Biodiversity loss is accelerating globally, pushing numerous mammalian species toward extinction. Multifaceted threats in the wild causing reproductive failure and limitations in the captive breeding program with unsatisfactory results are detrimental to the conservation outcome. Assisted reproductive technologies (ART), including artificial insemination (AI), promise a resource-efficient conservation tool in recovering the viability of a population through genetically managed reproductive success, potentially addressing the limitations in mammalian conservation efforts. Despite its growing application, the ethical implications of AI in mammalian conservation remain underexplored. This study aimed to identify and map the ethical issues of AI in mammalian conservation programs through a literature review, using ETHAS (Ethical Assessment Tool) (de Mori et al., 2024) as the analytical framework for ART in vertebrate conservation, articulated across four dimensions: environmental, animal welfare, social, and research ethics. The review identified several ethical issues concerning animal welfare, particularly pain, stress, and captivity-associated distress; research ethics, reduced procedure quality due to the lack of species-specific knowledge; and social ethics, the most neglected dimension for the lack of involvement of community and stakeholder perspectives in decision-making processes. Overall, AI holds remarkable conservation potential for mammals, but its responsible application requires addressing gaps in reproductive knowledge and community engagement.
Biodiversity loss is accelerating globally, pushing numerous mammalian species toward extinction. Multifaceted threats in the wild causing reproductive failure and limitations in the captive breeding program with unsatisfactory results are detrimental to the conservation outcome. Assisted reproductive technologies (ART), including artificial insemination (AI), promise a resource-efficient conservation tool in recovering the viability of a population through genetically managed reproductive success, potentially addressing the limitations in mammalian conservation efforts. Despite its growing application, the ethical implications of AI in mammalian conservation remain underexplored. This study aimed to identify and map the ethical issues of AI in mammalian conservation programs through a literature review, using ETHAS (Ethical Assessment Tool) (de Mori et al., 2024) as the analytical framework for ART in vertebrate conservation, articulated across four dimensions: environmental, animal welfare, social, and research ethics. The review identified several ethical issues concerning animal welfare, particularly pain, stress, and captivity-associated distress; research ethics, reduced procedure quality due to the lack of species-specific knowledge; and social ethics, the most neglected dimension for the lack of involvement of community and stakeholder perspectives in decision-making processes. Overall, AI holds remarkable conservation potential for mammals, but its responsible application requires addressing gaps in reproductive knowledge and community engagement.
Ethical analysis of Artificial Insemination (AI) in mammalian conservation breeding programs
TOGNON, GRETA
2025/2026
Abstract
Biodiversity loss is accelerating globally, pushing numerous mammalian species toward extinction. Multifaceted threats in the wild causing reproductive failure and limitations in the captive breeding program with unsatisfactory results are detrimental to the conservation outcome. Assisted reproductive technologies (ART), including artificial insemination (AI), promise a resource-efficient conservation tool in recovering the viability of a population through genetically managed reproductive success, potentially addressing the limitations in mammalian conservation efforts. Despite its growing application, the ethical implications of AI in mammalian conservation remain underexplored. This study aimed to identify and map the ethical issues of AI in mammalian conservation programs through a literature review, using ETHAS (Ethical Assessment Tool) (de Mori et al., 2024) as the analytical framework for ART in vertebrate conservation, articulated across four dimensions: environmental, animal welfare, social, and research ethics. The review identified several ethical issues concerning animal welfare, particularly pain, stress, and captivity-associated distress; research ethics, reduced procedure quality due to the lack of species-specific knowledge; and social ethics, the most neglected dimension for the lack of involvement of community and stakeholder perspectives in decision-making processes. Overall, AI holds remarkable conservation potential for mammals, but its responsible application requires addressing gaps in reproductive knowledge and community engagement.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tognon_Greta.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
1.27 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.27 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/114898