On 18 March 2025, Istanbul University annuls the university degree of Ekrem İmamoğlu, mayor of the city and the leading opposition figure against Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, paving the way for his arrest and his exclusion from the 2028 presidential race. This episode, ostensibly a bureaucratic pretext, becomes the starting point for a broader investigation into the rule of law in Turkey under AKP rule, conducted from the standpoint of human rights protection. The thesis reconstructs how the country moves, between 2002 and 2026, from a decade of reforms presented as a process of democratization to a configuration attributable to competitive authoritarianism, passing through the constitutional reforms aimed at European alignment, the rupture represented by the Gezi Park protests and the 2013 corruption scandal, the failed 2016 coup and the resulting derogation from conventional obligations, up to the consolidation of Erdoğan's executive presidentialism after 2018. Through key case law such as Alpay, Altan and Kavala, and developments affecting the legal profession and press freedom, the work tests the effectiveness of the three main international human rights mechanisms, the European Convention on Human Rights system, the United Nations system, and the conditionality linked to the European Union accession process, bringing to light the shared structural limitations that undermine their capacity to counter a democratic erosion carried out through formally legitimate means. Drawing on the theoretical category of competitive authoritarianism developed by Levitsky and Way, the thesis shows how, in Turkey, the democratic form survives while the substance of fundamental rights is systematically hollowed out from within.
Il 18 marzo 2025 l'Università di Istanbul annulla il diploma di laurea di Ekrem İmamoğlu, sindaco della città e principale esponente dell'opposizione a Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, aprendo la strada al suo arresto e alla sua esclusione dalla corsa presidenziale del 2028. Questo episodio, apparentemente un pretesto burocratico, diventa il punto di partenza di un'indagine più ampia sullo Stato di diritto in Turchia sotto il governo dell'AKP, condotta dal punto di vista della tutela dei diritti umani. La tesi ricostruisce come il paese sia transitato, tra il 2002 e il 2026, da un decennio di riforme presentate come processo di democratizzazione a un assetto riconducibile all' "autoritarismo competitivo", attraversando le riforme costituzionali di allineamento europeo, la rottura rappresentata da Gezi Park e dallo scandalo di corruzione del 2013, il tentato golpe del 2016 e la conseguente deroga agli obblighi convenzionali, fino al consolidamento del presidenzialismo esecutivo di Erdoğan dopo il 2018. Attraverso casi giurisprudenziali chiave come Alpay, Altan e Kavala, e le vicende dell'avvocatura e della libertà di stampa, il lavoro mette alla prova l'efficacia dei tre principali meccanismi internazionali di tutela dei diritti umani, il sistema della Convenzione europea dei diritti dell'uomo, il sistema delle Nazioni Unite e la condizionalità legata al processo di adesione all'Unione Europea, portando alla luce i limiti strutturali comuni che ne compromettono la capacità di contrastare un'erosione democratica condotta con strumenti formalmente legittimi. Alla luce della categoria teorica dell' "autoritarismo competitivo" elaborata da Levitsky e Way, la tesi mostra come, in Turchia, la forma democratica sopravviva mentre la sostanza dei diritti fondamentali viene sistematicamente svuotata dall'interno.
Lo Stato di diritto in Turchia nell'era Erdoğan: dalla democratizzazione all'autoritarismo competitivo (2002-2026)
GELONESE, ELISA
2025/2026
Abstract
On 18 March 2025, Istanbul University annuls the university degree of Ekrem İmamoğlu, mayor of the city and the leading opposition figure against Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, paving the way for his arrest and his exclusion from the 2028 presidential race. This episode, ostensibly a bureaucratic pretext, becomes the starting point for a broader investigation into the rule of law in Turkey under AKP rule, conducted from the standpoint of human rights protection. The thesis reconstructs how the country moves, between 2002 and 2026, from a decade of reforms presented as a process of democratization to a configuration attributable to competitive authoritarianism, passing through the constitutional reforms aimed at European alignment, the rupture represented by the Gezi Park protests and the 2013 corruption scandal, the failed 2016 coup and the resulting derogation from conventional obligations, up to the consolidation of Erdoğan's executive presidentialism after 2018. Through key case law such as Alpay, Altan and Kavala, and developments affecting the legal profession and press freedom, the work tests the effectiveness of the three main international human rights mechanisms, the European Convention on Human Rights system, the United Nations system, and the conditionality linked to the European Union accession process, bringing to light the shared structural limitations that undermine their capacity to counter a democratic erosion carried out through formally legitimate means. Drawing on the theoretical category of competitive authoritarianism developed by Levitsky and Way, the thesis shows how, in Turkey, the democratic form survives while the substance of fundamental rights is systematically hollowed out from within.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Gelonese_Elisa_2103852.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
1.19 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.19 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117810