The effectiveness of international human rights law depends on its capacity to acquire meaning and produce change within domestic contexts. Yet the transmission of international norms into national policy is neither automatic nor linear, but involves processes of interpretation, translation, mobilisation and contestation in which civil society can play a critical role. This thesis examines these processes through the case of the Italian NGO Group for the Convention of the Rights of the Child, known as “Gruppo CRC”, a long-standing coalition of civil society organisations monitoring the implementation of the UNCRC in Italy. Drawing on the concepts of vernacularization, transnational advocacy and multi-level governance, the thesis conceptualises the Gruppo CRC not only as a monitoring actor, but also as an intermediary through which international children’s rights norms are interpreted and translated into domestic advocacy. The analysis examines the coalition’s development, governance, resources, monitoring and advocacy practices, with particular attention to the role of its diverse expertise and multi-level engagement. It culminates in a case study of Comprehensive Sexuality Education, selected as a recent and debated issue in the Italian political arena and a field where children’s rights, protection, parental authority and education converge. The case illustrates the challenges of translating international children’s rights standards into domestic policy and provides insight into how civil society advocacy adapts and persists in contexts of political and institutional resistance. The Gruppo CRC case ultimately shows that domestic implementation is not the final stage of international human rights law, but an ongoing arena in which norms are interpreted, negotiated and contested across levels of governance.

Beyond Shadow Reporting: The Italian CRC Group and the Domestic Translation of UN Children's Rights Recommendations

DEACONU, VIRGINIA STEFANIA
2025/2026

Abstract

The effectiveness of international human rights law depends on its capacity to acquire meaning and produce change within domestic contexts. Yet the transmission of international norms into national policy is neither automatic nor linear, but involves processes of interpretation, translation, mobilisation and contestation in which civil society can play a critical role. This thesis examines these processes through the case of the Italian NGO Group for the Convention of the Rights of the Child, known as “Gruppo CRC”, a long-standing coalition of civil society organisations monitoring the implementation of the UNCRC in Italy. Drawing on the concepts of vernacularization, transnational advocacy and multi-level governance, the thesis conceptualises the Gruppo CRC not only as a monitoring actor, but also as an intermediary through which international children’s rights norms are interpreted and translated into domestic advocacy. The analysis examines the coalition’s development, governance, resources, monitoring and advocacy practices, with particular attention to the role of its diverse expertise and multi-level engagement. It culminates in a case study of Comprehensive Sexuality Education, selected as a recent and debated issue in the Italian political arena and a field where children’s rights, protection, parental authority and education converge. The case illustrates the challenges of translating international children’s rights standards into domestic policy and provides insight into how civil society advocacy adapts and persists in contexts of political and institutional resistance. The Gruppo CRC case ultimately shows that domestic implementation is not the final stage of international human rights law, but an ongoing arena in which norms are interpreted, negotiated and contested across levels of governance.
2025
Beyond Shadow Reporting: The Italian CRC Group and the Domestic Translation of UN Children's Rights Recommendations
Children's rights
Civil society
Domestic advocacy
Treaty Bodies
UN
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Deaconu_VirginiaStefania.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 679.34 kB
Formato Adobe PDF
679.34 kB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118165