Abstract Objective: To compare functional outcomes and postoperative urinary symptoms following Aquablation and holmium laser enucleation of the prostate (HoLEP), with particular emphasis on storage symptoms and continence. Materials and methods: A non-randomized comparative study based on a retrospective review of 208 prospectively followed patients who underwent Aquablation (n = 93) or HoLEP (n = 115). Perioperative parameters, complications, and functional outcomes at three months were assessed using IPSS, QoL, ICIQ-OAB, ICIQ-MLUTS, maximum urinary flow rate, and postvoid residual volume. Results: Both procedures showed descriptive improvements in voiding parameters compared with baseline. At three months, Aquablation was associated with lower IPSS, QoL, ICIQ-OAB, and ICIQ-MLUTS scores (all p < 0.0001), with lower rates of urgency (25.81% versus 53.04%) and urgency urinary incontinence (0% versus 26.09%). Early stress urinary incontinence was observed exclusively in the HoLEP group (20.87%). Mean operative time was shorter with Aquablation (38.42 versus 56.84 minutes). No statistically significant differences were found in postvoid residual volume, urinary tract infections, clot retention, or transfusions; catheterization duration and length of hospital stay were identical in both groups. Conclusions: In the cohort analyzed, Aquablation was associated with a more favorable urinary symptom profile at three months compared with HoLEP. The non-randomized design, and short follow-up warrant confirmation through controlled comparative studies and long-term follow-up.
Abstract Obiettivo: Confrontare gli esiti funzionali e i sintomi urinari postoperatori dopo Aquablation ed enucleazione prostatica con laser a olmio (HoLEP), con particolare attenzione ai sintomi di riempimento e alla continenza. Materiali e metodi: Studio comparativo non randomizzato, condotto mediante revisione retrospettiva di 208 pazienti seguiti prospetticamente, sottoposti ad Aquablation (n = 93) o HoLEP (n = 115). Sono stati valutati parametri perioperatori, complicanze ed esiti funzionali a tre mesi, mediante IPSS, QoL, ICIQ-OAB, ICIQ-MLUTS, flusso urinario massimo e residuo postminzionale. Risultati: Entrambe le procedure hanno mostrato un miglioramento descrittivo dei parametri minzionali rispetto al basale. A tre mesi, Aquablation era associata a punteggi inferiori di IPSS, QoL, ICIQ-OAB e ICIQ-MLUTS (tutti p < 0,0001), con minore frequenza di urgenza (25,81% contro 53,04%) e incontinenza da urgenza (0% contro 26,09%). L’incontinenza da sforzo precoce era rilevata esclusivamente nel gruppo HoLEP (20,87%). Il tempo operatorio medio era inferiore con Aquablation (38,42 contro 56,84 minuti). Non emergevano differenze significative nel residuo postminzionale, nelle infezioni urinarie, nella ritenzione da coaguli e nelle trasfusioni; cateterizzazione e degenza avevano uguale durata. Conclusioni: Nella coorte analizzata, Aquablation era associata a un profilo sintomatologico più favorevole a tre mesi rispetto a HoLEP. Il disegno non randomizzato e il breve follow-up richiedono conferma mediante studi comparativi controllati e osservazioni a lungo termine.
HOLEP VERSUS AQUABLATION: STUDIO COMPARATIVO DEI RISULTATI POSTOPERATORI IN 208 PAZIENTI
SERBIA, MARCO
2024/2025
Abstract
Abstract Objective: To compare functional outcomes and postoperative urinary symptoms following Aquablation and holmium laser enucleation of the prostate (HoLEP), with particular emphasis on storage symptoms and continence. Materials and methods: A non-randomized comparative study based on a retrospective review of 208 prospectively followed patients who underwent Aquablation (n = 93) or HoLEP (n = 115). Perioperative parameters, complications, and functional outcomes at three months were assessed using IPSS, QoL, ICIQ-OAB, ICIQ-MLUTS, maximum urinary flow rate, and postvoid residual volume. Results: Both procedures showed descriptive improvements in voiding parameters compared with baseline. At three months, Aquablation was associated with lower IPSS, QoL, ICIQ-OAB, and ICIQ-MLUTS scores (all p < 0.0001), with lower rates of urgency (25.81% versus 53.04%) and urgency urinary incontinence (0% versus 26.09%). Early stress urinary incontinence was observed exclusively in the HoLEP group (20.87%). Mean operative time was shorter with Aquablation (38.42 versus 56.84 minutes). No statistically significant differences were found in postvoid residual volume, urinary tract infections, clot retention, or transfusions; catheterization duration and length of hospital stay were identical in both groups. Conclusions: In the cohort analyzed, Aquablation was associated with a more favorable urinary symptom profile at three months compared with HoLEP. The non-randomized design, and short follow-up warrant confirmation through controlled comparative studies and long-term follow-up.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tesi_Marco_Serbia_PDFA.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
1.07 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.07 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/119597