When an animal is suffering from degenerative, geriatric, or terminal conditions, it often becomes difficult for caregivers and veterinarians to make decisions, especially since euthanasia is a viable end-of-life option in veterinary medicine. Quality-of-life (QOL) assessment scales are practical tools that can help caregivers become more aware of their animal’s condition, while also providing veterinarians with a comprehensive understanding of the situation facing both the animal and the caregiver. These scales are valuable tools that ensure that animals consistently maintain an adequate quality of life and, when this is no longer the case, that guide informed and appropriate decision-making. The emotional and psychological dimensions are essential components of a comprehensive quality-of-life assessment, particularly in patients experiencing progressive physical decline or approaching the end of life. This thesis study arose precisely from the need for a quality-of-life assessment tool that could also focus on the mental and emotional aspects of the well-being of geriatric, terminally ill or animals with degenerative conditions—and that could be as objective as possible in monitoring these aspects. For this reason, the study aimed to develop a quality-of-life assessment protocol that incorporates parameters related to Positive Animal Welfare, including agency. This tool therefore consists of one questionnaire for the physical component and one for the mental component. In the preliminary phase, the tool was tested by five individuals, and data were subsequently collected from ten dog-caregiver pairs who participated in the study. Finally, this thesis presents two case studies involving dogs receiving care at a specialized palliative care center. In both cases, the quality-of-life assessment scale was completed by the dogs’ respective caregivers. The questionnaire responses were recorded over a total period of 6 months, from January to the end of June 2026. The data collected was used to describe the dogs’ quality of life, as perceived by their caregivers, and to assess changes over time in the physical and mental parameters, following clinical developments reported by the veterinarian. Although the two animals were very different from one another in terms of physical characteristics, medical history, and life expectancy, they were both patients with degenerative conditions, and their physical health declined during the months of observation in which this study took place. In both animals, it emerged that their emotional and mental well-being did not deteriorate at the same rate as their physical well-being, and that the dogs continued to show interest in the activities and the environment that characterized their lives, in ways specific to each individual. The in-depth assessment of the patients’ emotional and psychological states also revealed that, for some caregivers, quality of life extends beyond physical health. Although they were able to acknowledge and adapt to the progressive decline in their pets’ physical condition, they also placed considerable importance on their animals’ emotional and psychological well-being. These findings highlight the need to consider these dimensions when assessing quality of life and offer valuable insights into their inclusion in quality-of-life assessment scales.
Quando un animale verte in condizioni degenerative, geriatriche o terminali, spesso diventa complesso per i caregiver e per i veterinari fare delle scelte, soprattutto perché in medicina veterinaria l’eutanasia è un’opzione praticabile per il fine vita. Le scale di valutazione della qualità di vita (QOL) sono strumenti pratici che possono aiutare i caregiver a diventare più consapevoli delle condizioni del proprio animale, oltre a offrire la possibilità al medico veterinario di comprendere a trecentosessanta gradi la situazione in cui animale e caregiver si trovano. Sono utili sia per garantire che gli animali abbiano sempre una qualità di vita soddisfacente sia, laddove questo non avvenga, nel supporto dei conseguenti processi decisionali. La dimensione emotiva e mentale risulta di fondamentale valore e importanza per una corretta valutazione della qualità di vita, soprattutto in quei casi in cui ci troviamo di fronte a pazienti con condizioni fisiche in progressivo declino o in prossimità del fine vita. Il presente studio di tesi è nato proprio dalla necessità di avere uno strumento di valutazione della qualità di vita che ponesse un’attenzione mirata anche alla componente mentale ed emotiva del benessere di animali geriatrici, terminali o con patologie ad andamento degenerativo e che fosse il più oggettivo possibile nel monitorare tali aspetti. Per questo, lo studio si è preposto la creazione di un protocollo per la valutazione della qualità di vita che includa parametri collegati al Benessere Animale Positivo, tra cui l’agency. Tale strumento prevede pertanto un questionario per la componente fisica e uno per quella mentale. In fase preliminare l’applicazione dello strumento è stata testata da cinque persone, raccogliendo poi dati di dieci diadi cane-caregiver che hanno partecipato allo studio. Questa tesi presenta infine due casi studio di cani seguiti in un centro specializzato in cure palliative a cui è stata