Since the launch of ChatGPT, much of the rally recorded by the major U.S. stock indices has been attributable to a narrow group of technology companies, leaders in the development of generative artificial intelligence: the Magnificent Seven, whose concentration within the S&P 500 has exceeded the record levels reached at the height of the dot-com bubble. This dynamic raises a question analogous to the one posed in the late 1990s: do valuations tied to generative AI reflect a structural transformation underpinned by solid fundamentals, or do they reveal the symptoms of a speculative bubble destined to burst? From a methodological standpoint, the thesis integrates macro-financial evidence (International Monetary Fund, Bank for International Settlements, and the econometric literature on speculative bubbles) with an industrial economics perspective grounded in Teece's (1986) framework of complementary assets, and with tools drawn from macroeconomic growth theory: in particular, the speculative equilibrium model of Caballero, Farhi and Hammour (2006) and Hulten's theorem as applied by Acemoglu (2025). A hybrid picture emerges: at the level of aggregate valuations, the ecosystem shares with the dot-com era a comparable degree of overvaluation, while at the industrial level the co-specialization of assets sets it clearly apart, pointing to a genuine technological discontinuity whose measurable macroeconomic contribution remains, at present, limited.
Dal lancio di ChatGPT, gran parte del rialzo registrato dai principali indici azionari statunitensi è riconducibile a un ristretto gruppo di società tecnologiche, leader nello sviluppo dell’intelligenza artificiale generativa: le Magnificent Seven, la cui concentrazione nell'indice S&P 500 ha superato i livelli record raggiunti al culmine della bolla delle dot-com. Tale dinamica pone un interrogativo analogo a quello sollevato a fine anni Novanta: le valutazioni legate all'IA generativa riflettono una trasformazione strutturale sostenuta da fondamentali solidi, oppure rivelano i sintomi di una bolla speculativa destinata a implodere? Sotto il profilo metodologico, il lavoro integra l'evidenza macro-finanziaria (Fondo Monetario Internazionale, Banca dei Regolamenti Internazionali e letteratura econometrica sulle bolle speculative) con una lettura di economia industriale fondata sul framework degli asset complementari di Teece (1986) e con strumenti di teoria macroeconomica della crescita: in particolare, il modello di equilibrio speculativo di Caballero, Farhi e Hammour (2006) e il teorema di Hulten applicato da Acemoglu (2025). Emerge un quadro ibrido: sul piano delle valutazioni aggregate l'ecosistema condivide con le dot-com un livello di sopravvalutazione, mentre sul piano industriale la co-specializzazione degli asset lo distingue nettamente, configurando una discontinuità tecnologica reale, il cui contributo macroeconomico misurabile resta, allo stato attuale, contenuto.
L'ecosistema dell'intelligenza artificiale generativa: evoluzione strutturale o bolla speculativa? Un'analisi comparativa con la crisi delle dot-com.
SANDRE, ILARIA
2025/2026
Abstract
Since the launch of ChatGPT, much of the rally recorded by the major U.S. stock indices has been attributable to a narrow group of technology companies, leaders in the development of generative artificial intelligence: the Magnificent Seven, whose concentration within the S&P 500 has exceeded the record levels reached at the height of the dot-com bubble. This dynamic raises a question analogous to the one posed in the late 1990s: do valuations tied to generative AI reflect a structural transformation underpinned by solid fundamentals, or do they reveal the symptoms of a speculative bubble destined to burst? From a methodological standpoint, the thesis integrates macro-financial evidence (International Monetary Fund, Bank for International Settlements, and the econometric literature on speculative bubbles) with an industrial economics perspective grounded in Teece's (1986) framework of complementary assets, and with tools drawn from macroeconomic growth theory: in particular, the speculative equilibrium model of Caballero, Farhi and Hammour (2006) and Hulten's theorem as applied by Acemoglu (2025). A hybrid picture emerges: at the level of aggregate valuations, the ecosystem shares with the dot-com era a comparable degree of overvaluation, while at the industrial level the co-specialization of assets sets it clearly apart, pointing to a genuine technological discontinuity whose measurable macroeconomic contribution remains, at present, limited.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Sandre_Ilaria.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
1.53 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.53 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/115612