Background: Implicit biases are automatic and often unconscious associations that can influence patient perception, clinical decision-making, and the quality of nursing care. The available literature has documented the presence of biases related to race and ethnicity, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, obesity, and age, also highlighting a potential discrepancy between explicit and implicit attitudes. Objective: To analyze the available literature on the presence and characteristics of implicit bias among nurses and nursing students, with a focus on its potential impact on patient care, and to identify the primary educational and organizational strategies aimed at its mitigation. Methods: A literature review was conducted via a search on PubMed, following the stages recommended by the PRISMA framework. Following initial title screening, records were assessed based on their relevance to the nursing population, the presence of implicit or unconscious bias, the analysis of its prevalence or mitigation strategies, and the availability of the full text. The final synthesis included 13 unique studies published between 2017 and 2025. The final corpus comprised one literature review, six quantitative cross-sectional studies or secondary analyses of quantitative data, one quantitative study utilizing randomized clinical vignettes, three descriptive qualitative studies, one mixed-methods longitudinal evaluation with an uncontrolled pre-post design, and one descriptive evaluation of an educational intervention. Results: The analyzed studies demonstrated the presence of implicit bias among nurses and nursing students across various healthcare settings. Specifically, negative implicit associations emerged regarding racial and ethnic minorities, lesbian, gay, and transgender individuals, people with disabilities, and patients with obesity. In several studies, explicit attitudes were more positive than implicit attitudes, suggesting that self-reported measures may not fully capture participants' automatic associations. Identified mitigation strategies included self-reflection, self-assessment using the Implicit Association Test (IAT), targeted training, guided discussion, simulation, the enhancement of communication skills, and the integration of bias awareness into nursing curricula. Educational interventions generally yielded an increase in awareness and knowledge; however, evidence regarding changes in caregiving behaviors and long-term effects remained limited. An overall prevalence was not calculated due to heterogeneity across study populations, measurement tools, bias types, and methodological designs. Conclusions: Implicit bias represents a significant phenomenon within the nursing profession and may pose a barrier to delivering equitable and inclusive care. Educational initiatives should begin during undergraduate education and continue into professional practice through ongoing interventions grounded in self-reflection, simulation, communication, and cultural competence development. However, individual strategies must be integrated with organizational and institutional interventions. Longitudinal studies, more representative samples, control groups, and clinical outcome measures are required to determine whether reductions in perceived bias translate into tangible improvements in professional practice and quality of care.
Contesto: I bias impliciti sono associazioni automatiche e spesso inconsapevoli che possono influenzare la percezione dei pazienti, il processo decisionale clinico e la qualità dell’assistenza infermieristica. La letteratura disponibile ha documentato la presenza di bias associati alla razza e all’etnia, all’orientamento sessuale, all’identità di genere, alla disabilità, all’obesità e all’età, evidenziando anche una possibile discrepanza tra atteggiamenti espliciti e atteggiamenti impliciti. Obiettivo: Analizzare la letteratura disponibile sulla presenza e sulle caratteristiche dei bias impliciti negli infermieri e negli studenti infermieri, con particolare attenzione alla loro possibile influenza sull’assistenza, e individuare le principali strategie educative e organizzative finalizzate alla loro mitigazione. Metodi: È stata condotta una revisione della letteratura attraverso una ricerca bibliografica su PubMed, seguendo le fasi raccomandate dal metodo PRISMA. Dopo lo screening iniziale dei titoli, sono stati valutati i record in base alla pertinenza rispetto alla popolazione infermieristica, alla presenza di bias impliciti o inconsci, all’analisi della loro prevalenza o delle strategie di mitigazione e alla disponibilità del testo completo. La sintesi finale ha incluso 13 studi unici pubblicati tra il 2017 e il 2025. Il corpus comprendeva una revisione della letteratura, sei studi quantitativi trasversali o analisi secondarie di dati quantitativi, uno studio quantitativo con vignette cliniche randomizzate, tre studi qualitativi descrittivi, una valutazione longitudinale mixed methods con disegno pre-post non controllato e una valutazione descrittiva di un intervento educativo. Risultati: Gli studi analizzati hanno evidenziato la presenza di bias impliciti tra infermieri e studenti infermieri in diversi ambiti assistenziali. In particolare, sono emerse associazioni implicite negative verso persone appartenenti a minoranze razziali ed etniche, persone lesbiche, gay e transgender, persone con disabilità e pazienti con obesità. In diversi lavori gli atteggiamenti