European data protection law is currently facing a crisis. The existing legal framework struggles to meet the needs of today’s technological context, particularly the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence. This dissertation analyzes the current regulatory framework of the European Union and its main problems. Key issues include the erosion of the “personal data” concept, the failure of the consent paradigm, and the inherent conflict between the functioning of AI and some provisions contained in the GDPR. In response to these critical issues, this research examines the recent “Digital Omnibus” and “Digital Omnibus on AI” regulatory proposals. Although these drafts aim to resolve certain fundamental problems, their practical effectiveness remains questionable. In conclusion, reconciling personal data protection with AI requires a paradigm shift. The law must balance technological advancement with the fundamental rights of data subjects. The extreme complexity of AI makes effective and individual control by the data subject practically impossible. For this purpose, a system of objective, systemic, and mandatory safeguards is essential. Only in this way can the technological innovation required for global competitiveness align with the fundamental centrality of the human being.
Il diritto europeo in materia di protezione dei dati personali si trova oggi ad affrontare una crisi, a causa delle difficoltà della disciplina a rispondere alle esigenze del contesto tecnologico attuale, del quale l’intelligenza artificiale è la massima espressione. L’elaborato si propone di analizzare l’attuale quadro normativo di diritto dell’Unione europea ed i suoi limiti principali, tra i quali l’erosione della nozione stessa di “dato personale”, la crisi del criterio del consenso e l’incompatibilità fisiologica tra il funzionamento dell’IA ed alcune disposizioni contenute nel GDPR. A fronte di tali criticità, l’indagine si sofferma sull’esame analitico delle recenti proposte di Regolamento “Omnibus digitale” e “Omnibus digitale sull’IA”, le quali ambiscono a risolvere alcuni tra i problemi principali della disciplina, ma non risultano esenti da perplessità in merito alla loro concreta efficacia. In conclusione, il lavoro evidenzia come, per conciliare protezione dei dati personali e IA, apparirebbe necessario un cambio di paradigma, in grado di contemperare la necessità di sviluppo tecnologico con la salvaguardia dei diritti fondamentali degli interessati. A tal fine, appare indispensabile approdare ad un sistema di garanzie oggettive, sistemiche e inderogabili, in quanto l’estrema complessità della materia parrebbe rendere ormai impraticabile un controllo effettivo da parte dell’interessato. Solo in tal modo, l’innovazione tecnologica richiesta per la competitività a livello globale può conciliarsi con la fondamentale centralità della persona umana.
Trattamento dei dati personali e IA: una prospettiva europea
MIATELLO, GIANLUIGI
2025/2026
Abstract
European data protection law is currently facing a crisis. The existing legal framework struggles to meet the needs of today’s technological context, particularly the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence. This dissertation analyzes the current regulatory framework of the European Union and its main problems. Key issues include the erosion of the “personal data” concept, the failure of the consent paradigm, and the inherent conflict between the functioning of AI and some provisions contained in the GDPR. In response to these critical issues, this research examines the recent “Digital Omnibus” and “Digital Omnibus on AI” regulatory proposals. Although these drafts aim to resolve certain fundamental problems, their practical effectiveness remains questionable. In conclusion, reconciling personal data protection with AI requires a paradigm shift. The law must balance technological advancement with the fundamental rights of data subjects. The extreme complexity of AI makes effective and individual control by the data subject practically impossible. For this purpose, a system of objective, systemic, and mandatory safeguards is essential. Only in this way can the technological innovation required for global competitiveness align with the fundamental centrality of the human being.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Miatello_Gianluigi.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
4.73 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
4.73 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117424