Biodiversity decline is intensifying worldwide, with many fish species becoming critically endangered by factors derived from anthropogenic threats. These issues—paired with insufficient results in the establishment of protected areas and traditional captive breeding programs—call for the employment of streamlined interventions, through the use of assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs). ARTs, including artificial fertilization (AF) and artificial insemination (AI), offer promising outcomes for the conservation of endangered fishes by enhancing reproductive capabilities and genetic management. However, their application often raise ethical concerns. This study aims to address the ethical issues in AI and AF use in fish conservation through a literature review guided by the ETHAS framework (de Mori et al., 2024) —designed for ethical analysis in vertebrate conservation projects, addressing four ethical dimensions: environmental, animal welfare, social, and research ethics. Overall, the analysis revealed multidimensional ethical issues, the main issues include the animal welfare during the procedure, conservation risk in valuable genetic material handling,, and lack of standardized methodological rigor. Social ethics emerged as the most ignored category for the lack of involvement of communities in the studies. ARTs offer outstanding advantages regarding fish conservation, however a consistent ethical monitoring for its application needs to be applied for their optimal use.

Biodiversity decline is intensifying worldwide, with many fish species becoming critically endangered by factors derived from anthropogenic threats. These issues—paired with insufficient results in the establishment of protected areas and traditional captive breeding programs—call for the employment of streamlined interventions, through the use of assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs). ARTs, including artificial fertilization (AF) and artificial insemination (AI), offer promising outcomes for the conservation of endangered fishes by enhancing reproductive capabilities and genetic management. However, their application often raise ethical concerns. This study aims to address the ethical issues in AI and AF use in fish conservation through a literature review guided by the ETHAS framework (de Mori et al., 2024) —designed for ethical analysis in vertebrate conservation projects, addressing four ethical dimensions: environmental, animal welfare, social, and research ethics. Overall, the analysis revealed multidimensional ethical issues, the main issues include the animal welfare during the procedure, conservation risk in valuable genetic material handling,, and lack of standardized methodological rigor. Social ethics emerged as the most ignored category for the lack of involvement of communities in the studies. ARTs offer outstanding advantages regarding fish conservation, however a consistent ethical monitoring for its application needs to be applied for their optimal use.

Ethical analysis of Artificial Insemination (AI) and Fertilization (AF) in fish conservation breeding programs

PARISE, NOEL
2025/2026

Abstract

Biodiversity decline is intensifying worldwide, with many fish species becoming critically endangered by factors derived from anthropogenic threats. These issues—paired with insufficient results in the establishment of protected areas and traditional captive breeding programs—call for the employment of streamlined interventions, through the use of assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs). ARTs, including artificial fertilization (AF) and artificial insemination (AI), offer promising outcomes for the conservation of endangered fishes by enhancing reproductive capabilities and genetic management. However, their application often raise ethical concerns. This study aims to address the ethical issues in AI and AF use in fish conservation through a literature review guided by the ETHAS framework (de Mori et al., 2024) —designed for ethical analysis in vertebrate conservation projects, addressing four ethical dimensions: environmental, animal welfare, social, and research ethics. Overall, the analysis revealed multidimensional ethical issues, the main issues include the animal welfare during the procedure, conservation risk in valuable genetic material handling,, and lack of standardized methodological rigor. Social ethics emerged as the most ignored category for the lack of involvement of communities in the studies. ARTs offer outstanding advantages regarding fish conservation, however a consistent ethical monitoring for its application needs to be applied for their optimal use.
2025
Ethical analysis of Artificial Insemination (AI) and Fertilization (AF) in fish conservation breeding programs
Biodiversity decline is intensifying worldwide, with many fish species becoming critically endangered by factors derived from anthropogenic threats. These issues—paired with insufficient results in the establishment of protected areas and traditional captive breeding programs—call for the employment of streamlined interventions, through the use of assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs). ARTs, including artificial fertilization (AF) and artificial insemination (AI), offer promising outcomes for the conservation of endangered fishes by enhancing reproductive capabilities and genetic management. However, their application often raise ethical concerns. This study aims to address the ethical issues in AI and AF use in fish conservation through a literature review guided by the ETHAS framework (de Mori et al., 2024) —designed for ethical analysis in vertebrate conservation projects, addressing four ethical dimensions: environmental, animal welfare, social, and research ethics. Overall, the analysis revealed multidimensional ethical issues, the main issues include the animal welfare during the procedure, conservation risk in valuable genetic material handling,, and lack of standardized methodological rigor. Social ethics emerged as the most ignored category for the lack of involvement of communities in the studies. ARTs offer outstanding advantages regarding fish conservation, however a consistent ethical monitoring for its application needs to be applied for their optimal use.
Ethics
Conservation
Fish
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Parise_Noel.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 538.98 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
538.98 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/114884