espliciti risultavano più positivi rispetto agli atteggiamenti impliciti, suggerendo che le misure autoriportate potrebbero non riflettere pienamente le associazioni automatiche dei partecipanti. Le strategie di mitigazione individuate comprendevano l’autoriflessione, l’autovalutazione mediante IAT, la formazione specifica, la discussione guidata, la simulazione, il miglioramento delle competenze comunicative e l’integrazione della consapevolezza del bias nei curricula infermieristici. Gli interventi formativi hanno generalmente prodotto un aumento della consapevolezza e delle conoscenze, ma le evidenze relative alla modifica dei comportamenti assistenziali e agli effetti a lungo termine sono risultate limitate. Non è stata calcolata una prevalenza complessiva, poiché gli studi presentavano popolazioni, strumenti di misurazione, tipologie di bias e disegni metodologici differenti. Conclusioni: I bias impliciti rappresentano un fenomeno rilevante anche nell’ambito infermieristico e possono costituire un ostacolo alla realizzazione di un’assistenza equa e inclusiva. La formazione dovrebbe iniziare durante il percorso universitario e proseguire nella pratica professionale attraverso interventi continuativi basati su autoriflessione, simulazione, comunicazione e sviluppo delle competenze culturali. Tuttavia, le strategie individuali dovrebbero essere integrate con interventi organizzativi e istituzionali. Sono necessari studi longitudinali, campioni più rappresentativi, gruppi di controllo e misure degli esiti assistenziali per valutare se la riduzione del bias percepito corrisponda a un effettivo miglioramento dei comportamenti professionali e della qualità delle cure.
Oltre il pregiudizio inconscio: bias impliciti nella pratica infermieristica e strategie per garantire l'equità delle cure.
UNGARO, LEONARDO
2025/2026
Abstract
Background: Implicit biases are automatic and often unconscious associations that can influence patient perception, clinical decision-making, and the quality of nursing care. The available literature has documented the presence of biases related to race and ethnicity, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, obesity, and age, also highlighting a potential discrepancy between explicit and implicit attitudes. Objective: To analyze the available literature on the presence and characteristics of implicit bias among nurses and nursing students, with a focus on its potential impact on patient care, and to identify the primary educational and organizational strategies aimed at its mitigation. Methods: A literature review was conducted via a search on PubMed, following the stages recommended by the PRISMA framework. Following initial title screening, records were assessed based on their relevance to the nursing population, the presence of implicit or unconscious bias, the analysis of its prevalence or mitigation strategies, and the availability of the full text. The final synthesis included 13 unique studies published between 2017 and 2025. The final corpus comprised one literature review, six quantitative cross-sectional studies or secondary analyses of quantitative data, one quantitative study utilizing randomized clinical vignettes, three descriptive qualitative studies, one mixed-methods longitudinal evaluation with an uncontrolled pre-post design, and one descriptive evaluation of an educational intervention. Results: The analyzed studies demonstrated the presence of implicit bias among nurses and nursing students across various healthcare settings. Specifically, negative implicit associations emerged regarding racial and ethnic minorities, lesbian, gay, and transgender individuals, people with disabilities, and patients with obesity. In several studies, explicit attitudes were more positive than implicit attitudes, suggesting that self-reported measures may not fully capture participants' automatic associations. Identified mitigation strategies included self-reflection, self-assessment using the Implicit Association Test (IAT), targeted training, guided discussion, simulation, the enhancement of communication skills, and the integration of bias awareness into nursing curricula. Educational interventions generally yielded an increase in awareness and knowledge; however, evidence regarding changes in caregiving behaviors and long-term effects remained limited. An overall prevalence was not calculated due to heterogeneity across study populations, measurement tools, bias types, and methodological designs. Conclusions: Implicit bias represents a significant phenomenon within the nursing profession and may pose a barrier to delivering equitable and inclusive care. Educational initiatives should begin during undergraduate education and continue into professional practice through ongoing interventions grounded in self-reflection, simulation, communication, and cultural competence development. However, individual strategies must be integrated with organizational and institutional interventions. Longitudinal studies, more representative samples, control groups, and clinical outcome measures are required to determine whether reductions in perceived bias translate into tangible improvements in professional practice and quality of care.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Ungaro_Leonardo.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
530.81 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
530.81 kB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/120437