The conformity control process constitutes a fundamental stage of the construction process, as it enables verification of the correspondence between what is specified in the design (As Designed) and what is constructed (As Built). In current practice, this activity is still predominantly conducted through manual inspections, based on visual assessments, and point measurements, which may be affected by operator variability and provide only limited coverage of the elements being inspected. This thesis investigates the potential of computational tools to support on-site Quality Check, with reference to the geometric comparison between the As Designed BIM model and the As Built point cloud. The objective is to assess how the integration of BIM, three-dimensional surveying, and Scan-to-BIM procedures can improve the detection, quantification, and traceability of geometric deviations compared with traditional manual inspection methods. The research combines a review of the scientific literature with an experimental application to a case study involving airport infrastructure, analysed from the perspective of the General Contractor. The developed workflow includes data preparation and verification, registration between the BIM model and the point cloud, selection of the elements to be inspected, geometric deviation analysis, and comparison with specific acceptance criteria. The methodology was applied to both structural and MEP elements to assess its effectiveness under different geometric and data acquisition conditions. The results show that the computational approach enables quantitative and traceable information to be obtained regarding deviations between the designed and surveyed conditions, while also highlighting critical issues related to point cloud quality, georeferencing, and the reliability of the As Designed models. The research therefore demonstrates how these tools can provide effective support for the decision-making process without replacing the final technical assessment. Looking ahead, the implementation of progressive digital workflows during construction may contribute to improving the efficiency and continuity of on-site conformity control.
Il controllo di conformità costituisce una fase fondamentale del processo costruttivo, poiché consente di verificare la corrispondenza tra quanto previsto dal progetto (As Designed) e quanto effettivamente realizzato (As Built). Nella pratica corrente, tale attività viene ancora svolta prevalentemente mediante controlli manuali, basati su ispezioni visive e misurazioni puntuali, che possono risultare soggetti alla variabilità dell’operatore e caratterizzati da una limitata completezza delle verifiche. La presente tesi analizza il potenziale degli strumenti computazionali a supporto del Quality Check in cantiere, con particolare riferimento al controllo geometrico tra modello BIM As Designed e nuvola di punti As Built. L’obiettivo è valutare in che modo l’integrazione tra BIM, rilievo tridimensionale e procedure Scan-to-BIM possa migliorare l’individuazione, la quantificazione e la tracciabilità degli scostamenti rispetto ai tradizionali metodi di controllo manuale. La ricerca combina una revisione della letteratura scientifica con una sperimentazione applicata a un caso studio relativo a un’infrastruttura aeroportuale, analizzato dal punto di vista del General Contractor. Il workflow sviluppato comprende la preparazione e verifica dei dati, la registrazione tra modello e nuvola di punti, la selezione degli elementi da controllare, l’analisi geometrica degli scostamenti e il confronto con specifici criteri di accettabilità. La metodologia è stata applicata a elementi strutturali e MEP, al fine di valutarne l’efficacia in differenti condizioni geometriche e di acquisizione. I risultati evidenziano come l’approccio computazionale permetta di ottenere informazioni quantitative e tracciabili sugli scostamenti tra stato progettato e stato rilevato, evidenziando al contempo criticità legate alla qualità della nuvola di punti, alla georeferenziazione e all’affidabilità dei modelli As Designed. La ricerca mostra pertanto come tali strumenti possano costituire un supporto efficace al processo decisionale, senza sostituire la valutazione tecnica finale. In prospettiva futura, l’impiego di workflow digitali progressivi durante l’esecuzione dei lavori può contribuire a migliorare l’efficienza e la continuità del controllo di conformità in cantiere.
Quality Check computazionale nel settore delle costruzioni: metodologie e strumenti per il controllo di conformità As Designed - As Built per il General Contractor
BASSO, MARTINA
2025/2026
Abstract
The conformity control process constitutes a fundamental stage of the construction process, as it enables verification of the correspondence between what is specified in the design (As Designed) and what is constructed (As Built). In current practice, this activity is still predominantly conducted through manual inspections, based on visual assessments, and point measurements, which may be affected by operator variability and provide only limited coverage of the elements being inspected. This thesis investigates the potential of computational tools to support on-site Quality Check, with reference to the geometric comparison between the As Designed BIM model and the As Built point cloud. The objective is to assess how the integration of BIM, three-dimensional surveying, and Scan-to-BIM procedures can improve the detection, quantification, and traceability of geometric deviations compared with traditional manual inspection methods. The research combines a review of the scientific literature with an experimental application to a case study involving airport infrastructure, analysed from the perspective of the General Contractor. The developed workflow includes data preparation and verification, registration between the BIM model and the point cloud, selection of the elements to be inspected, geometric deviation analysis, and comparison with specific acceptance criteria. The methodology was applied to both structural and MEP elements to assess its effectiveness under different geometric and data acquisition conditions. The results show that the computational approach enables quantitative and traceable information to be obtained regarding deviations between the designed and surveyed conditions, while also highlighting critical issues related to point cloud quality, georeferencing, and the reliability of the As Designed models. The research therefore demonstrates how these tools can provide effective support for the decision-making process without replacing the final technical assessment. Looking ahead, the implementation of progressive digital workflows during construction may contribute to improving the efficiency and continuity of on-site conformity control.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Basso_Martina.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
5.83 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
5.83 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/119089