Climate transition in the European automotive sector is simultaneously an industrial transformation and a challenge for reporting. This thesis examines the extent to which ESRS E1 enables external users to assess the informational credibility and completeness of the electric-vehicle transition reported by six major European automotive groups: Volkswagen Group, BMW Group, Mercedes-Benz Group, Stellantis, Renault Group and Volvo Cars. The empirical analysis focuses on FY2025 and on five Disclosure Requirements that follow the transition from strategy to financial consequences: E1-1 (transition plan), E1-3 (actions and resources), E1-4 (targets), E1-6 (GHG emissions) and E1-9 (anticipated financial effects). A scorecard assigns 120 individual scores on a 0–3 scale across four dimensions. Completeness, specificity and comparability assess disclosure quality, while external correspondence is kept analytically separate and examines whether sustainability information is corroborated by other publicly reported financial and operational information, particularly the financial statements. The results indicate that climate disclosure is comparatively mature for transition plans and reported emissions, while greater limitations emerge in the granular connection between individual actions, financial resources and anticipated financial effects. E1-9 is the weakest Disclosure Requirement at sample level, although this result is materially affected by the transitional provisions applicable in FY2025 and should not be interpreted as evidence of non-compliance or of the absence of internal climate-risk assessment. At dimension level, external correspondence is not the weakest aggregate dimension; its contribution lies instead in distinguishing disclosures that appear similar in formal quality but differ in the degree of documentary corroboration available to external users. The main contribution of the thesis is therefore methodological: it operationalises the ESRS principle of connectivity as an analytical criterion. In this sense, “Beyond the Pledge” does not mean proving whether an industrial transition is real in an absolute sense, but moving beyond corporate commitments to assess how completely, specifically, comparably and consistently they are represented and supported across publicly observable corporate reporting.
Climate transition in the European automotive sector is simultaneously an industrial transformation and a challenge for reporting. This thesis examines the extent to which ESRS E1 enables external users to assess the informational credibility and completeness of the electric-vehicle transition reported by six major European automotive groups: Volkswagen Group, BMW Group, Mercedes-Benz Group, Stellantis, Renault Group and Volvo Cars. The empirical analysis focuses on FY2025 and on five Disclosure Requirements that follow the transition from strategy to financial consequences: E1-1 (transition plan), E1-3 (actions and resources), E1-4 (targets), E1-6 (GHG emissions) and E1-9 (anticipated financial effects). A scorecard assigns 120 individual scores on a 0–3 scale across four dimensions. Completeness, specificity and comparability assess disclosure quality, while external correspondence is kept analytically separate and examines whether sustainability information is corroborated by other publicly reported financial and operational information, particularly the financial statements. The results indicate that climate disclosure is comparatively mature for transition plans and reported emissions, while greater limitations emerge in the granular connection between individual actions, financial resources and anticipated financial effects. E1-9 is the weakest Disclosure Requirement at sample level, although this result is materially affected by the transitional provisions applicable in FY2025 and should not be interpreted as evidence of non-compliance or of the absence of internal climate-risk assessment. At dimension level, external correspondence is not the weakest aggregate dimension; its contribution lies instead in distinguishing disclosures that appear similar in formal quality but differ in the degree of documentary corroboration available to external users. The main contribution of the thesis is therefore methodological: it operationalises the ESRS principle of connectivity as an analytical criterion. In this sense, “Beyond the Pledge” does not mean proving whether an industrial transition is real in an absolute sense, but moving beyond corporate commitments to assess how completely, specifically, comparably and consistently they are represented and supported across publicly observable corporate reporting.
Beyond the Pledge: ESRS E1 and the Transition to Electric Vehicles in the European Automotive Industry
FRIZZARIN, FEDERICO
2025/2026
Abstract
Climate transition in the European automotive sector is simultaneously an industrial transformation and a challenge for reporting. This thesis examines the extent to which ESRS E1 enables external users to assess the informational credibility and completeness of the electric-vehicle transition reported by six major European automotive groups: Volkswagen Group, BMW Group, Mercedes-Benz Group, Stellantis, Renault Group and Volvo Cars. The empirical analysis focuses on FY2025 and on five Disclosure Requirements that follow the transition from strategy to financial consequences: E1-1 (transition plan), E1-3 (actions and resources), E1-4 (targets), E1-6 (GHG emissions) and E1-9 (anticipated financial effects). A scorecard assigns 120 individual scores on a 0–3 scale across four dimensions. Completeness, specificity and comparability assess disclosure quality, while external correspondence is kept analytically separate and examines whether sustainability information is corroborated by other publicly reported financial and operational information, particularly the financial statements. The results indicate that climate disclosure is comparatively mature for transition plans and reported emissions, while greater limitations emerge in the granular connection between individual actions, financial resources and anticipated financial effects. E1-9 is the weakest Disclosure Requirement at sample level, although this result is materially affected by the transitional provisions applicable in FY2025 and should not be interpreted as evidence of non-compliance or of the absence of internal climate-risk assessment. At dimension level, external correspondence is not the weakest aggregate dimension; its contribution lies instead in distinguishing disclosures that appear similar in formal quality but differ in the degree of documentary corroboration available to external users. The main contribution of the thesis is therefore methodological: it operationalises the ESRS principle of connectivity as an analytical criterion. In this sense, “Beyond the Pledge” does not mean proving whether an industrial transition is real in an absolute sense, but moving beyond corporate commitments to assess how completely, specifically, comparably and consistently they are represented and supported across publicly observable corporate reporting.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Frizzarin_Federico.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
2.77 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.77 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118879