Background:Hypospadias is one of the most common congenital malformations in males, and its surgical treatment aims to achieve a cosmetic and functional result as close to normal as possible. Outcome assessment is often based solely on the surgeon’s judgement and on short-term follow-up. This study evaluated the long-term outcomes of patients who underwent hypospadias repair at our centre, considering complications, anatomical outcome, voiding function, and the perspective of patients and their families together. Methods: This is a single-centre study with retrospective identification of the cohort, followed by a single follow-up reassessment of the patients who agreed to participate. In the 225 patients operated on between 2009 and 2024 at the Paediatric Surgery Unit of Santa Chiara Hospital, Trento, we analysed complications, classified according to the Sydney Hypospadias Outcome Complication (SHOC) score, and their associated factors, including age at first surgery. Participating patients (n = 74) were reassessed with the HOPE and HOSE anatomical scores, uroflowmetry, and the patient and parent satisfaction questionnaires (PPPS and PPS). Parental decision regret was also assessed using the Decision Regret Scale (DRS), and erectile function was assessed with the IIEF-5 in older patients. Results: In the overall cohort, 38% of patients had at least one complication, with a clear gradient according to severity: 34% in distal, 57% in midshaft and 71% in proximal forms. Proximal hypospadias was the only factor independently associated with complications. Age at first surgery was not associated with complications; however, complications were less frequent in patients operated on after 48 months of age, and none of them required more than one reintervention. The reassessed cohort included 74 patients. Overall, 80% of patients and 73% of parents reported being satisfied. HOSE was satisfactory in 84% of patients, whereas an optimal HOPE score was achieved in only 24%; neither HOPE nor HOSE discriminated between satisfied and non-satisfied patients. Urinary flow showed an increasing trend with age: an obstructed flow was found in 50% of children younger than 8 years and in 4% of those older than 12 years, and it persisted more often in patients with previous neourethral stenosis or non-distal forms. Obstructed flow was asymptomatic in 44% of cases and was associated with neither anatomical outcome nor satisfaction. Moderate-to-strong regret was reported by 30% of parents; it was more frequent in proximal forms and after complications, but was not related to the final outcome. Erectile function appeared preserved in 5 of the 6 patients aged 17–23 years who completed the IIEF-5. Discussion and conclusions: The severity of hypospadias is the main determinant of the surgical pathway. The surgeon’s and the family’s assessments measure different aspects: satisfaction is high despite frequent cosmetic imperfections and is not explained by clinical scores. Flow obstruction tends to resolve with growth, may be clinically silent, and cannot be detected either by physical examination or by the family’s perception. Parental regret appears to be related more to the treatment pathway experienced than to the final outcome. These findings support a multidimensional follow-up extended into post-pubertal age. On this basis, we propose a standardised follow-up protocol to be adopted at our centre.
Introduzione: L’ipospadia è una delle malformazioni congenite più frequenti nel maschio e il suo trattamento chirurgico ha l’obiettivo di ottenere un risultato estetico e funzionale che si avvicini il più possibile alla normalità. La valutazione degli esiti si basa spesso sul solo giudizio del chirurgo e su follow-up brevi. Questo studio ha valutato a lungo termine i pazienti operati di ipospadia presso il nostro centro, considerando insieme le complicanze, il risultato anatomico, la funzione minzionale e il punto di vista di pazienti e famiglie. Materiali e metodi: Studio monocentrico con identificazione retrospettiva della coorte e una seconda parte composta da una valutazione ex post dei pazienti che hanno aderito alo studio. Nei 225 pazienti operati tra il 2009 e il 2024 presso la Chirurgia Pediatrica dell’Ospedale Santa Chiara di Trento sono state analizzate le complicanze, classificate secondo lo score SHOC, e i fattori associati, tra cui l’età al primo intervento. I pazienti aderenti (74) sono stati rivalutati con gli score anatomici HOPE e HOSE, l’uroflussometria e i questionari di soddisfazione di pazienti e genitori PPPS e PPS. Sono stati inoltre raccolti la scala del rimpianto decisionale dei genitori (DRS) e, nei pazienti più grandi, l’IIEF-5 che valuta la presenza di eventuale disfunzione erettile. Risultati: Nella coorte totale il 38% dei pazienti ha presentato almeno una complicanza, con un gradiente netto in base alla gravità: 34% nelle forme distali, 57% nelle medio-peniene e 71% nelle prossimali. La forma prossimale è risultata l’unico fattore associato in modo indipendente alle complicanze. L’età al primo intervento non è risultata associata alle complicanze, ma nei pazienti operati dopo i 48 mesi le complicanze sono state meno frequenti e nessuno ha richiesto più di un intervento. Per quanto riguarda la coorte aderente, è risultata di 74 pazienti. Si sono dichiarati soddisfatti l’80% dei pazienti e il 73% dei