This dissertation examines the successive periods of abandonment of the Jardin d'agronomie tropicale René-Dumont, on the edge of the Bois de Vincennes and Nogent-sur-Marne, to understand what they reveal about France's administrative, structural and memorial difficulties in owning, managing and transmitting its colonial heritage. Created in 1899 as a scientific tool serving colonial expansion, underfunded and disputed between competing authorities from the outset, the garden accumulated, after the 1907 colonial exhibition, overlapping functions and memories (colonial, military, scientific) that were never 5 articulated into a coherent project: it is this unresolved accumulation that makes each of its abandonments possible, and explains it. Drawing on the geography of abandonment (Le Gallou, Nacef), memory studies (Nora, Bancel and Blanchard, Aldrich), the notion of “difficult heritage” (Macdonald), and primary archives (Archives de Paris, municipal archives of Nogent-sur-Marne, CIRAD historical library) and press sources, this study distinguishes four successive abandonments, each of a different nature : a scientific and institutional abandonment triggered by the First World War (1899-1920) ; a structural and administrative abandonment linked to the entanglement of oversight bodies and the departure of research institutes (1920-1985) ; a properly memorial abandonment corresponding to a “denial of memory” (1985-2002) ; and, since 2002, a rehabilitation that remains partial, merely recomposing abandonment in an attenuated form. The study thus shows that these abandonments are not mere accidents of management, but the recurring symptom of a deeper indecision over what this site is meant to be, and thus over the way French society chooses, or fails to choose, what to do with its imperial past.
Ce mémoire interroge les périodes d'abandon successives du Jardin d'agronomie tropicale René-Dumont, à la lisière du bois de Vincennes et de Nogent-sur-Marne, pour comprendre ce qu'elles révèlent des difficultés administratives, structurelles et mémorielles de la France à assumer, gérer et transmettre son héritage colonial. Créé en 1899 comme outil scientifique au service de l'expansion coloniale, sous-financé et disputé entre plusieurs tutelles dès l'origine, le jardin accumule, après l'exposition coloniale de 1907, des fonctions et des mémoires concurrentes (coloniale, militaire, scientifique) sans jamais parvenir à les articuler dans un projet cohérent : c'est cette accumulation non résolue qui rend possible, et explique, chacun de ses abandons. À partir de la géographie de l'abandon (Le Gallou, Nacef), des études mémorielles (Nora, Bancel et Blanchard, Aldrich), de la notion de “patrimoine difficile” (Macdonald), et d'un corpus d'archives inédites (Archives de Paris, Archives municipales de Nogent-sur-Marne, Bibliothèque historique du CIRAD) et de presse, ce travail distingue quatre abandons successifs, chacun de nature différente : un abandon scientifique et institutionnel amorcé par la Première Guerre mondiale (1899-1920) ; un abandon structurel et administratif, lié à l'enchevêtrement des tutelles et au départ des instituts de recherche (1920-1985) ; un abandon proprement mémoriel, correspondant à un “déni de mémoire” (1985-2002) ; puis, depuis 2002, une réhabilitation engagée mais restée partielle, qui n'a fait que recomposer l'abandon sous une forme atténuée. L'étude montre ainsi que ces abandons ne sont pas de simples accidents de gestion, mais le symptôme récurrent d'une indécision plus profonde sur ce que ce lieu doit être, et donc sur la manière dont la société française choisit, ou s'abstient de choisir, ce qu'elle fait de son passé impérial.
Les temps d'abandon du Jardin d'agronomie tropical René-Dumont
JACQUET, ELEA CARLA GWENN
2025/2026
Abstract
This dissertation examines the successive periods of abandonment of the Jardin d'agronomie tropicale René-Dumont, on the edge of the Bois de Vincennes and Nogent-sur-Marne, to understand what they reveal about France's administrative, structural and memorial difficulties in owning, managing and transmitting its colonial heritage. Created in 1899 as a scientific tool serving colonial expansion, underfunded and disputed between competing authorities from the outset, the garden accumulated, after the 1907 colonial exhibition, overlapping functions and memories (colonial, military, scientific) that were never 5 articulated into a coherent project: it is this unresolved accumulation that makes each of its abandonments possible, and explains it. Drawing on the geography of abandonment (Le Gallou, Nacef), memory studies (Nora, Bancel and Blanchard, Aldrich), the notion of “difficult heritage” (Macdonald), and primary archives (Archives de Paris, municipal archives of Nogent-sur-Marne, CIRAD historical library) and press sources, this study distinguishes four successive abandonments, each of a different nature : a scientific and institutional abandonment triggered by the First World War (1899-1920) ; a structural and administrative abandonment linked to the entanglement of oversight bodies and the departure of research institutes (1920-1985) ; a properly memorial abandonment corresponding to a “denial of memory” (1985-2002) ; and, since 2002, a rehabilitation that remains partial, merely recomposing abandonment in an attenuated form. The study thus shows that these abandonments are not mere accidents of management, but the recurring symptom of a deeper indecision over what this site is meant to be, and thus over the way French society chooses, or fails to choose, what to do with its imperial past.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
JACQUET_EleaCarlaGwenn.pdf
accesso aperto
Descrizione: Les temps d'abandon du Jardin d'agronomie tropical René-Dumont
Dimensione
30.01 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
30.01 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118198