Every year the Italian Bone Marrow Donor Registry (IBMDR) enrolls tens of thousands of new donors and supports an increasing number of transplants, reflecting the growing clinical reliance on Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation (HSCT). This growth, however, raises Health Economics questions about the sustainability and efficiency of the entire donation pipeline, from donor recruitment and HLA typing to the transplant itself. This thesis asks what explains the wide variation in Confirmatory Typing success rates across Donor Management Centers (DMCs), once the volume of requests is accounted for. Using a panel of 70 DMCs observed over 2017-2025, built from IBMDR records on Confirmatory Typing requests, Work-Up procedures, donor enrollments/discharges and staffing, the success rate is modeled as a binomial proportion through a fixed-effects generalized linear model, complemented by a correlated random effects specification and a set of robustness checks. Among the variables describing how the donor pool is composed, donor age is the only one showing an association with performance in the correlated random effects specification, both within and across centers, although this result does not survive the cluster-level robustness check; center size and gender composition carry little to no signal throughout. The share of donors who transfer to a different center than the one where they originally enrolled emerges as the most robust predictor of lower success, since relocation breaks the contact between the center and the donor without releasing the enrollment cost already incurred. On the operational side, centers with dedicated staff process requests faster and confirm a higher share of them, showing that the network has not scaled its processing capacity at the same pace as demand. Overall, the results suggest that what converts a growing registry into transplants performed is not the size of the donor stock but the quality of the contact each center maintains with the donors it already holds, with direct implications for how staff and resources should be allocated across the network.
Evaluating the Performance of Donor Management Centers: An Economic Analysis of the IBMDR Registry
FALASCO, BEATRICE
2025/2026
Abstract
Every year the Italian Bone Marrow Donor Registry (IBMDR) enrolls tens of thousands of new donors and supports an increasing number of transplants, reflecting the growing clinical reliance on Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation (HSCT). This growth, however, raises Health Economics questions about the sustainability and efficiency of the entire donation pipeline, from donor recruitment and HLA typing to the transplant itself. This thesis asks what explains the wide variation in Confirmatory Typing success rates across Donor Management Centers (DMCs), once the volume of requests is accounted for. Using a panel of 70 DMCs observed over 2017-2025, built from IBMDR records on Confirmatory Typing requests, Work-Up procedures, donor enrollments/discharges and staffing, the success rate is modeled as a binomial proportion through a fixed-effects generalized linear model, complemented by a correlated random effects specification and a set of robustness checks. Among the variables describing how the donor pool is composed, donor age is the only one showing an association with performance in the correlated random effects specification, both within and across centers, although this result does not survive the cluster-level robustness check; center size and gender composition carry little to no signal throughout. The share of donors who transfer to a different center than the one where they originally enrolled emerges as the most robust predictor of lower success, since relocation breaks the contact between the center and the donor without releasing the enrollment cost already incurred. On the operational side, centers with dedicated staff process requests faster and confirm a higher share of them, showing that the network has not scaled its processing capacity at the same pace as demand. Overall, the results suggest that what converts a growing registry into transplants performed is not the size of the donor stock but the quality of the contact each center maintains with the donors it already holds, with direct implications for how staff and resources should be allocated across the network.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Falasco_Beatrice.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
3.91 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
3.91 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118954