Training for audiologists requires the development of advanced practical and manual skills, such as Real Ear Measurement (REM) and impression taking, traditionally acquired directly on patients during clinical training. However, this approach can cause discomfort in patients and performance anxiety in students, making the adoption of effective and safe teaching tools essential. In line with a now consolidated trend throughout the healthcare sector, which increasingly relies on simulation, both through software and high-fidelity mannequins, the use of the CARL (Computer-Assisted Real -Life) anatomical simulator at the University of Padua is now in place. This study aims to examine the teaching effectiveness, pedagogical impact, and student perceptions of integrating the CARL simulator into the curriculum, evaluating aspects such as ease of use, development of practical skills, psychological safety of the learning environment, and opportunities for theory-practice integration. A cross-sectional quantitative study was conducted using a structured questionnaire, administered voluntarily and anonymously, consisting of 22 questions on a 5-point Likert scale and open-ended questions. A sample of 35 current and former students of the Degree Program in Hearing Aid Techniques at the University of Padua answered the questionnaire. The collected data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, inferential t-tests for gender comparisons, correlation coefficients with age, and thematic analysis of qualitative responses. Data analysis revealed a high level of satisfaction with the CARL experience (mean M = 4.60, SD = 0.54). Students particularly appreciated the opportunity to practice without the pressure of a real patient (M = 4.40) and the safety of the training environment, which allows for learning from mistakes (M = 4.34). There was a strong demand for expanded use of the simulator (M = 4.71), with particularly high satisfaction among female students (M = 4.94 vs. M = 4.47; p < 0.01, Cohen's d = 0.95). Qualitative analyses confirm that CARL improves manual dexterity and safety in REM procedures. One of the main limitations reported concerns the stiffness of the ear material compared to human tissue. The integration of the CARL simulator represents a significant pedagogical innovation for the acquisition of technical and manual skills and for reducing performance anxiety prior to clinical practice on patients. While it does not replace direct clinical experience, simulation remains a universal and inclusive tool, in line with developments in contemporary healthcare education, and highly sought after by students to optimize their hearing aid training.
La formazione del Tecnico Audioprotesista richiede lo sviluppo di competenze pratiche e manuali avanzate, come la misurazione Real Ear Measurement (REM) e le prese d’impronta, tradizionalmente acquisite direttamente sui pazienti durante il tirocinio clinico. Tuttavia, questo approccio può causare disagio nei pazienti e ansia da prestazione negli studenti, rendendo fondamentale l’adozione di strumenti didattici efficaci e sicuri. In linea con una tendenza ormai consolidata in tutto il settore della salute, che fa sempre più ricorso alla simulazione sia tramite software sia attraverso manichini ad alta fedeltà, si inserisce l’utilizzo del simulatore anatomico CARL (Computer-Assisted Real-Life) presso l’Università degli Studi di Padova. Questo studio propone di esaminare l’efficacia didattica, l’impatto pedagogico e la percezione degli studenti rispetto all’integrazione del simulatore CARL nel percorso formativo, valutando aspetti come la facilità d’uso, lo sviluppo delle competenze pratiche, la sicurezza psicologica dell’ambiente d’apprendimento e le opportunità di integrazione teoria-pratica. È stato condotto uno studio quantitativo trasversale (cross-sectional) attraverso un questionario strutturato, somministrato su base volontaria e in forma anonima, composto da 22 domande su scala Likert a 5 punti e domande aperte a un campione di 35 studenti ed ex-studenti del Corso di Laurea in Tecniche Audioprotesiche dell’Ateneo di Padova. I dati raccolti sono stati analizzati con statistiche descrittive, t-test inferenziali per il confronto di genere, coefficienti di correlazione con l’età e analisi tematica delle risposte qualitative. L’analisi dei dati ha evidenziato un alto livello di soddisfazione per l’esperienza con CARL (media M = 4,60, DS = 0,54). Gli studenti hanno apprezzato soprattutto la possibilità di esercitarsi senza la pressione derivante dalla presenza del paziente reale (M = 4,40) e la sicurezza dell’ambiente formativo che permette di apprendere dagli errori (M = 4,34). È emersa una forte richiesta di ampliare l’uso del simulatore (M = 4,71), con un gradimento particolarmente elevato tra le studentesse (M = 4,94 vs M = 4,47; p < 0,01, Cohen’s d = 0,95). Le analisi qualitative confermano che CARL migliora la destrezza manuale e la sicurezza nelle procedure REM. Uno dei limiti principali segnalati riguarda la rigidità del materiale dell’orecchio rispetto ai tessuti umani. L’integrazione del simulatore CARL rappresenta un’importante innovazione pedagogica per l’acquisizione di abilità tecnico-manuali e per ridurre l’ansia da prestazione prima della pratica clinica sul paziente. Sebbene non sostituisca l’esperienza clinica diretta, la simulazione si conferma uno strumento universale e inclusivo, in linea con le evoluzioni della formazione sanitaria contemporanea, e fortemente richiesto dagli studenti per ottimizzare il loro percorso formativo audioprotesico.
Innovazione pedagogica nella formazione audioprotesica: analisi dell’esperienza con CARL
DI TROIA, ILARIA
2025/2026
Abstract
Training for audiologists requires the development of advanced practical and manual skills, such as Real Ear Measurement (REM) and impression taking, traditionally acquired directly on patients during clinical training. However, this approach can cause discomfort in patients and performance anxiety in students, making the adoption of effective and safe teaching tools essential. In line with a now consolidated trend throughout the healthcare sector, which increasingly relies on simulation, both through software and high-fidelity mannequins, the use of the CARL (Computer-Assisted Real -Life) anatomical simulator at the University of Padua is now in place. This study aims to examine the teaching effectiveness, pedagogical impact, and student perceptions of integrating the CARL simulator into the curriculum, evaluating aspects such as ease of use, development of practical skills, psychological safety of the learning environment, and opportunities for theory-practice integration. A cross-sectional quantitative study was conducted using a structured questionnaire, administered voluntarily and anonymously, consisting of 22 questions on a 5-point Likert scale and open-ended questions. A sample of 35 current and former students of the Degree Program in Hearing Aid Techniques at the University of Padua answered the questionnaire. The collected data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, inferential t-tests for gender comparisons, correlation coefficients with age, and thematic analysis of qualitative responses. Data analysis revealed a high level of satisfaction with the CARL experience (mean M = 4.60, SD = 0.54). Students particularly appreciated the opportunity to practice without the pressure of a real patient (M = 4.40) and the safety of the training environment, which allows for learning from mistakes (M = 4.34). There was a strong demand for expanded use of the simulator (M = 4.71), with particularly high satisfaction among female students (M = 4.94 vs. M = 4.47; p < 0.01, Cohen's d = 0.95). Qualitative analyses confirm that CARL improves manual dexterity and safety in REM procedures. One of the main limitations reported concerns the stiffness of the ear material compared to human tissue. The integration of the CARL simulator represents a significant pedagogical innovation for the acquisition of technical and manual skills and for reducing performance anxiety prior to clinical practice on patients. While it does not replace direct clinical experience, simulation remains a universal and inclusive tool, in line with developments in contemporary healthcare education, and highly sought after by students to optimize their hearing aid training.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Di Troia_Ilaria.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
1.73 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.73 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/119537