This thesis examines how evolving interpretations and applications of Sharia affect women’s rights and how these dynamics are assessed within the international human rights framework. Rather than treating Sharia as a fixed and uniform body of rules, the study approaches it as a plural and evolving normative framework whose legal effects are shaped by interpretation, state institutions, religious authorities, social movements and transnational pressures. The research adopts a socio-legal and interdisciplinary perspective informed by feminist human rights analysis, substantive equality and legal pluralism. It first examines the tension between the universality of human rights and claims based on cultural and religious particularity, with particular attention to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women and the Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam. It then analyses the institutional and sociological processes through which particular interpretations of Sharia acquire legal authority and shape women’s legal position and the practical enjoyment of their rights. Special attention is given to family and personal status law, including marriage, divorce, guardianship, custody and inheritance, as these areas represent some of the principal sites of tension between religiously grounded norms and international standards of equality and non-discrimination. The thesis also examines how the CEDAW Committee and United Nations Special Procedures address conflicts involving freedom of religion or belief and women’s rights. Finally, the study develops a comparative analysis of Morocco and the United Arab Emirates to assess how different forms of codification, legal pluralism, reform strategies and institutional authority shape the protection of women’s rights. It argues that the effects of Sharia-based norms cannot be understood through religious reference alone, but depend on the institutional processes through which particular interpretations are selected, incorporated into law and enforced. The research therefore identifies the legal and institutional conditions under which religiously grounded norms may preserve inequality, accommodate reform or be brought into closer alignment with international human rights standards.

Sharia and Women’s Rights under International Human Rights Regime: A Comparative Analysis of Morocco and the United Arab Emirates

MAGNABOSCO, IRENE
2025/2026

Abstract

This thesis examines how evolving interpretations and applications of Sharia affect women’s rights and how these dynamics are assessed within the international human rights framework. Rather than treating Sharia as a fixed and uniform body of rules, the study approaches it as a plural and evolving normative framework whose legal effects are shaped by interpretation, state institutions, religious authorities, social movements and transnational pressures. The research adopts a socio-legal and interdisciplinary perspective informed by feminist human rights analysis, substantive equality and legal pluralism. It first examines the tension between the universality of human rights and claims based on cultural and religious particularity, with particular attention to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women and the Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam. It then analyses the institutional and sociological processes through which particular interpretations of Sharia acquire legal authority and shape women’s legal position and the practical enjoyment of their rights. Special attention is given to family and personal status law, including marriage, divorce, guardianship, custody and inheritance, as these areas represent some of the principal sites of tension between religiously grounded norms and international standards of equality and non-discrimination. The thesis also examines how the CEDAW Committee and United Nations Special Procedures address conflicts involving freedom of religion or belief and women’s rights. Finally, the study develops a comparative analysis of Morocco and the United Arab Emirates to assess how different forms of codification, legal pluralism, reform strategies and institutional authority shape the protection of women’s rights. It argues that the effects of Sharia-based norms cannot be understood through religious reference alone, but depend on the institutional processes through which particular interpretations are selected, incorporated into law and enforced. The research therefore identifies the legal and institutional conditions under which religiously grounded norms may preserve inequality, accommodate reform or be brought into closer alignment with international human rights standards.
2025
Sharia and Women’s Rights under International Human Rights Regime: A Comparative Analysis of Morocco and the United Arab Emirates
Sharia Law
Women's rights
Morocco
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
official draft.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 2.07 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
2.07 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118188