During the 2010s, traditional left-wing parties in Western Europe and North America witnessed their vote shares fall, in some cases by large margins and seemingly irreversibly. Coincidently, right-wing populist parties emerged as major political forces, gaining considerable ground or coming into power. Particularly in the media, these two phenomena have been attributed to working-class voters shifting away from the traditional left towards the populist right. Yet, a consensus on the reasons behind this phenomenon is still missing. This thesis has a twofold purpose: to verify whether such electoral shift did indeed happen, and to highlight the economic drivers behind it. First, using regional electoral outcomes and national post-election surveys, this thesis confirms the occurrence of a significant (although uneven) electoral shift from the traditional left to the populist right among working-class voters in France, Britain and the United States in the late-2010s. Second, based on Shayo (2009)’s model of social identity, this thesis explains such electoral shift in terms of identity politics. In this regard, working-class voters in France, Britain and the United States were adversely affected by a combination of different economic factors, namely economic crises; immigration; globalization; deindustrialization and tertiarization; rising income and wealth inequality; and declining trade union membership. Consequently, they switched from a class identity to a national identity, changing their policy preferences and shifting their vote from the traditional left-wing parties to the right-wing populist parties. In this way, this thesis contributes to the strand of research emphasizing economic factors as the primary drivers of support for right-wing populism.
During the 2010s, traditional left-wing parties in Western Europe and North America witnessed their vote shares fall, in some cases by large margins and seemingly irreversibly. Coincidently, right-wing populist parties emerged as major political forces, gaining considerable ground or coming into power. Particularly in the media, these two phenomena have been attributed to working-class voters shifting away from the traditional left towards the populist right. Yet, a consensus on the reasons behind this phenomenon is still missing. This thesis has a twofold purpose: to verify whether such electoral shift did indeed happen, and to highlight the economic drivers behind it. First, using regional electoral outcomes and national post-election surveys, this thesis confirms the occurrence of a significant (although uneven) electoral shift from the traditional left to the populist right among working-class voters in France, Britain and the United States in the late-2010s. Second, based on Shayo (2009)’s model of social identity, this thesis explains such electoral shift in terms of identity politics. In this regard, working-class voters in France, Britain and the United States were adversely affected by a combination of different economic factors, namely economic crises; immigration; globalization; deindustrialization and tertiarization; rising income and wealth inequality; and declining trade union membership. Consequently, they switched from a class identity to a national identity, changing their policy preferences and shifting their vote from the traditional left-wing parties to the right-wing populist parties. In this way, this thesis contributes to the strand of research emphasizing economic factors as the primary drivers of support for right-wing populism.
Slide to the right: the economic roots of the electoral shift from the traditional left to the populist right among working-class voters in Western democracies
NADALINI, LORENZO
2025/2026
Abstract
During the 2010s, traditional left-wing parties in Western Europe and North America witnessed their vote shares fall, in some cases by large margins and seemingly irreversibly. Coincidently, right-wing populist parties emerged as major political forces, gaining considerable ground or coming into power. Particularly in the media, these two phenomena have been attributed to working-class voters shifting away from the traditional left towards the populist right. Yet, a consensus on the reasons behind this phenomenon is still missing. This thesis has a twofold purpose: to verify whether such electoral shift did indeed happen, and to highlight the economic drivers behind it. First, using regional electoral outcomes and national post-election surveys, this thesis confirms the occurrence of a significant (although uneven) electoral shift from the traditional left to the populist right among working-class voters in France, Britain and the United States in the late-2010s. Second, based on Shayo (2009)’s model of social identity, this thesis explains such electoral shift in terms of identity politics. In this regard, working-class voters in France, Britain and the United States were adversely affected by a combination of different economic factors, namely economic crises; immigration; globalization; deindustrialization and tertiarization; rising income and wealth inequality; and declining trade union membership. Consequently, they switched from a class identity to a national identity, changing their policy preferences and shifting their vote from the traditional left-wing parties to the right-wing populist parties. In this way, this thesis contributes to the strand of research emphasizing economic factors as the primary drivers of support for right-wing populism.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Nadalini_Lorenzo.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
7.84 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
7.84 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118994