The growing number of women in political leadership roles has been seen as a sign of success for gender equality. However, the election of female leaders of government or state does not inevitably translate into substantial advancements in women’s rights or gender-sensitive public policy. This thesis explores the intersection of women’s human rights and female political leadership through a comparative analysis of Giorgia Meloni, Prime Minister of Italy, and Claudia Sheinbaum, President of Mexico, focusing on their political careers, leadership styles, and policy impacts. The research intends to explore whether descriptive representation, the presence of women in positions of political authority, results in substantive representation, which is defined as promoting policies that successfully advance women's rights and gender equality. The research examines how political ideology, institutional arrangements, and sociocultural circumstances influence the opportunities and limitations encountered by women leaders, drawing on feminist political theory, theories of political representation, gender studies, and leadership literature. The conflict between symbolic representation and transformational political action, including the idea of donnismo as a kind of identity-based political legitimacy, is given special focus. Using a qualitative comparative case study technique, the thesis examines legislative efforts, government policies, and institutional reforms that impact women's rights in Italy and Mexico in addition to document analysis and political discourse analysis. The comparative design makes it possible to evaluate how various ideological orientations, conservative nationalism in Italy and progressive technocratic leadership in Mexico, interact with gender to affect political power and policy results. The study demonstrates that having women in positions of authority does not immediately eliminate structural injustices or provide gender-responsive governance, highlighting the ongoing gap between symbolic political participation and revolutionary policy change. This study adds to the larger discussion on women's political representation by fusing feminist political theory with comparative political analysis and a human rights viewpoint. It shows that significant advancements depend more on the interaction between institutional structures, political ideology, and the dedication to enacting meaningful gender equality policies than on the gender of political leaders. The thesis ends with policy suggestions meant to improve the circumstances in which women's political representation can lead to long-term advancements in women's human rights.

The growing number of women in political leadership roles has been seen as a sign of success for gender equality. However, the election of female leaders of government or state does not inevitably translate into substantial advancements in women’s rights or gender-sensitive public policy. This thesis explores the intersection of women’s human rights and female political leadership through a comparative analysis of Giorgia Meloni, Prime Minister of Italy, and Claudia Sheinbaum, President of Mexico, focusing on their political careers, leadership styles, and policy impacts. The research intends to explore whether descriptive representation, the presence of women in positions of political authority, results in substantive representation, which is defined as promoting policies that successfully advance women's rights and gender equality. The research examines how political ideology, institutional arrangements, and sociocultural circumstances influence the opportunities and limitations encountered by women leaders, drawing on feminist political theory, theories of political representation, gender studies, and leadership literature. The conflict between symbolic representation and transformational political action, including the idea of donnismo as a kind of identity-based political legitimacy, is given special focus. Using a qualitative comparative case study technique, the thesis examines legislative efforts, government policies, and institutional reforms that impact women's rights in Italy and Mexico in addition to document analysis and political discourse analysis. The comparative design makes it possible to evaluate how various ideological orientations, conservative nationalism in Italy and progressive technocratic leadership in Mexico, interact with gender to affect political power and policy results. The study demonstrates that having women in positions of authority does not immediately eliminate structural injustices or provide gender-responsive governance, highlighting the ongoing gap between symbolic political participation and revolutionary policy change. This study adds to the larger discussion on women's political representation by fusing feminist political theory with comparative political analysis and a human rights viewpoint. It shows that significant advancements depend more on the interaction between institutional structures, political ideology, and the dedication to enacting meaningful gender equality policies than on the gender of political leaders. The thesis ends with policy suggestions meant to improve the circumstances in which women's political representation can lead to long-term advancements in women's human rights.

