This thesis examines child sex trafficking as a modern form of slavery, focusing on the gap between international legal standards and their implementation at the national level. Despite comprehensive international and regional frameworks prohibiting child sexual exploitation and trafficking, significant shortcomings persist in practice, leaving many minors vulnerable to abuse and exploitation. Through a comparative legal analysis, the research explores two emblematic case studies - the Rotherham abuse scandal in the United Kingdom and the Epstein and Nassar cases in the United States - to highlight recurring patterns of systemic failure, impunity, and institutional neglect. The study aims to identify the legal and structural factors that enable such crimes to continue despite existing obligations under human rights law. Special attention will be given to the principle of state responsibility and due diligence, as well as the challenges posed by transnational criminal networks and cultural or institutional barriers that undermine enforcement. By bridging legal analysis with real-world examples, the thesis seeks to shed light on how international commitments often fall short in practice, and to reflect on possible reforms to strengthen accountability, victim protection, and prevention in line with human rights standards.

This thesis examines child sex trafficking as a modern form of slavery, focusing on the gap between international legal standards and their implementation at the national level. Despite comprehensive international and regional frameworks prohibiting child sexual exploitation and trafficking, significant shortcomings persist in practice, leaving many minors vulnerable to abuse and exploitation. Through a comparative legal analysis, the research explores two emblematic case studies - the Rotherham abuse scandal in the United Kingdom and the Epstein and Nassar cases in the United States - to highlight recurring patterns of systemic failure, impunity, and institutional neglect. The study aims to identify the legal and structural factors that enable such crimes to continue despite existing obligations under human rights law. Special attention will be given to the principle of state responsibility and due diligence, as well as the challenges posed by transnational criminal networks and cultural or institutional barriers that undermine enforcement. By bridging legal analysis with real-world examples, the thesis seeks to shed light on how international commitments often fall short in practice, and to reflect on possible reforms to strengthen accountability, victim protection, and prevention in line with human rights standards.

Child Sex Trafficking as Modern Slavery: The Gap Between Global Norms and Domestic Implementation

FERRARA, MARIAGIOVANNA
2024/2025

Abstract

This thesis examines child sex trafficking as a modern form of slavery, focusing on the gap between international legal standards and their implementation at the national level. Despite comprehensive international and regional frameworks prohibiting child sexual exploitation and trafficking, significant shortcomings persist in practice, leaving many minors vulnerable to abuse and exploitation. Through a comparative legal analysis, the research explores two emblematic case studies - the Rotherham abuse scandal in the United Kingdom and the Epstein and Nassar cases in the United States - to highlight recurring patterns of systemic failure, impunity, and institutional neglect. The study aims to identify the legal and structural factors that enable such crimes to continue despite existing obligations under human rights law. Special attention will be given to the principle of state responsibility and due diligence, as well as the challenges posed by transnational criminal networks and cultural or institutional barriers that undermine enforcement. By bridging legal analysis with real-world examples, the thesis seeks to shed light on how international commitments often fall short in practice, and to reflect on possible reforms to strengthen accountability, victim protection, and prevention in line with human rights standards.
2024
Child Sex Trafficking as Modern Slavery: The Gap Between Global Norms and Domestic Implementation
This thesis examines child sex trafficking as a modern form of slavery, focusing on the gap between international legal standards and their implementation at the national level. Despite comprehensive international and regional frameworks prohibiting child sexual exploitation and trafficking, significant shortcomings persist in practice, leaving many minors vulnerable to abuse and exploitation. Through a comparative legal analysis, the research explores two emblematic case studies - the Rotherham abuse scandal in the United Kingdom and the Epstein and Nassar cases in the United States - to highlight recurring patterns of systemic failure, impunity, and institutional neglect. The study aims to identify the legal and structural factors that enable such crimes to continue despite existing obligations under human rights law. Special attention will be given to the principle of state responsibility and due diligence, as well as the challenges posed by transnational criminal networks and cultural or institutional barriers that undermine enforcement. By bridging legal analysis with real-world examples, the thesis seeks to shed light on how international commitments often fall short in practice, and to reflect on possible reforms to strengthen accountability, victim protection, and prevention in line with human rights standards.
sex trafficking
modern slavery
human rights law
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Ferrara_Mariagiovanna.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 449.67 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
449.67 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/98689