This thesis develops a methodological and operational tool aimed at supporting designers in material selection and in the definition of environmentally optimized scenarios through the integration of BIM, EPD and LCA. The methodology defines a progressive process that guides product selection through to the assessment of the consequences generated on the overall building model. The procedure begins with the BIM model, from which the quantities of the main building components are extracted and subsequently analysed within the life cycle assessment in order to define a reference baseline model. This model is based on generic datasets, representative of average industry values or specific product categories, and constitutes the basis for comparison in the subsequent assessment of products with EPDs. For each material family, environmental data are therefore collected for specific products with EPDs prepared in accordance with EN 15804+A2. Their comparability is verified by considering the declared unit, namely the quantity of product to which the environmental impacts refer, the system boundaries, corresponding to the life cycle stages included in the analysis, and the technical performance. Through the normalization and weighting of the impact categories, the tool calculates a weighted environmental index for the product, which is used to develop a ranking and identify the potentially preferable product within each family. The selected products are subsequently introduced, one at a time, into the baseline model, generating substitution scenarios useful for assessing their effects on the entire building. The results obtained from each scenario are reprocessed by calculating the percentages of improvement or worsening and a weighted substitution index, used to assess the overall incidence of individual substitutions and to distinguish the most influential ones from those characterized by marginal effects. Finally, the products found to be favourable are combined into a single environmentally optimized scenario among the alternatives analysed, which is compared with the baseline model in order to quantify the overall variation in environmental impacts. The validation of the tool is conducted on the Port Authority Building, part of the new port and tourist complex in Lamezia Terme, intended to accommodate the functions of the maritime terminal, the Harbour Master’s Office, the Port Authority, as well as passenger services. The study also reconstructs the evolution and role of port buildings, examining their typological and functional aspects, and defines the territorial and design framework of the new tourist port. The research concludes with a critical analysis of the two LEED v4 credits directly related to LCA and EPDs, highlighting, for the former, the limitations in methodological compatibility and, for the latter, the difficulties in finding compliant products and documentation.
La presente tesi sviluppa uno strumento metodologico-operativo, finalizzato a supportare il progettista nella selezione dei materiali e nella definizione di scenari ambientalmente ottimizzati mediante l’integrazione tra BIM, EPD e LCA. La metodologia definisce un percorso progressivo che accompagna la scelta dei prodotti fino alla verifica delle conseguenze generate sul modello complessivo dell’edificio. La procedura prende avvio dal modello BIM, dal quale vengono ricavate le quantità dei principali componenti edilizi, successivamente analizzate nell’ambito della valutazione del ciclo di vita per definire un modello baseline di riferimento. Questo modello è basato su dataset generici, rappresentativi di valori medi di settore o di determinate categorie di prodotto, costituendo la base di confronto per la successiva valutazione di prodotti dotati di EPD. Per ciascuna famiglia di materiali vengono quindi raccolti i dati ambientali di prodotti specifici dotati di EPD redatte secondo la norma EN 15804+A2. La loro comparabilità viene verificata considerando l’unità dichiarata, ossia la quantità di prodotto alla quale sono riferiti gli impatti ambientali, i confini di sistema, corrispondenti alle fasi del ciclo di vita incluse nell’analisi, e le prestazioni tecniche. Attraverso la normalizzazione e la pesatura delle categorie di impatto, lo strumento calcola un indice ambientale pesato del prodotto, utilizzato per elaborare una graduatoria e individuare il prodotto potenzialmente preferibile all’interno di ciascuna famiglia. I prodotti selezionati vengono successivamente inseriti, uno alla volta, nel modello baseline, generando scenari di sostituzione utili a valutarne gli effetti sull’intero edificio. I risultati ottenuti da ciascun scenario vengono rielaborati mediante il calcolo delle percentuali di miglioramento o peggioramento e un indice pesato della sostituzione, impiegato per valutare l’incidenza sintetica delle singole sostituzioni e distinguere quelle maggiormente influenti da quelle caratterizzate da effetti marginali. Infine, i prodotti risultati favorevoli vengono combinati in un unico scenario ambientalmente ottimizzato tra le alternative analizzate, confrontato con il modello baseline per quantificare la variazione complessiva degli impatti ambientali. La validazione dello strumento viene condotta sul Port Authority Building, parte del nuovo complesso portuale-turistico di Lamezia Terme, destinato a ospitare le funzioni di stazione marittima, la Capitaneria di Porto, l’Autorità Portuale, oltre ai servizi per i passeggeri. Lo studio ricostruisce inoltre l’evoluzione e il ruolo degli edifici portuali, approfondendone gli aspetti tipologici e funzionali, e definisce il quadro territoriale e progettuale del nuovo porto turistico. La ricerca si conclude con un’analisi critica dei due crediti LEED v4 direttamente connessi alla LCA e alle EPD, evidenziando, per il primo, i limiti di compatibilità metodologica e, per il secondo, le difficoltà nel reperimento di prodotti e documentazioni conformi.
Sviluppo di uno strumento metodologico-operativo per il confronto degli impatti ambientali e la selezione dei prodotti da costruzione mediante EPD e LCA. Validazione sul caso studio Port Authority Building.
ZAMENGO, PIETRO
2025/2026
Abstract
This thesis develops a methodological and operational tool aimed at supporting designers in material selection and in the definition of environmentally optimized scenarios through the integration of BIM, EPD and LCA. The methodology defines a progressive process that guides product selection through to the assessment of the consequences generated on the overall building model. The procedure begins with the BIM model, from which the quantities of the main building components are extracted and subsequently analysed within the life cycle assessment in order to define a reference baseline model. This model is based on generic datasets, representative of average industry values or specific product categories, and constitutes the basis for comparison in the subsequent assessment of products with EPDs. For each material family, environmental data are therefore collected for specific products with EPDs prepared in accordance with EN 15804+A2. Their comparability is verified by considering the declared unit, namely the quantity of product to which the environmental impacts refer, the system boundaries, corresponding to the life cycle stages included in the analysis, and the technical performance. Through the normalization and weighting of the impact categories, the tool calculates a weighted environmental index for the product, which is used to develop a ranking and identify the potentially preferable product within each family. The selected products are subsequently introduced, one at a time, into the baseline model, generating substitution scenarios useful for assessing their effects on the entire building. The results obtained from each scenario are reprocessed by calculating the percentages of improvement or worsening and a weighted substitution index, used to assess the overall incidence of individual substitutions and to distinguish the most influential ones from those characterized by marginal effects. Finally, the products found to be favourable are combined into a single environmentally optimized scenario among the alternatives analysed, which is compared with the baseline model in order to quantify the overall variation in environmental impacts. The validation of the tool is conducted on the Port Authority Building, part of the new port and tourist complex in Lamezia Terme, intended to accommodate the functions of the maritime terminal, the Harbour Master’s Office, the Port Authority, as well as passenger services. The study also reconstructs the evolution and role of port buildings, examining their typological and functional aspects, and defines the territorial and design framework of the new tourist port. The research concludes with a critical analysis of the two LEED v4 credits directly related to LCA and EPDs, highlighting, for the former, the limitations in methodological compatibility and, for the latter, the difficulties in finding compliant products and documentation.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Zamengo_Pietro.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
19.56 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
19.56 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/119060