This paper aims to investigate whether, and to what extent, current US immigration policy, specifically the federal agency ICE, can be considered a paradox of control: a repressive response to a tragedy that the United States itself helped generate and fuel. The hypothesis is that certain political, economic, or interventionist processes that developed during the 20th century contributed to shaping the conditions that fuel the migration flow from Central America to the North. According to this interpretation, the current migration crisis at the US southern border, defined by Donald Trump as an invasion and a calamity to be countered with zero-tolerance policies, would represent a blowback of US interventionism in the region: an unintended consequence that current immigration policies are attempting to repress. In verifying this thesis, the focus will be on analyzing US interference in the region during the Cold War years; the political, social, and economic factors at the root of Central American migration will be analyzed, drawing on official statistical data and investigations by international human rights organizations. The objective is to deconstruct the myth of migration as a merely voluntary phenomenon, keeping the individual at the center of the entire reflection in order to show the destructive effects of the migratory condition on a person's integrity and dignity.
L’elaborato si propone di indagare se, e in che misura, l’attuale politica migratoria statunitense, nello specifico l’agenzia federale dell’ICE, possa ritenersi un paradosso del controllo: una risposta repressiva ad un dramma che gli stessi Stati Uniti hanno contribuito a generare ed alimentare. L’ipotesi è che determinati processi politici, economici o di intervento sviluppatisi nel corso del XX secolo abbiano contribuito a configurare le condizioni che alimentano il flusso migratorio dall’America Centrale verso il Nord. Secondo questa lettura, l’attuale crisi migratoria al confine meridionale degli USA, definita da Donald Trump come invasione e calamità da contrastare con politiche di tolleranza zero, si configurerebbe come blowback dell’interventismo statunitense nella regione: un effetto indesiderato che le attuali politiche migratorie starebbero tentando di reprimere. Nel verificare questa tesi ci si soffermerà sull’analisi dell’ingerenza statunitense nella regione durante gli anni della Guerra Fredda, si analizzeranno i fattori politici, sociali, ed economici all’origine delle migrazioni centroamericane, ci si avvarrà di dati statistici ufficiali e di indagini di organizzazioni internazionali a tutela dei diritti umani. L’obiettivo è decostruire il mito della migrazione come fenomeno meramente volontario, mantenendo l’individuo al centro dell’intera riflessione al fine di mostrare gli effetti distruttivi della condizione migratoria sull’integrità e sulla dignità della persona.
IL PARADOSSO DEL CONTROLLO: L'ICE COME RISPOSTA AL BLOWBACK DELL’INTERVENTISMO STATUNITENSE IN AMERICA LATINA
SALA, IRENE
2025/2026
Abstract
This paper aims to investigate whether, and to what extent, current US immigration policy, specifically the federal agency ICE, can be considered a paradox of control: a repressive response to a tragedy that the United States itself helped generate and fuel. The hypothesis is that certain political, economic, or interventionist processes that developed during the 20th century contributed to shaping the conditions that fuel the migration flow from Central America to the North. According to this interpretation, the current migration crisis at the US southern border, defined by Donald Trump as an invasion and a calamity to be countered with zero-tolerance policies, would represent a blowback of US interventionism in the region: an unintended consequence that current immigration policies are attempting to repress. In verifying this thesis, the focus will be on analyzing US interference in the region during the Cold War years; the political, social, and economic factors at the root of Central American migration will be analyzed, drawing on official statistical data and investigations by international human rights organizations. The objective is to deconstruct the myth of migration as a merely voluntary phenomenon, keeping the individual at the center of the entire reflection in order to show the destructive effects of the migratory condition on a person's integrity and dignity.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
IRENE_SALA.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
2.66 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.66 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117860