts of coloniality of power, epistemic hierarchy, humanitarian reason, and humanitarian governance, it argues that aid cannot be understood as neutral, since it operates through unequal relations of authority, legitimacy, and representation. Using Lebanon as an empirical site to examine these broader dynamics, the aim of this research is to analyze how refugee governance has developed in a setting marked by political fragmentation, legal ambiguity, limited state protection, and strong reliance on humanitarian actors. It discusses that NGOs have become central intermediaries in the organization of refugee life, yet without the authority to provide durable protection or resolve the structural conditions that produce exclusion. Their over-responsibilization is therefore not simply an institutional burden, but a defining feature of a humanitarian system that manages survival while leaving rights deferred. The thesis contributes to critical debates on humanitarianism by showing that dependency is not merely an unintended consequence of aid, nor solely the result of NGO practice, but a structural outcome of a governance arrangement in which responsibilities are displaced onto humanitarian actors in the absence of substantive rights and state protection. In doing so, it positions the Lebanese case as a revealing site for a broader critique of humanitarian governance, NGOization, and the management of precarious refugee lives.
2025
NGO Over-Responsibilization, Humanitarian Governance, and Dependency in Lebanon’s Response to Syrian Displacement
Decoloniality
NGOs
Dependency
Refugee governance
Lebanon
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
BiancaVizzotto_Thesis.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 649.49 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
649.49 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118186