Material fatigue has represented a major problem in mechanical engineering for more than a century. Its assessment is complex because fatigue failure may occur suddenly, often without macroscopic warning signs. This difficulty becomes more pronounced in the case of notched components, where geometric discontinuities act as stress concentrators and produce highly non-uniform local stress fields. The stress state at the notch root becomes multiaxial, even when the external loading is simple. The study of multiaxial fatigue requires advanced methods that consider the interaction between different loading components and conditions. Several theoretical and engineering approaches have been developed, leading to the formulation of numerous multiaxial fatigue strength criteria. This Master’s thesis project, developed at the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering at CTU in Prague, proposes an evaluation of several methods for assessing different types of notched components under varying load ratios. In the TCD, the evaluation is also based on the use of different criteria for multiaxial fatigue. The aim of this evaluation is to have an evaluation, combining variable notches under different load cases at different numbers of cycles, how much each criterion and method is influenced by each other and by the other variables, and which combination leads to the best conclusions in terms of not only single values, but also the stability of the entire set of results, allowing the strengths and limitations of each approach to be discussed, contributing to a more reliable application of multiaxial fatigue models and verification of notched mechanical components. First of all, an introduction to the basics of material fatigue is presented, then the entire experimental study is presented: fatigue tests on the examined material, finite element analyzes on the specimens, and explanations of different criteria are provided. Several stress-based fatigue criteria are considered, including the Böhme–Papuga, Dang Van, Manson–McKnight, and Papuga QCP models. These criteria are applied to finite element stress fields obtained along characteristic paths starting from the notch root, allowing for the evolution of the fatigue index with distance from the critical point to be analyzed. Two different engineering approaches are examined: the first is the Theory of Critical Distances, implemented through both the Point Method and the Line Method, which evaluate fatigue damage at a finite distance from the notch root or through an averaged stress measure over a characteristic length, then the relative stress gradient approach of the FKM guideline is explained, which introduces a notch support concept based on the local stress gradient. In the final part of the thesis, results are discussed, stressing the comparison between the outcomes from the four criteria implemented, combined with the two TCD method analyzes, and also confronting them with results of the RSG, in order to highlight criticalities of the approaches. The conclusions summarize all key points of the work, discussing issues that are present in some particular cases. The document closes with the appendix where additional data and information useful for understanding are collected.
Material fatigue has represented a major problem in mechanical engineering for more than a century. Its assessment is complex because fatigue failure may occur suddenly, often without macroscopic warning signs. This difficulty becomes more pronounced in the case of notched components, where geometric discontinuities act as stress concentrators and produce highly non-uniform local stress fields. The stress state at the notch root becomes multiaxial, even when the external loading is simple. The study of multiaxial fatigue requires advanced methods that consider the interaction between different loading components and conditions. Several theoretical and engineering approaches have been developed, leading to the formulation of numerous multiaxial fatigue strength criteria. This Master’s thesis project, developed at the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering at CTU in Prague, proposes an evaluation of several methods for assessing different types of notched components under varying load ratios. In the TCD, the evaluation is also based on the use of different criteria for multiaxial fatigue. The aim of this evaluation is to have an evaluation, combining variable notches under different load cases at different numbers of cycles, how much each criterion and method is influenced by each other and by the other variables, and which combination leads to the best conclusions in terms of not only single values, but also the stability of the entire set of results, allowing the strengths and limitations of each approach to be discussed, contributing to a more reliable application of multiaxial fatigue models and verification of notched mechanical components. First of all, an introduction to the basics of material fatigue is presented, then the entire experimental study is presented: fatigue tests on the examined material, finite element analyzes on the specimens, and explanations of different criteria are provided. Several stress-based fatigue criteria are considered, including the Böhme–Papuga, Dang Van, Manson–McKnight, and Papuga QCP models. These criteria are applied to finite element stress fields obtained along characteristic paths starting from the notch root, allowing for the evolution of the fatigue index with distance from the critical point to be analyzed. Two different engineering approaches are examined: the first is the Theory of Critical Distances, implemented through both the Point Method and the Line Method, which evaluate fatigue damage at a finite distance from the notch root or through an averaged stress measure over a characteristic length, then the relative stress gradient approach of the FKM guideline is explained, which introduces a notch support concept based on the local stress gradient. In the final part of the thesis, results are discussed, stressing the comparison between the outcomes from the four criteria implemented, combined with the two TCD method analyzes, and also confronting them with results of the RSG, in order to highlight criticalities of the approaches. The conclusions summarize all key points of the work, discussing issues that are present in some particular cases. The document closes with the appendix where additional data and information useful for understanding are collected.
Fatigue estimation of notched components under multiaxial loading
SIMON, ALBERTO IONUC
2025/2026
Abstract
Material fatigue has represented a major problem in mechanical engineering for more than a century. Its assessment is complex because fatigue failure may occur suddenly, often without macroscopic warning signs. This difficulty becomes more pronounced in the case of notched components, where geometric discontinuities act as stress concentrators and produce highly non-uniform local stress fields. The stress state at the notch root becomes multiaxial, even when the external loading is simple. The study of multiaxial fatigue requires advanced methods that consider the interaction between different loading components and conditions. Several theoretical and engineering approaches have been developed, leading to the formulation of numerous multiaxial fatigue strength criteria. This Master’s thesis project, developed at the Faculty of Mechanical Engineering at CTU in Prague, proposes an evaluation of several methods for assessing different types of notched components under varying load ratios. In the TCD, the evaluation is also based on the use of different criteria for multiaxial fatigue. The aim of this evaluation is to have an evaluation, combining variable notches under different load cases at different numbers of cycles, how much each criterion and method is influenced by each other and by the other variables, and which combination leads to the best conclusions in terms of not only single values, but also the stability of the entire set of results, allowing the strengths and limitations of each approach to be discussed, contributing to a more reliable application of multiaxial fatigue models and verification of notched mechanical components. First of all, an introduction to the basics of material fatigue is presented, then the entire experimental study is presented: fatigue tests on the examined material, finite element analyzes on the specimens, and explanations of different criteria are provided. Several stress-based fatigue criteria are considered, including the Böhme–Papuga, Dang Van, Manson–McKnight, and Papuga QCP models. These criteria are applied to finite element stress fields obtained along characteristic paths starting from the notch root, allowing for the evolution of the fatigue index with distance from the critical point to be analyzed. Two different engineering approaches are examined: the first is the Theory of Critical Distances, implemented through both the Point Method and the Line Method, which evaluate fatigue damage at a finite distance from the notch root or through an averaged stress measure over a characteristic length, then the relative stress gradient approach of the FKM guideline is explained, which introduces a notch support concept based on the local stress gradient. In the final part of the thesis, results are discussed, stressing the comparison between the outcomes from the four criteria implemented, combined with the two TCD method analyzes, and also confronting them with results of the RSG, in order to highlight criticalities of the approaches. The conclusions summarize all key points of the work, discussing issues that are present in some particular cases. The document closes with the appendix where additional data and information useful for understanding are collected.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Simon_AlbertoIonuc.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
14.22 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
14.22 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118128