This thesis looks at the gap between what Argentine law says about people deprived of their liberty and what actually happens inside the country's prisons. National legislation — from Law 24,660 to oversight bodies such as the National Penitentiary Ombudsman's Office (PPN) — recognizes rights like healthcare, education, and social reintegration. However, reports from CELS, research from UNTREF, and journalistic accounts point to a serious crisis marked by chronic overcrowding, ongoing torture and mistreatment, and a rising number of deaths of people in state custody. This overcrowding is not accidental: it stems directly from the excessive use of pretrial detention, a problem that is even worse within the Buenos Aires Provincial Penitentiary Service. On top of this, prison labor is either poorly paid or simply unavailable to most inmates, and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has already condemned the Argentine State for failing to fulfill the rehabilitative purpose of punishment. This thesis argues that imprisonment has stopped being merely a legal deprivation of liberty and has, in practice, become a form of physical and psychological torture. To support this claim, the analysis draws on laws and court rulings alongside real data and testimonies, from a human rights perspective.
Este trabajo analiza la distancia que hay entre lo que dice la ley argentina sobre las personas privadas de libertad y lo que realmente pasa dentro de las cárceles. La normativa nacional —desde la Ley 24.660 hasta organismos de control como la Procuración Penitenciaria de la Nación (PPN)— reconoce derechos como la salud, la educación y la reinserción social. Sin embargo, informes del CELS, investigaciones de la UNTREF y notas periodísticas muestran una crisis bastante grave, marcada por el hacinamiento constante, la tortura y los malos tratos que siguen pasando, y el aumento de las muertes de personas detenidas bajo custodia del Estado. Este hacinamiento no es casualidad: es consecuencia directa del uso excesivo de la prisión preventiva, algo que se ve todavía peor en el Servicio Penitenciario Bonaerense. A esto se suma que el trabajo dentro de las cárceles está mal pagado o directamente no existe para la mayoría, y que la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos ya condenó al Estado argentino por no cumplir con la función resocializadora de la pena. La hipótesis de este trabajo es que la cárcel dejó de ser solo una privación de la libertad y se convirtió, en los hechos, en una forma de tortura física y psicológica. Para demostrarlo, se cruzan leyes y fallos judiciales con datos y testimonios reales, desde una mirada de derechos humanos.
Los derechos de los detenidos entre la ley y la realidad: Tortura, hacinamiento y muerte en el sistema carcelario argentino
GOBBI, ANGELA
2025/2026
Abstract
This thesis looks at the gap between what Argentine law says about people deprived of their liberty and what actually happens inside the country's prisons. National legislation — from Law 24,660 to oversight bodies such as the National Penitentiary Ombudsman's Office (PPN) — recognizes rights like healthcare, education, and social reintegration. However, reports from CELS, research from UNTREF, and journalistic accounts point to a serious crisis marked by chronic overcrowding, ongoing torture and mistreatment, and a rising number of deaths of people in state custody. This overcrowding is not accidental: it stems directly from the excessive use of pretrial detention, a problem that is even worse within the Buenos Aires Provincial Penitentiary Service. On top of this, prison labor is either poorly paid or simply unavailable to most inmates, and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has already condemned the Argentine State for failing to fulfill the rehabilitative purpose of punishment. This thesis argues that imprisonment has stopped being merely a legal deprivation of liberty and has, in practice, become a form of physical and psychological torture. To support this claim, the analysis draws on laws and court rulings alongside real data and testimonies, from a human rights perspective.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Angela_Gobbi_2103850.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
795.25 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
795.25 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117815