The European Union’s approach towards policymaking is evidence-based, but not exclusively. An appropriate mixing of scientific and political inputs is believed to be the right recipe to achieve the most efficient and effective policy outcomes. In this dissertation, an in-depth analysis of the former aspect takes place, exploring the role and the influence that expertise and experts exert in relation to policymaking at the European level. An introduction serves to contextualize the subject and to draw an appropriate framework of the current structure of experts within the decisional bodies of the Union: the European Parliament, the European Commission and the European Council. An analytical study of the abovementioned structure will follow with reference to the advisory system of the main technical body, the European Commission. As case study, the high-level expert group on artificial intelligence was selected due to the crucial role it has been playing in the European policymaking process in the field of artificial intelligence. The strict connection with the current ethical, social and security issues caused by the introduction of AI on the global market highlights the need for a wide societal consultation and science-based legislation, which is represented by the present case study in the context of the European Union. The aim of the dissertation is to clarify analytically if, how, when and to what extent expert groups influence EU policymaking. An extended literature review allowed to build a comprehensive framework and to obtain valid and reliable data in order to derive the most innovative and controversial aspects of the discussed topic.

The European Union’s approach towards policymaking is evidence-based, but not exclusively. An appropriate mixing of scientific and political inputs is believed to be the right recipe to achieve the most efficient and effective policy outcomes. In this dissertation, an in-depth analysis of the former aspect takes place, exploring the role and the influence that expertise and experts exert in relation to policymaking at the European level. An introduction serves to contextualize the subject and to draw an appropriate framework of the current structure of experts within the decisional bodies of the Union: the European Parliament, the European Commission and the European Council. An analytical study of the abovementioned structure will follow with reference to the advisory system of the main technical body, the European Commission. As case study, the high-level expert group on artificial intelligence was selected due to the crucial role it has been playing in the European policymaking process in the field of artificial intelligence. The strict connection with the current ethical, social and security issues caused by the introduction of AI on the global market highlights the need for a wide societal consultation and science-based legislation, which is represented by the present case study in the context of the European Union. The aim of the dissertation is to clarify analytically if, how, when and to what extent expert groups influence EU policymaking. An extended literature review allowed to build a comprehensive framework and to obtain valid and reliable data in order to derive the most innovative and controversial aspects of the discussed topic.

THE ROLE OF EXPERTS IN THE DECISION-MAKING PROCESS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION High-level expert group on artificial intelligence (AI HLEG) as key actor

ZARA, FRANCESCO
2023/2024

Abstract

The European Union’s approach towards policymaking is evidence-based, but not exclusively. An appropriate mixing of scientific and political inputs is believed to be the right recipe to achieve the most efficient and effective policy outcomes. In this dissertation, an in-depth analysis of the former aspect takes place, exploring the role and the influence that expertise and experts exert in relation to policymaking at the European level. An introduction serves to contextualize the subject and to draw an appropriate framework of the current structure of experts within the decisional bodies of the Union: the European Parliament, the European Commission and the European Council. An analytical study of the abovementioned structure will follow with reference to the advisory system of the main technical body, the European Commission. As case study, the high-level expert group on artificial intelligence was selected due to the crucial role it has been playing in the European policymaking process in the field of artificial intelligence. The strict connection with the current ethical, social and security issues caused by the introduction of AI on the global market highlights the need for a wide societal consultation and science-based legislation, which is represented by the present case study in the context of the European Union. The aim of the dissertation is to clarify analytically if, how, when and to what extent expert groups influence EU policymaking. An extended literature review allowed to build a comprehensive framework and to obtain valid and reliable data in order to derive the most innovative and controversial aspects of the discussed topic.
2023
THE ROLE OF EXPERTS IN THE DECISION-MAKING PROCESS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION High-level expert group on artificial intelligence (AI HLEG) as key actor
The European Union’s approach towards policymaking is evidence-based, but not exclusively. An appropriate mixing of scientific and political inputs is believed to be the right recipe to achieve the most efficient and effective policy outcomes. In this dissertation, an in-depth analysis of the former aspect takes place, exploring the role and the influence that expertise and experts exert in relation to policymaking at the European level. An introduction serves to contextualize the subject and to draw an appropriate framework of the current structure of experts within the decisional bodies of the Union: the European Parliament, the European Commission and the European Council. An analytical study of the abovementioned structure will follow with reference to the advisory system of the main technical body, the European Commission. As case study, the high-level expert group on artificial intelligence was selected due to the crucial role it has been playing in the European policymaking process in the field of artificial intelligence. The strict connection with the current ethical, social and security issues caused by the introduction of AI on the global market highlights the need for a wide societal consultation and science-based legislation, which is represented by the present case study in the context of the European Union. The aim of the dissertation is to clarify analytically if, how, when and to what extent expert groups influence EU policymaking. An extended literature review allowed to build a comprehensive framework and to obtain valid and reliable data in order to derive the most innovative and controversial aspects of the discussed topic.
European Governance
Expertise
AI
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
TESI FINAL ZARA.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 2.62 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
2.62 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/62165