As is generally known, indigenous peoples represent one of the most neglected and marginalized minority groups not only socially but also economically, legally, and politically. Among these are the native peoples of Japan, specifically the Ainu of Hokkaido to the north and the Ryukyu of the archipelago of the same name to the south of the country, more emblematic victims of the negligence in the protection of indigenous rights of the Japanese central government. Despite their geographical distance, the two share a similar history of conquest and subsequent assimilation and colonization of their respective territories, resources, cultural, religious, and linguistic traits. This historical process has today led to a significant problem of poor representation of indigenous identities on the historical and mainstream levels, and even more significantly on the institutional level. This heavy historical legacy has had several consequences: first and foremost, systematic discrimination in employment and education, the need to emigrate from one's homeland due to the lack of financial resources and funds to pursue traditional activities, the progressive disappearance of one's linguistic and spiritual heritage, and an overall decline in the population itself. A further serious obstacle is represented by the limited management of their ancestral territories by the natives, a fundamental principle protected by multiple conventions on the protection of indigenous rights (e.g. FPIC contained in several articles of UNDRIP) and linked to the key criterion of ensuring the self-determination of peoples, regularly absent in the Japanese case, especially with regard to the Ryukyu people, not yet formally recognized by the Japanese government, unlike the Ainu people, who, despite ongoing difficulties, received official recognition as an indigenous population by the central government in 2008. In fact, in addition to modest political efforts towards the latter, Japan has so far never ratified the main indigenous rights conventions ((ILO No. 169, Convention on Biological Diversity 1992, etc.) and despite having voted favourably on UNDRIP on 13 September 2007, there is still a lack of diligence in applying their provisions, especially those protecting the right of self-determination, principle which is still being resolutely claimed by local indigenous associations. In this context, the aim of this thesis is precisely to understand the reasons and modalities of Japan's refusal to integrate the provisions contained in the articles of UNDRIP as well as other similar conventions, and the consequences that this policy line entails for the quality of life of the nation's natives.
Com’è generalmente noto, le popolazioni indigene rappresentano uno dei gruppi minoritari maggiormente trascurati e marginalizzati a livello non solo sociale ma anche economico, giuridico e politico. Tra queste, si configurano i popoli nativi del Giappone, precisamente gli Ainu dell’Hokkaido a nord e i Ryūkyū dell’omonimo arcipelago a sud del paese, vittime più emblematiche della negligenza in materia di tutela dei diritti indigeni del governo centrale giapponese. Nonostante la distanza geografica, infatti, le due condividono una simile storia di conquista e successivamente di assimilazione e colonizzazione dei rispettivi territori, risorse, tratti culturali, religiosi e linguistici, processo storico che oggi ha portato ad un notevole problema di scarsa rappresentazione delle identità indigene sul piano storico e della cultura mainstream, ed ancora più significativamente su quello istituzionale. Questa pesante eredità storica ha avuto diverse conseguenze: in primis discriminazioni sistematiche in ambito lavorativo e scolastico, la necessità di emigrare dalla terra d’origine a causa della mancanza di mezzi e fondi economici per perseguire le attività tradizionali, la progressiva scomparsa del proprio patrimonio linguistico e spirituale, nonché una complessiva diminuzione della popolazione stessa. Un ulteriore grave ostacolo è rappresentato dalla limitata gestione dei propri territori ancestrali da parte dei nativi, principio fondamentale tutelato da molteplici convenzioni sulla tutela dei diritti indigeni (es. FPIC contenuto in diversi articoli della UNDRIP) e legato al criterio cardine della garanzia all’autodeterminazione dei popoli, regolarmente assente nel caso giapponese, soprattutto per quanto riguarda il popolo Ryūkyū, non ancora riconosciuto formalmente dal governo nipponico, a differenza di quello Ainu, che, nonostante le difficoltà permanenti, ha ricevuto il riconoscimento ufficiale come popolazione indigena da parte del governo centrale nel 2008. Di fatto, oltre a modesti sforzi politici nei confronti di quest’ultimi, il Giappone non ha mai finora ratificato le principali convenzioni sui diritti indigeni ((ILO No. 169, Convention on Biological Diversity 1992, ecc) e nonostante abbia votato favorevolmente all’UNDRIP nel 13 settembre 2007, tutt’ora manca la diligenza dell’applicarne le disposizioni, specialmente quelle a tutela del diritto di autodeterminazione, principio che viene ancora rivendicato con determinazione dalle associazioni indigene locali. In questo contesto, lo scopo di questa tesi è proprio quello di comprendere i motivi e le modalità del rifiuto da parte del Giappone di integrare le disposizioni contenute negli articoli dell’UNDRIP nonché delle altre convenzioni analoghe, e le conseguenze che questa linea politica comporta per la qualità di vita dei nativi della nazione.
Dall'Assimilazione alle Moderne Rivendicazioni di Diritti: la Tutela Giuridica delle Popolazioni Ainu e Ryūkyū nel Giappone Contemporaneo.
VANIN, REBECCA
2025/2026
Abstract
As is generally known, indigenous peoples represent one of the most neglected and marginalized minority groups not only socially but also economically, legally, and politically. Among these are the native peoples of Japan, specifically the Ainu of Hokkaido to the north and the Ryukyu of the archipelago of the same name to the south of the country, more emblematic victims of the negligence in the protection of indigenous rights of the Japanese central government. Despite their geographical distance, the two share a similar history of conquest and subsequent assimilation and colonization of their respective territories, resources, cultural, religious, and linguistic traits. This historical process has today led to a significant problem of poor representation of indigenous identities on the historical and mainstream levels, and even more significantly on the institutional level. This heavy historical legacy has had several consequences: first and foremost, systematic discrimination in employment and education, the need to emigrate from one's homeland due to the lack of financial resources and funds to pursue traditional activities, the progressive disappearance of one's linguistic and spiritual heritage, and an overall decline in the population itself. A further serious obstacle is represented by the limited management of their ancestral territories by the natives, a fundamental principle protected by multiple conventions on the protection of indigenous rights (e.g. FPIC contained in several articles of UNDRIP) and linked to the key criterion of ensuring the self-determination of peoples, regularly absent in the Japanese case, especially with regard to the Ryukyu people, not yet formally recognized by the Japanese government, unlike the Ainu people, who, despite ongoing difficulties, received official recognition as an indigenous population by the central government in 2008. In fact, in addition to modest political efforts towards the latter, Japan has so far never ratified the main indigenous rights conventions ((ILO No. 169, Convention on Biological Diversity 1992, etc.) and despite having voted favourably on UNDRIP on 13 September 2007, there is still a lack of diligence in applying their provisions, especially those protecting the right of self-determination, principle which is still being resolutely claimed by local indigenous associations. In this context, the aim of this thesis is precisely to understand the reasons and modalities of Japan's refusal to integrate the provisions contained in the articles of UNDRIP as well as other similar conventions, and the consequences that this policy line entails for the quality of life of the nation's natives.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Rebecca.Vanin.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
893.26 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
893.26 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117228