applicata la scala di valutazione della qualità di vita da parte dei rispettivi caregiver. Le risposte ai questionari sono state registrate per un periodo complessivo di 6 mesi, da gennaio a fine giugno 2026. I dati raccolti sono stati utilizzati per descrivere la qualità di vita dei cani, come percepita dal caregiver, e valutare l’andamento nel tempo dei parametri di valutazione del benessere fisico e mentale, anche in base agli sviluppi clinici riferiti dal veterinario. Nonostante i due animali fossero molto diversi tra loro, sia nel segnalamento che nell’anamnesi e aspettative di vita, erano entrambi pazienti con patologie ad andamento degenerativo, le cui condizioni di salute fisica hanno subito un declino nei mesi di osservazione in cui ha avuto luogo questo studio. In entrambi gli animali, è emerso come la componente di benessere emotivo e mentale non peggiorasse di pari passo con quella fisica e come i cani continuassero a esprimere interesse per le attività e i contesti che caratterizzavano la loro vita, in modo individuo-specifico. La valutazione approfondita della componente dello stato emotivo-mentale dei pazienti ha inoltre rivelato come anche per alcuni caregiver rimanga importante non solo la parte fisica, essendo in grado di accettare il declino progressivo della salute del proprio animale e adattandosi alle loro necessità, ma anche quella emotiva e mentale, donando uno spunto di riflessione sull’importanza di tale aspetto nelle scale di valutazione della qualità di vita.
Sviluppo di un Nuovo Sistema di Valutazione della Qualità di Vita applicabile da Caregiver di Cani con patologie degenerative, geriatrici o terminali: Due Casi Studio
SAMBROTTA, CELESTE
2025/2026
Abstract
When an animal is suffering from degenerative, geriatric, or terminal conditions, it often becomes difficult for caregivers and veterinarians to make decisions, especially since euthanasia is a viable end-of-life option in veterinary medicine. Quality-of-life (QOL) assessment scales are practical tools that can help caregivers become more aware of their animal’s condition, while also providing veterinarians with a comprehensive understanding of the situation facing both the animal and the caregiver. These scales are valuable tools that ensure that animals consistently maintain an adequate quality of life and, when this is no longer the case, that guide informed and appropriate decision-making. The emotional and psychological dimensions are essential components of a comprehensive quality-of-life assessment, particularly in patients experiencing progressive physical decline or approaching the end of life. This thesis study arose precisely from the need for a quality-of-life assessment tool that could also focus on the mental and emotional aspects of the well-being of geriatric, terminally ill or animals with degenerative conditions—and that could be as objective as possible in monitoring these aspects. For this reason, the study aimed to develop a quality-of-life assessment protocol that incorporates parameters related to Positive Animal Welfare, including agency. This tool therefore consists of one questionnaire for the physical component and one for the mental component. In the preliminary phase, the tool was tested by five individuals, and data were subsequently collected from ten dog-caregiver pairs who participated in the study. Finally, this thesis presents two case studies involving dogs receiving care at a specialized palliative care center. In both cases, the quality-of-life assessment scale was completed by the dogs’ respective caregivers. The questionnaire responses were recorded over a total period of 6 months, from January to the end of June 2026. The data collected was used to describe the dogs’ quality of life, as perceived by their caregivers, and to assess changes over time in the physical and mental parameters, following clinical developments reported by the veterinarian. Although the two animals were very different from one another in terms of physical characteristics, medical history, and life expectancy, they were both patients with degenerative conditions, and their physical health declined during the months of observation in which this study took place. In both animals, it emerged that their emotional and mental well-being did not deteriorate at the same rate as their physical well-being, and that the dogs continued to show interest in the activities and the environment that characterized their lives, in ways specific to each individual. The in-depth assessment of the patients’ emotional and psychological states also revealed that, for some caregivers, quality of life extends beyond physical health. Although they were able to acknowledge and adapt to the progressive decline in their pets’ physical condition, they also placed considerable importance on their animals’ emotional and psychological well-being. These findings highlight the need to consider these dimensions when assessing quality of life and offer valuable insights into their inclusion in quality-of-life assessment scales.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Tesi Celeste Sambrotta.pdf
embargo fino al 13/10/2029
Dimensione
1.82 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.82 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117914