Introduction: Major trauma remains a leading cause of preventable death, especially when initial management does not meet the strict "Golden Hour" timeframes. The ABCDE assessment of polytrauma patients is usually entrusted to the operator's memory, a method that demonstrates its limitations precisely at times of greatest pressure, when stress and cognitive overload increase the risk of omitting fundamental maneuvers. For this reason, in contexts with high cognitive load, safety checklists are adopted to ensure that no critical maneuvers are missed. Objective: This study investigates whether the introduction of the WHO Trauma Care Checklist, as a cognitive aid, reduces mortality in the most severely ill patients, improves adherence to ATLS/PHTLS protocols, impacts intervention times, and reduces the team's mental burden in high-pressure settings. Methods: A PubMed, Embase, and CINAHL search was conducted, supplemented with relevant guidelines and articles, selecting studies on adult patients with major trauma in the pre-hospital and in-hospital first emergency settings, excluding surgical checklists, pediatric population, and studies focused only on cost or patient satisfaction. Results: The use of the checklist significantly increases adherence to protocols and, in patients with ISS ≥ 25, reduces mortality by up to 50%. Unrecognized injuries are drastically reduced, and surgery times do not worsen, in fact in several cases they improve thanks to a more organized team. However, practical barriers remain: resistance to change, professional hierarchies, and the perception of wasted time. Success depends on adaptation to the local context, ongoing training and staff involvement. Conclusions: The systematic integration of the WHO Trauma Care Checklist allows for the standardization of lifesaving maneuvers, reduction of omissions, improvement of intervention times and team communication. Since it is a time-dependent condition, every minute gained translates into a real chance of survival for the polytraumatized patient.
Introduzione: Il trauma maggiore resta una delle principali cause di morte evitabile, soprattutto quando la gestione iniziale non rispetta i tempi stretti della "Golden Hour". La valutazione ABCDE del paziente politraumatizzato viene solitamente affidata alla memoria dell'operatore, un metodo che mostra i suoi limiti proprio nei momenti di maggiore pressione, quando stress e sovraccarico cognitivo aumentano il rischio di omettere manovre fondamentali. Per questo, in contesti ad alto carico cognitivo, vengono adottate checklist di sicurezza per garantire che nessuna manovra critica venga tralasciata. Obiettivo: Il lavoro indaga se l'introduzione della WHO Trauma Care Checklist, quale ausilio cognitivo, riduca la mortalità nei pazienti più gravi, migliori l'aderenza ai protocolli ATLS/PHTLS, incida sui tempi di intervento e riduca il carico mentale del team in contesti ad alta pressione. Metodi: È stata condotta una ricerca su PubMed, Embase e CINAHL, integrata con linee guida e articoli pertinenti, selezionando studi su pazienti adulti con trauma maggiore in ambito pre-ospedaliero e di prima emergenza intra-ospedaliera, escludendo checklist chirurgiche, popolazione pediatrica e studi centrati solo su costi o soddisfazione del paziente. Risultati: L'uso della checklist aumenta significativamente l'aderenza ai protocolli e, nei pazienti con ISS ≥ 25, riduce la mortalità fino al 50%. Le lesioni misconosciute si riducono drasticamente, e i tempi di intervento non peggiorano, anzi in diversi casi migliorano grazie a un team più organizzato. Permangono tuttavia barriere pratiche: resistenza al cambiamento, gerarchie professionali e percezione di perdita di tempo. Il successo dipende da adattamento al contesto locale, formazione continua e coinvolgimento del personale. Conclusioni: L'integrazione sistematica della WHO Trauma Care Checklist consente di standardizzare le manovre salvavita, ridurre le omissioni, migliorare i tempi d'intervento e la comunicazione d'équipe. Trattandosi di una condizione tempo-dipendente, ogni minuto guadagnato si traduce in una reale possibilità di sopravvivenza per il paziente politraumatizzato.
Ridurre la mortalità nel politrauma: la WHO Trauma Care Checklist come strumento di supporto al team infermieristico.
MONTIN, NICOLE
2025/2026
Abstract
Introduction: Major trauma remains a leading cause of preventable death, especially when initial management does not meet the strict "Golden Hour" timeframes. The ABCDE assessment of polytrauma patients is usually entrusted to the operator's memory, a method that demonstrates its limitations precisely at times of greatest pressure, when stress and cognitive overload increase the risk of omitting fundamental maneuvers. For this reason, in contexts with high cognitive load, safety checklists are adopted to ensure that no critical maneuvers are missed. Objective: This study investigates whether the introduction of the WHO Trauma Care Checklist, as a cognitive aid, reduces mortality in the most severely ill patients, improves adherence to ATLS/PHTLS protocols, impacts intervention times, and reduces the team's mental burden in high-pressure settings. Methods: A PubMed, Embase, and CINAHL search was conducted, supplemented with relevant guidelines and articles, selecting studies on adult patients with major trauma in the pre-hospital and in-hospital first emergency settings, excluding surgical checklists, pediatric population, and studies focused only on cost or patient satisfaction. Results: The use of the checklist significantly increases adherence to protocols and, in patients with ISS ≥ 25, reduces mortality by up to 50%. Unrecognized injuries are drastically reduced, and surgery times do not worsen, in fact in several cases they improve thanks to a more organized team. However, practical barriers remain: resistance to change, professional hierarchies, and the perception of wasted time. Success depends on adaptation to the local context, ongoing training and staff involvement. Conclusions: The systematic integration of the WHO Trauma Care Checklist allows for the standardization of lifesaving maneuvers, reduction of omissions, improvement of intervention times and team communication. Since it is a time-dependent condition, every minute gained translates into a real chance of survival for the polytraumatized patient.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
TESI_DEFINITIVA_MONTIN_1.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
1.7 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.7 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/119848