Migrants who graduate from host-country universities hold the same formal credentials as their domestic classmates, and are therefore expected to compete for jobs on comparable terms. This study examines the professional integration of Russian-speaking migrants holding Italian master's degrees in the Italian labour market. By restricting the sample to graduates of Italian universities, credential non-recognition is controlled as a confounding variable, allowing the study to focus on taste-based discrimination as one possible explanatory mechanism. Seventeen semi-structured narrative interviews were conducted with Russian-speaking migrants from Russia, Belarus, and Kazakhstan, and analysed through reflexive thematic analysis with a narrative analytic lens grounded in Career Construction Theory. Results identify six themes: professional status reset, basic security as a prerequisite for job search, structural barriers and internalisation of failure, networking norms, language as a structural gate, identity work and strategic self-presentation. The findings suggest that participants were often unable to determine whether rejection operated through language or national origin, and that they consistently resolved this uncertainty in favour of the explanation they could act on. At the same time, several accounts indicate that formally equivalent qualifications do not by themselves neutralise origin-based exclusion at the point of hiring. This work provides a phenomenological account of taste-based discrimination as experienced from within individual career trajectories, and documents the psychological costs of occupational exclusion for this group.
Migrants who graduate from host-country universities hold the same formal credentials as their domestic classmates, and are therefore expected to compete for jobs on comparable terms. This study examines the professional integration of Russian-speaking migrants holding Italian master's degrees in the Italian labour market. By restricting the sample to graduates of Italian universities, credential non-recognition is controlled as a confounding variable, allowing the study to focus on taste-based discrimination as one possible explanatory mechanism. Seventeen semi-structured narrative interviews were conducted with Russian-speaking migrants from Russia, Belarus, and Kazakhstan, and analysed through reflexive thematic analysis with a narrative analytic lens grounded in Career Construction Theory. Results identify six themes: professional status reset, basic security as a prerequisite for job search, structural barriers and internalisation of failure, networking norms, language as a structural gate, identity work and strategic self-presentation. The findings suggest that participants were often unable to determine whether rejection operated through language or national origin, and that they consistently resolved this uncertainty in favour of the explanation they could act on. At the same time, several accounts indicate that formally equivalent qualifications do not by themselves neutralise origin-based exclusion at the point of hiring. This work provides a phenomenological account of taste-based discrimination as experienced from within individual career trajectories, and documents the psychological costs of occupational exclusion for this group.
Professional Integration of Russian-Speaking Migrants in Italy: Career Construction and Perceived Barriers
GIL, ELENA
2025/2026
Abstract
Migrants who graduate from host-country universities hold the same formal credentials as their domestic classmates, and are therefore expected to compete for jobs on comparable terms. This study examines the professional integration of Russian-speaking migrants holding Italian master's degrees in the Italian labour market. By restricting the sample to graduates of Italian universities, credential non-recognition is controlled as a confounding variable, allowing the study to focus on taste-based discrimination as one possible explanatory mechanism. Seventeen semi-structured narrative interviews were conducted with Russian-speaking migrants from Russia, Belarus, and Kazakhstan, and analysed through reflexive thematic analysis with a narrative analytic lens grounded in Career Construction Theory. Results identify six themes: professional status reset, basic security as a prerequisite for job search, structural barriers and internalisation of failure, networking norms, language as a structural gate, identity work and strategic self-presentation. The findings suggest that participants were often unable to determine whether rejection operated through language or national origin, and that they consistently resolved this uncertainty in favour of the explanation they could act on. At the same time, several accounts indicate that formally equivalent qualifications do not by themselves neutralise origin-based exclusion at the point of hiring. This work provides a phenomenological account of taste-based discrimination as experienced from within individual career trajectories, and documents the psychological costs of occupational exclusion for this group.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Gil_Elena.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
1.11 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.11 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118428