Gendered Leadership and the Limits of Representation in Contemporary Democracy: The Cases of Giorgia Meloni and Claudia Sheinbaum

MASTRANGELO, CHIARA
2025/2026

Abstract

The growing number of women in political leadership roles has been seen as a sign of success for gender equality. However, the election of female leaders of government or state does not inevitably translate into substantial advancements in women’s rights or gender-sensitive public policy. This thesis explores the intersection of women’s human rights and female political leadership through a comparative analysis of Giorgia Meloni, Prime Minister of Italy, and Claudia Sheinbaum, President of Mexico, focusing on their political careers, leadership styles, and policy impacts. The research intends to explore whether descriptive representation, the presence of women in positions of political authority, results in substantive representation, which is defined as promoting policies that successfully advance women's rights and gender equality. The research examines how political ideology, institutional arrangements, and sociocultural circumstances influence the opportunities and limitations encountered by women leaders, drawing on feminist political theory, theories of political representation, gender studies, and leadership literature. The conflict between symbolic representation and transformational political action, including the idea of donnismo as a kind of identity-based political legitimacy, is given special focus. Using a qualitative comparative case study technique, the thesis examines legislative efforts, government policies, and institutional reforms that impact women's rights in Italy and Mexico in addition to document analysis and political discourse analysis. The comparative design makes it possible to evaluate how various ideological orientations, conservative nationalism in Italy and progressive technocratic leadership in Mexico, interact with gender to affect political power and policy results. The study demonstrates that having women in positions of authority does not immediately eliminate structural injustices or provide gender-responsive governance, highlighting the ongoing gap between symbolic political participation and revolutionary policy change. This study adds to the larger discussion on women's political representation by fusing feminist political theory with comparative political analysis and a human rights viewpoint. It shows that significant advancements depend more on the interaction between institutional structures, political ideology, and the dedication to enacting meaningful gender equality policies than on the gender of political leaders. The thesis ends with policy suggestions meant to improve the circumstances in which women's political representation can lead to long-term advancements in women's human rights.
2025
Gendered Leadership and the Limits of Representation in Contemporary Democracy: The Cases of Giorgia Meloni and Claudia Sheinbaum
The growing number of women in political leadership roles has been seen as a sign of success for gender equality. However, the election of female leaders of government or state does not inevitably translate into substantial advancements in women’s rights or gender-sensitive public policy. This thesis explores the intersection of women’s human rights and female political leadership through a comparative analysis of Giorgia Meloni, Prime Minister of Italy, and Claudia Sheinbaum, President of Mexico, focusing on their political careers, leadership styles, and policy impacts. The research intends to explore whether descriptive representation, the presence of women in positions of political authority, results in substantive representation, which is defined as promoting policies that successfully advance women's rights and gender equality. The research examines how political ideology, institutional arrangements, and sociocultural circumstances influence the opportunities and limitations encountered by women leaders, drawing on feminist political theory, theories of political representation, gender studies, and leadership literature. The conflict between symbolic representation and transformational political action, including the idea of donnismo as a kind of identity-based political legitimacy, is given special focus. Using a qualitative comparative case study technique, the thesis examines legislative efforts, government policies, and institutional reforms that impact women's rights in Italy and Mexico in addition to document analysis and political discourse analysis. The comparative design makes it possible to evaluate how various ideological orientations, conservative nationalism in Italy and progressive technocratic leadership in Mexico, interact with gender to affect political power and policy results. The study demonstrates that having women in positions of authority does not immediately eliminate structural injustices or provide gender-responsive governance, highlighting the ongoing gap between symbolic political participation and revolutionary policy change. This study adds to the larger discussion on women's political representation by fusing feminist political theory with comparative political analysis and a human rights viewpoint. It shows that significant advancements depend more on the interaction between institutional structures, political ideology, and the dedication to enacting meaningful gender equality policies than on the gender of political leaders. The thesis ends with policy suggestions meant to improve the circumstances in which women's political representation can lead to long-term advancements in women's human rights.
WOMEN'S RIGHTS
GENDERED LEADERSHIP
POLITICS
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
chiara_mastrangelo_2139654.pdf

Accesso riservato

Dimensione 1.18 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.18 MB Adobe PDF

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118189