Background: Donation after Circulatory Death (DCD) represents a complex clinical and care pathway that integrates end-of-life management with the possibility of organ donation. The process requires specialized skills, multi-professional coordination, and careful attention to ethical, relational, and organizational aspects. In this context, critical care nurses play a key role in managing potential donors, implementing procedures, and providing support to the individual and their family. It is therefore important to examine nurses' knowledge, perceived confidence, and educational needs in order to identify the primary challenges within this pathway. Aim and Objectives: This study aims to explore nurses' knowledge, training, and perceived confidence regarding the management of Type III DCD, with a focus on organizational challenges, multi-professional collaboration, ethical and emotional considerations, and educational needs. Materials and Methods: A descriptive-analytical cross-sectional observational study was conducted, preceded by a review of the scientific literature. Between late August and mid-October 2026, an anonymous, self-administered online questionnaire—consisting of 45 items—was distributed to nurses working in emergency departments and intensive care units at two hospitals in the Veneto region. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and statistical tests for exploratory comparisons between subgroups, with the Holm correction applied for multiple comparisons where appropriate. Results: Among the 64 participants, 75% stated that they understood the meaning of Type III DCD; however, only 25.0% reported having received specific training, and 39.1% indicated that they had directly participated in at least one such donation process. The five questions regarding objective knowledge, posed to the 25 nurses with direct experience, yielded correct response rates ranging from 91.7% to 100%. However, only 20% indicated that they were "somewhat" or "completely" confident in their ability to recognize when to initiate the donation pathway in a timely manner. Furthermore, while 80% acknowledged the importance of a structured organization for ensuring quality of care, only 40.0% agreed that clear protocols were in place within their own work environment. Consistent with these challenges, 60.9% of the entire sample identified the enhancement of training as a priority intervention, while 81.3% recognized the value of debriefing. Finally, from an ethical perspective, nurses with direct experience provided less favorable assessments—on average—than those without such experience regarding the ability of the DCD (Donation after Circulatory Death) process to ensure dignity and respect for the individual at the end of life. Conclusions: The findings suggest a potential discrepancy between theoretical knowledge and perceived operational confidence, highlighting the importance of specialized training, shared procedures, and effective multiprofessional coordination. There is also a clear need to address ethical and emotional aspects, as well as the provision of support for family members. The study’s limitations—including the sample size, the use of non-probabilistic sampling, the inclusion of only two healthcare facilities, and the lack of formal psychometric validation of the questionnaire—restrict the generalizability of the results. Keywords: controlled donation after circulatory death, cDCD, DCD type III, nursing care, critical care area, emergency department, intensive care, training, safety, care protocols
Background: la donazione a cuore fermo controllato (Donation after Circulatory Death, DCD), rappresenta un percorso clinico-assistenziale complesso, che integra la gestione del fine vita con la possibilità di donazione. Il processo richiede competenze specifiche, coordinamento multiprofessionale e attenzione agli aspetti etici, relazionali ed organizzativi. In tale contesto, l’infermiere di area critica contribuisce alla gestione del potenziale donatore, all’applicazione delle procedure e al supporto della persona e dei suoi familiari. Risulta pertanto rilevante approfondire le conoscenze, la sicurezza percepita e i bisogni formativi degli infermieri, al fine di individuare le principali criticità del percorso. Finalità e obiettivi: lo studio si propone di esplorare le conoscenze, la formazione e la sicurezza percepita dagli infermieri nella gestione della DCD di tipo III, approfondendo le criticità organizzative, la collaborazione multiprofessionale, gli aspetti etici, emotivi e i bisogni formativi Materiali e metodi: è stato condotto uno studio osservazionale trasversale descrittivo-analitico, preceduto da una revisione della letteratura scientifica. Tra la fine di agosto e la prima metà di ottobre 2026 è stato somministrato un questionario anonimo e autosomministrato online, composto da 45 item, a infermieri di pronto soccorso e terapia intensiva di due strutture ospedaliere del Veneto. I dati sono stati analizzati mediante statistiche descrittive e test statistici per i confronti esplorativi tra sottogruppi, applicando la correzione di Holm per confronti multipli, ove prevista. Risultati: Su 64 partecipanti, il 75% ha dichiarato di conoscere il significato della DCD di tipo III, ma solo il 25,0% ha riferito di aver ricevuto una formazione specifica e il 39,1% di aver partecipato direttamente ad almeno un percorso. Le cinque domande sulle conoscenze oggettive, rivolte ai 25 infermieri con esperienza diretta, hanno registrato percentuali di risposta corretta, comprese tra il 91,7% e