African swine fever represents one of the main threats to animal health and the pig production sector because of its high transmissibility and lethality, as well as the significant economic consequences associated with its spread. In mainland Italy, the presence of the virus since 2022 has highlighted the complexity of managing a disease that affects both wild boar populations and domestic pig farms. In this context, assessing the ability of the surveillance system to detect infection promptly is of fundamental importance. The aim of this study was to develop a methodological framework for evaluating the sensitivity of the African swine fever surveillance system in mainland Italy through the implementation of a scenario tree model. This approach was selected in view of the expected low prevalence of infection and the difficulty of accurately determining the size and distribution of the wild boar population. These factors make it difficult to estimate the required sample size and limit the feasibility of relying exclusively on sampling-based surveillance. The model was adapted from a framework developed for the Sardinian context, taking into account the epidemiological, territorial and organisational characteristics of mainland Italy. In particular, the different health zones established under the current legislation were considered, together with the main surveillance components for domestic pigs, including slaughter for private consumption, mortality surveillance, clinical and epidemiological suspicion, and the movement of animals and products of porcine origin. The component relating to wild boar was retained in the overall structure of the model; however, its parameterisation was postponed to a later stage because of the uncertainty surrounding the size and distribution of the wild boar population and the probability of carcass detection. The model developed does not therefore provide a definitive estimate of national surveillance sensitivity but establishes a logical and reproducible framework for its future quantitative assessment based on data from veterinary information systems and official surveillance activities. The integration of Monte Carlo simulations and sensitivity analyses will make it possible to quantify uncertainty, identify the most critical steps and assess the effects of different surveillance strategies.
La Peste suina africana rappresenta una delle principali minacce per la sanità animale e per il comparto suinicolo, a causa della sua elevata contagiosità e letalità e delle rilevanti conseguenze economiche associate alla sua diffusione. In Italia continentale, la presenza del virus dal 2022 ha evidenziato la complessità della gestione di una malattia che coinvolge sia le popolazioni di cinghiale sia gli allevamenti di suini domestici. In questo contesto, la valutazione della capacità del sistema di sorveglianza di rilevare tempestivamente l’infezione assume un ruolo fondamentale. Il presente lavoro ha avuto l’obiettivo di sviluppare una struttura metodologica per la valutazione della sensibilità del sistema di sorveglianza della PSA nell’Italia continentale mediante l’implementazione di uno scenario tree model. Tale approccio è stato scelto in considerazione della bassa prevalenza attesa dell’infezione e della difficoltà di definire con precisione la consistenza e la distribuzione della popolazione di cinghiali. Questi elementi rendono complessa la stima della numerosità campionaria necessaria e limitano la possibilità di basare la sorveglianza esclusivamente sul campionamento. Il modello è stato adattato a partire da una struttura sviluppata per il contesto sardo, tenendo conto delle caratteristiche epidemiologiche, territoriali e organizzative dell’Italia continentale. In particolare, sono state considerate le diverse zone sanitarie previste dalla normativa vigente e le principali componenti della sorveglianza nei suini domestici, relative alla macellazione per autoconsumo, alla mortalità, ai sospetti clinici ed epidemiologici e alle movimentazioni di animali e prodotti di origine suina. La componente relativa ai suini selvatici è stata mantenuta nella struttura generale del modello, ma la sua parametrizzazione è stata rinviata a una fase successiva, a causa dell’incertezza relativa alla consistenza e alla distribuzione della popolazione selvatica e alla probabilità di rinvenimento delle carcasse. Il modello elaborato non fornisce pertanto una stima definitiva della sensibilità nazionale, ma definisce una struttura logica e riproducibile per la sua futura valutazione quantitativa mediante dati provenienti dai sistemi informativi veterinari e dalle attività di sorveglianza ufficiale. L’impiego di simulazioni Monte Carlo e di analisi di sensibilità consentirà di quantificare l’incertezza, individuare i passaggi più critici e valutare l’effetto di differenti strategie di sorveglianza.
Valutazione del sistema di sorveglianza della Peste Suina Africana mediante l'implementazione di uno Scenario Tree Model
MARCATO, DAVIDE
2025/2026
Abstract
African swine fever represents one of the main threats to animal health and the pig production sector because of its high transmissibility and lethality, as well as the significant economic consequences associated with its spread. In mainland Italy, the presence of the virus since 2022 has highlighted the complexity of managing a disease that affects both wild boar populations and domestic pig farms. In this context, assessing the ability of the surveillance system to detect infection promptly is of fundamental importance. The aim of this study was to develop a methodological framework for evaluating the sensitivity of the African swine fever surveillance system in mainland Italy through the implementation of a scenario tree model. This approach was selected in view of the expected low prevalence of infection and the difficulty of accurately determining the size and distribution of the wild boar population. These factors make it difficult to estimate the required sample size and limit the feasibility of relying exclusively on sampling-based surveillance. The model was adapted from a framework developed for the Sardinian context, taking into account the epidemiological, territorial and organisational characteristics of mainland Italy. In particular, the different health zones established under the current legislation were considered, together with the main surveillance components for domestic pigs, including slaughter for private consumption, mortality surveillance, clinical and epidemiological suspicion, and the movement of animals and products of porcine origin. The component relating to wild boar was retained in the overall structure of the model; however, its parameterisation was postponed to a later stage because of the uncertainty surrounding the size and distribution of the wild boar population and the probability of carcass detection. The model developed does not therefore provide a definitive estimate of national surveillance sensitivity but establishes a logical and reproducible framework for its future quantitative assessment based on data from veterinary information systems and official surveillance activities. The integration of Monte Carlo simulations and sensitivity analyses will make it possible to quantify uncertainty, identify the most critical steps and assess the effects of different surveillance strategies.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Marcato Davide 1222391.pdf
embargo fino al 13/10/2029
Dimensione
2.3 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
2.3 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117912