Obesity is a chronic, multifactorial disease with significant physical, psychological, and behavioral implications, which make long-term lifestyle change and weight management complex. Motivational Interviewing (MI)—based on the model developed by Miller and Rollnick—employs a person-centered approach that fosters autonomy and self-efficacy. With its non-prescriptive style and focus on exploring ambivalence, MI has been proposed as a potentially useful nursing tool to facilitate lifestyle change in individuals who are overweight or obese. However, the evidence regarding the effectiveness of MI when delivered by nursing staff for the management of overweight and obesity remains not yet fully defined; furthermore, the specific characteristics of such interventions that correlate with the most positive outcomes are not yet well established. The objective is to analyze the effectiveness of Motivational Interviewing delivered by nurses to adults who are overweight or obese, by evaluating its physical, psychological, and behavioral effects and identifying the intervention characteristics that significantly correlate with the best outcomes. The sample examined includes adults aged ≥18 years who are overweight and/or obese, defined by a BMI of ≥25 kg/m² or ≥30 kg/m². The studies considered were conducted across various care settings, including primary care, hospital environments, and follow-up contexts. In all the studies, the MI was administered by nursing staff, involving a total of over 6,000 individuals. The literature review was conducted by searching electronic databases such as PubMed, CINAHL, and Google Scholar, covering studies published over the last 14 years and including both prospective single-center studies and randomized controlled trials (RCTs). The selection process resulted in the inclusion of eight studies, published between 2012 and 2025. The outcomes reported in the analyzed studies are heterogeneous; however, specific elements of Motivational Interviewing (MI) consistently emerged as significant. These outcomes relate to physiological changes (weight loss, anthropometric parameters), behavioral changes (reduced sedentary behavior, modifications in eating habits), and perceptions of well-being (psychosocial well-being, mood, and stress levels). The characteristics of MI—when delivered by nurses—that appear most significant for achieving positive outcomes pertain to the style of the interaction, which is marked by empathy and a non-directive approach, as well as a focus on enhancing patient autonomy. These elements align with the structure of MI as defined by the Miller and Rollnick model. It was observed that studies incorporating a greater number of components from the Miller and Rollnick MI model reported more favorable results, although it is not possible to establish a direct causal link between individual components and specific outcomes. In conclusion, while MI delivered by nurses cannot be considered a universally effective intervention, it serves as a useful option to integrate into the care of individuals who are overweight and/or obese—particularly for fostering physical changes, behavioral shifts, and improvements in the perception of well-being. This review highlights that MI, when conducted by nurses, is associated with better outcomes when it incorporates elements derived from the core components of the Miller and Rollnick MI framework: the OARS skills and the four processes. Further research is therefore required to determine which specific components of MI are significantly correlated with these outcomes. A study on the systematic and standardized use of MI, following the Miller and Rollnick model, could clarify which features of the intervention are significantly associated with achieving and maintaining lifestyle changes in individuals who are overweight or obese.
L'obesità è una malattia cronica multifattoriale con rilevanti implicazioni fisiche, psicologiche e comportamentali, che rendono complesso il cambiamento dello stile di vita e la gestione del peso nel lungo periodo. Il colloquio motivazionale (MI), secondo il modello di Miller e Rollnick, basato su un approccio centrato sulla persona, sul sostegno dell'autonomia e dell'autoefficacia, con il suo stile non prescrittivo e con l'esplorazione dell'ambivalenza, è stato proposto come strumento infermieristico potenzialmente utile per facilitare il cambiamento dello stile di vita del paziente sovrappeso e obeso. Tuttavia, le evidenze sull'efficacia del MI condotto dal personale infermieristico nella gestione del sovrappeso e dell'obesità risultano non ancora pienamente definite, così come non sono ancora ben definite le caratteristiche dell'intervento che correlano con i maggior esiti positivi. Analizzare l'efficacia del colloquio motivazionale condotto da infermieri negli adulti con sovrappeso ed obesità, valutandone gli effetti fisici, psicologici, comportamentali ed identificando le caratteristiche che correlano in modo significativo con i migliori outcome. Il campione preso in esame include adulti di età ≥18 anni, con sovrappeso e/o obesità, sulla base di un BMI ≥25 kg/m² o ≥30 kg/m². Gli studi presi in considerazione sono stati condotti in diversi setting assistenziali, tra cui Primary care, setting ospedalieri e follow-up. In tutti gli studi il MI è stato eseguito da personale infermieristico ed ha coinvolto oltre 6,000 persone. La revisione della letteratura è stata effettuata consultando database elettronici come PubMed, CINAHL e Google Scholar, includendo studi pubblicati negli ultimi 14 anni e considerando studi monocentrici prospettici e RCT. Il percorso di selezione ha portato all’inclusione di otto studi, con pubblicazione compresa tra il 2012 e il 2025. Gli outcome riportati negli studi analizzati sono eterogenei, ma sono emersi degli elementi specifici del MI che in modo trasversale sono stati identificati come significativi. Gli outcome si riferiscono a cambiamenti fisiologici (calo ponderale, parametri antropometrici), comportamentali (riduzione della sedentarietà, modifica della condotta alimentare) e di percezione di benessere (benessere 2psico-sociale; tono dell’umore; stress). Le caratteristiche del colloquio motivazionale infermieristico che risultano essere più significative per il raggiungimento di outcome positivi sono inerenti lo stile di conduzione dello stesso, caratterizzato da empatia e non direttività, oltre che al focus sul potenziamento dell’autonomia del paziente. Tali elementi sono riconducibili alla struttura del MI secondo il modello di Miller e Rollnick. Si è notato che gli studi con una maggiore presenza di componenti del MI di Miller e Rollnick riportano risultati più favorevoli, senza tuttavia consentire di stabilire una relazione causale tra singole componenti e outcome specifici. In conclusione, il MI infermieristico non può essere considerato un intervento universalmente efficace, ma può costituire un'opzione utile da integrare nella presa in carico delle persone in sovrappeso e/o obese, in particolar modo per favorire un cambiamento fisico, nei comportamenti e nella percezione di benessere. La revisione evidenzia che il MI condotto da infermieri è associato ad outcome migliori quando vi è la presenza di elementi riconducibili alle componenti fondamentali del metodo MI di Miller e Rollnick: OARS ed i quattro processi. Sono quindi necessari ulteriori studi per definire quali componenti del MI si correlino significativamente agli outcome. Uno studio sull’utilizzo sistematico e standardizzato del MI secondo il modello di Miller e Rollnick potrebbe chiarire quali caratteristiche dell'intervento siano significativamente associate al raggiungimento e mantenimento del cambiamento dello stile di vita nelle persone sovrappeso ed obese.
Il Colloquio Motivazionale Infermieristico nella Gestione del Sovrappeso e dell’Obesità: caratteristiche ed outcome
BIASETTO, NICOLO'
2025/2026
Abstract
Obesity is a chronic, multifactorial disease with significant physical, psychological, and behavioral implications, which make long-term lifestyle change and weight management complex. Motivational Interviewing (MI)—based on the model developed by Miller and Rollnick—employs a person-centered approach that fosters autonomy and self-efficacy. With its non-prescriptive style and focus on exploring ambivalence, MI has been proposed as a potentially useful nursing tool to facilitate lifestyle change in individuals who are overweight or obese. However, the evidence regarding the effectiveness of MI when delivered by nursing staff for the management of overweight and obesity remains not yet fully defined; furthermore, the specific characteristics of such interventions that correlate with the most positive outcomes are not yet well established. The objective is to analyze the effectiveness of Motivational Interviewing delivered by nurses to adults who are overweight or obese, by evaluating its physical, psychological, and behavioral effects and identifying the intervention characteristics that significantly correlate with the best outcomes. The sample examined includes adults aged ≥18 years who are overweight and/or obese, defined by a BMI of ≥25 kg/m² or ≥30 kg/m². The studies considered were conducted across various care settings, including primary care, hospital environments, and follow-up contexts. In all the studies, the MI was administered by nursing staff, involving a total of over 6,000 individuals. The literature review was conducted by searching electronic databases such as PubMed, CINAHL, and Google Scholar, covering studies published over the last 14 years and including both prospective single-center studies and randomized controlled trials (RCTs). The selection process resulted in the inclusion of eight studies, published between 2012 and 2025. The outcomes reported in the analyzed studies are heterogeneous; however, specific elements of Motivational Interviewing (MI) consistently emerged as significant. These outcomes relate to physiological changes (weight loss, anthropometric parameters), behavioral changes (reduced sedentary behavior, modifications in eating habits), and perceptions of well-being (psychosocial well-being, mood, and stress levels). The characteristics of MI—when delivered by nurses—that appear most significant for achieving positive outcomes pertain to the style of the interaction, which is marked by empathy and a non-directive approach, as well as a focus on enhancing patient autonomy. These elements align with the structure of MI as defined by the Miller and Rollnick model. It was observed that studies incorporating a greater number of components from the Miller and Rollnick MI model reported more favorable results, although it is not possible to establish a direct causal link between individual components and specific outcomes. In conclusion, while MI delivered by nurses cannot be considered a universally effective intervention, it serves as a useful option to integrate into the care of individuals who are overweight and/or obese—particularly for fostering physical changes, behavioral shifts, and improvements in the perception of well-being. This review highlights that MI, when conducted by nurses, is associated with better outcomes when it incorporates elements derived from the core components of the Miller and Rollnick MI framework: the OARS skills and the four processes. Further research is therefore required to determine which specific components of MI are significantly correlated with these outcomes. A study on the systematic and standardized use of MI, following the Miller and Rollnick model, could clarify which features of the intervention are significantly associated with achieving and maintaining lifestyle changes in individuals who are overweight or obese.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Biasetto_Nicolò_2121282.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
698.54 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
698.54 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/120190