The increasing integration of artificial intelligence into organizational processes has led to a fundamental change in the decision-making process of performance management. Algorithms and data driven tools are increasingly used to assess employee performance, set targets and support managerial decisions, raising important questions about how employees perceive the fairness of such processes and the extent to which they trust the decisions that result from them. This thesis examines the influence of AI mediated performance management on employee trust and fairness perceptions. The study draws on Colquitt’s (2001) framework of organizational justice, focusing specifically on procedural justice and informational justice, the two dimensions most directly disrupted by algorithmic decision-making, rather than the distributive or interpersonal dimensions. Trust is examined through two complementary frameworks: the ABI model of trust (Mayer et al., 1995), which conceptualizes trust as resting on an employee’s perceived ability, benevolence, and integrity and is directly measured in this study, and trust calibration theory (Lee & See, 2004), which describes how trust should track a system’s actual reliability and serves here as an interpretive lens rather than a directly tested construct. Together, these frameworks investigate the impact of AI mediated performance management on employees’ perceptions of procedural and informational justice, and whether these perceptions mediate the relationship between the source of the performance management decision and employee trust. To address this, a between subjects experimental vignette design is used, and participants are recruited through Prolific. Participants are randomly assigned to either a manager-led or AI-mediated performance management condition and asked to rate their fairness perceptions and trust. The findings of this study intend to contribute to the increasing body of literature on algorithmic management and organizational justice, with practical implications for organizations adopting AI driven performance management systems.

When Algorithms Evaluate: The Impact of AI mediated Performance Management on Employee Trust and Fairness Perceptions

OMANE, BOATEMAH CHRISTIANA
2025/2026

Abstract

The increasing integration of artificial intelligence into organizational processes has led to a fundamental change in the decision-making process of performance management. Algorithms and data driven tools are increasingly used to assess employee performance, set targets and support managerial decisions, raising important questions about how employees perceive the fairness of such processes and the extent to which they trust the decisions that result from them. This thesis examines the influence of AI mediated performance management on employee trust and fairness perceptions. The study draws on Colquitt’s (2001) framework of organizational justice, focusing specifically on procedural justice and informational justice, the two dimensions most directly disrupted by algorithmic decision-making, rather than the distributive or interpersonal dimensions. Trust is examined through two complementary frameworks: the ABI model of trust (Mayer et al., 1995), which conceptualizes trust as resting on an employee’s perceived ability, benevolence, and integrity and is directly measured in this study, and trust calibration theory (Lee & See, 2004), which describes how trust should track a system’s actual reliability and serves here as an interpretive lens rather than a directly tested construct. Together, these frameworks investigate the impact of AI mediated performance management on employees’ perceptions of procedural and informational justice, and whether these perceptions mediate the relationship between the source of the performance management decision and employee trust. To address this, a between subjects experimental vignette design is used, and participants are recruited through Prolific. Participants are randomly assigned to either a manager-led or AI-mediated performance management condition and asked to rate their fairness perceptions and trust. The findings of this study intend to contribute to the increasing body of literature on algorithmic management and organizational justice, with practical implications for organizations adopting AI driven performance management systems.
2025
When Algorithms Evaluate: The Impact of AI mediated Performance Management on Employee Trust and Fairness Perceptions
Algorithmic PM
Employee Trust
Fairness Perceptions
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
OMANE_BOATEMAH CHRISTIANA.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 1.27 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.27 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118893