genitori. L’HOSE è risultato soddisfacente nell’84% dei pazienti, mentre un HOPE ottimale è stato raggiunto solo dal 24%; né l’HOPE né l’HOSE permettevano di distinguere i soddisfatti dai non soddisfatti. Il flusso urinario è risultato avere un trend in aumento in associazione all’età: il flusso ostruito era presente nel 50% dei bambini sotto gli 8 anni e nel 4% dopo i 12, e persisteva più spesso in pazienti con pregresse stenosi della neouretra o nelle forme non distali. Nel 44% dei casi il flusso ostruito è risultato asintomatico, e non associato né al risultato anatomico né alla soddisfazione. Il 30% dei genitori ha riportato un rimpianto moderato-forte, più frequente nelle forme prossimali e dopo complicanze, ma non legato al risultato finale. La funzione erettile è apparsa conservata in 5 dei 6 pazienti tra 17 e 23 anni che hanno compilato l’IIEF-5. Discussione e conclusioni: La gravità della forma è il principale determinante del percorso chirurgico. Il giudizio del chirurgo e quello della famiglia misurano aspetti diversi: la soddisfazione è elevata nonostante imperfezioni estetiche frequenti, e non è spiegata dagli score clinici. L’ostruzione del flusso tende a risolversi con la crescita, può essere non clinicamente rilevante e non si riconosce né dall’esame obiettivo né dalla percezione della famiglia. Il rimpianto dei genitori sembra legato più al percorso vissuto che al risultato ottenuto. I risultati supportano un follow-up multidimensionale e prolungato fino all’età post-puberale. Su questa base proponiamo un protocollo di follow-up che utilizzeremo presso il nostro centro.
IPOSPADIA: VALUTAZIONE INTEGRATA DEGLI ESITI FUNZIONALI, ESTETICI E PSICOSOCIALI
VARNER, FEDERICA
2024/2025
Abstract
Background:Hypospadias is one of the most common congenital malformations in males, and its surgical treatment aims to achieve a cosmetic and functional result as close to normal as possible. Outcome assessment is often based solely on the surgeon’s judgement and on short-term follow-up. This study evaluated the long-term outcomes of patients who underwent hypospadias repair at our centre, considering complications, anatomical outcome, voiding function, and the perspective of patients and their families together. Methods: This is a single-centre study with retrospective identification of the cohort, followed by a single follow-up reassessment of the patients who agreed to participate. In the 225 patients operated on between 2009 and 2024 at the Paediatric Surgery Unit of Santa Chiara Hospital, Trento, we analysed complications, classified according to the Sydney Hypospadias Outcome Complication (SHOC) score, and their associated factors, including age at first surgery. Participating patients (n = 74) were reassessed with the HOPE and HOSE anatomical scores, uroflowmetry, and the patient and parent satisfaction questionnaires (PPPS and PPS). Parental decision regret was also assessed using the Decision Regret Scale (DRS), and erectile function was assessed with the IIEF-5 in older patients. Results: In the overall cohort, 38% of patients had at least one complication, with a clear gradient according to severity: 34% in distal, 57% in midshaft and 71% in proximal forms. Proximal hypospadias was the only factor independently associated with complications. Age at first surgery was not associated with complications; however, complications were less frequent in patients operated on after 48 months of age, and none of them required more than one reintervention. The reassessed cohort included 74 patients. Overall, 80% of patients and 73% of parents reported being satisfied. HOSE was satisfactory in 84% of patients, whereas an optimal HOPE score was achieved in only 24%; neither HOPE nor HOSE discriminated between satisfied and non-satisfied patients. Urinary flow showed an increasing trend with age: an obstructed flow was found in 50% of children younger than 8 years and in 4% of those older than 12 years, and it persisted more often in patients with previous neourethral stenosis or non-distal forms. Obstructed flow was asymptomatic in 44% of cases and was associated with neither anatomical outcome nor satisfaction. Moderate-to-strong regret was reported by 30% of parents; it was more frequent in proximal forms and after complications, but was not related to the final outcome. Erectile function appeared preserved in 5 of the 6 patients aged 17–23 years who completed the IIEF-5. Discussion and conclusions: The severity of hypospadias is the main determinant of the surgical pathway. The surgeon’s and the family’s assessments measure different aspects: satisfaction is high despite frequent cosmetic imperfections and is not explained by clinical scores. Flow obstruction tends to resolve with growth, may be clinically silent, and cannot be detected either by physical examination or by the family’s perception. Parental regret appears to be related more to the treatment pathway experienced than to the final outcome. These findings support a multidimensional follow-up extended into post-pubertal age. On this basis, we propose a standardised follow-up protocol to be adopted at our centre.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Varner_Federica.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
2.53 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.53 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/119988