il 100%. Tuttavia, solo il solo il 20% si è dichiarato abbastanza o completamente d’accordo con la propria capacità di riconoscere tempestivamente quando attivare il percorso. Inoltre, sebbene l’80% abbia riconosciuto l’importanza di un’organizzazione strutturata per la qualità assistenziale, soltanto il 40,0% ha espresso accordo sulla presenza di protocolli chiari nel proprio contesto lavorativo. In linea con queste criticità, il 60,9% dell’intero campione ha indicato il potenziamento della formazione come intervento prioritario, mentre l’81,3% ha riconosciuto l’utilità del debriefing. Sul piano etico, infine, gli infermieri con esperienza diretta hanno espresso valutazioni mediamente meno favorevoli rispetto a quelli senza tale esperienza sulla capacità della DCD di garantire dignità e rispetto della persona nel fine vita. Conclusioni: I risultati suggeriscono una possibile discrepanza tra conoscenze teoriche e sicurezza operativa percepita, evidenziando l'importanza della formazione specifica, di procedure condivise e di un adeguato coordinamento multiprofessionale. Emergono inoltre esigenze di attenzione agli aspetti etici ed emotivi e al supporto dei familiari. La numerosità del campione, il campionamento non probabilistico, il coinvolgimento di due sole strutture e la mancata validazione psicometrica formale del questionario limitano la generalizzabilità dei risultati. Parole chiave: donazione controllata dopo accertamento della morte cardiocircolatoria, cDCD, DCD di tipo III, assistenza infermieristica, area critica, pronto soccorso, terapia intensiva, formazione, sicurezza, protocolli assistenziali
L'infermiere nella donazione a cuore fermo controllato: competenze tecniche e valore umano
SILVESTRIN, RACHELE
2025/2026
Abstract
Background: Donation after Circulatory Death (DCD) represents a complex clinical and care pathway that integrates end-of-life management with the possibility of organ donation. The process requires specialized skills, multi-professional coordination, and careful attention to ethical, relational, and organizational aspects. In this context, critical care nurses play a key role in managing potential donors, implementing procedures, and providing support to the individual and their family. It is therefore important to examine nurses' knowledge, perceived confidence, and educational needs in order to identify the primary challenges within this pathway. Aim and Objectives: This study aims to explore nurses' knowledge, training, and perceived confidence regarding the management of Type III DCD, with a focus on organizational challenges, multi-professional collaboration, ethical and emotional considerations, and educational needs. Materials and Methods: A descriptive-analytical cross-sectional observational study was conducted, preceded by a review of the scientific literature. Between late August and mid-October 2026, an anonymous, self-administered online questionnaire—consisting of 45 items—was distributed to nurses working in emergency departments and intensive care units at two hospitals in the Veneto region. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and statistical tests for exploratory comparisons between subgroups, with the Holm correction applied for multiple comparisons where appropriate. Results: Among the 64 participants, 75% stated that they understood the meaning of Type III DCD; however, only 25.0% reported having received specific training, and 39.1% indicated that they had directly participated in at least one such donation process. The five questions regarding objective knowledge, posed to the 25 nurses with direct experience, yielded correct response rates ranging from 91.7% to 100%. However, only 20% indicated that they were "somewhat" or "completely" confident in their ability to recognize when to initiate the donation pathway in a timely manner. Furthermore, while 80% acknowledged the importance of a structured organization for ensuring quality of care, only 40.0% agreed that clear protocols were in place within their own work environment. Consistent with these challenges, 60.9% of the entire sample identified the enhancement of training as a priority intervention, while 81.3% recognized the value of debriefing. Finally, from an ethical perspective, nurses with direct experience provided less favorable assessments—on average—than those without such experience regarding the ability of the DCD (Donation after Circulatory Death) process to ensure dignity and respect for the individual at the end of life. Conclusions: The findings suggest a potential discrepancy between theoretical knowledge and perceived operational confidence, highlighting the importance of specialized training, shared procedures, and effective multiprofessional coordination. There is also a clear need to address ethical and emotional aspects, as well as the provision of support for family members. The study’s limitations—including the sample size, the use of non-probabilistic sampling, the inclusion of only two healthcare facilities, and the lack of formal psychometric validation of the questionnaire—restrict the generalizability of the results. Keywords: controlled donation after circulatory death, cDCD, DCD type III, nursing care, critical care area, emergency department, intensive care, training, safety, care protocols| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
TESI SILVESTRIN RACHELE.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
1.52 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.52 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/120266