The Market Comparison Approach (MCA) is one of the principal valuation methods used to determine the market value of real estate properties and land. This approach is based on comparing the property being appraised (the subject property) with a set of comparable properties (comparables) selected from actual market transactions. The reliability of the valuation largely depends on the correct identification of the comparables, making the selection process one of the most critical stages of the entire appraisal procedure. This thesis aims to replicate and critically evaluate a recent reference model from the scientific literature, which focuses on the use of quantitative indices of similarity and reliability to perform the selection of the comparables among potential candidates. The objective is to analyze its replicability, highlight its structural limitations, and test its extendibility to a complex and different market such as the land and agricultural market, while also investigating the impact of price temporal discounting methods. To this end, an experimental approach based on real transaction data is developed, applying different strategies and analytical pipelines for the selection of comparables and the management of price dynamics. For each experiment, the value estimated via MCA is compared with the observed transaction price, evaluating its accuracy and fairness through statistical error metrics and specific parameters. The analysis makes it possible to quantify the impact of selection criteria and temporal corrections on valuation precision, highlighting their respective strengths, limitations, and potential areas of application, thereby contributing to the scientific debate on quantitative methods in property valuation processes.
Il Market Comparison Approach (MCA) è uno dei principali metodi di stima utilizzati per determinare il valore di mercato di beni immobili e fondiari. Questo approccio si basa sul confronto tra il bene da stimare (subject property) e un insieme di beni comparabili scelti tra transazioni di mercato realmente avvenute. L'affidabilità della stima dipende in larga misura dalla corretta identificazione dei comparabili, rendendo questa fase una delle più critiche dell'intera procedura estimativa. Questa tesi si propone di replicare e valutare criticamente un recente modello di riferimento tratto dalla letteratura scientifica, incentrato sull'uso di indici quantitativi di similarità e affidabilità. L'obiettivo è analizzarne la replicabilità, evidenziarne i limiti strutturali e testarne l'estendibilità a un mercato complesso e differente come quello fondiario e agricolo, indagando al contempo l'impatto dei metodi di attualizzazione temporale dei prezzi. A tal fine, viene sviluppato un approccio sperimentale basato su dati transattivi reali, applicando diverse strategie e pipeline analitiche per la selezione dei comparabili e la gestione della dinamica dei prezzi. Per ciascun esperimento, il valore stimato tramite MCA viene confrontato con il prezzo di transazione osservato, valutandone l'accuratezza e l'equità attraverso metriche di errore statistiche e parametri specifici. L'analisi permette di quantificare l'impatto dei criteri di selezione e delle correzioni temporali sulla precisione della stima, evidenziandone i punti di forza, i limiti applicativi e le potenziali aree di miglioramento, contribuendo così al dibattito scientifico sui metodi quantitativi nei processi di stima.
Un'analisi comparativa dei criteri di selezione dei comparables nel Market Comparison Approach mediante simulazioni
ADAMI, ELEONORA
2025/2026
Abstract
The Market Comparison Approach (MCA) is one of the principal valuation methods used to determine the market value of real estate properties and land. This approach is based on comparing the property being appraised (the subject property) with a set of comparable properties (comparables) selected from actual market transactions. The reliability of the valuation largely depends on the correct identification of the comparables, making the selection process one of the most critical stages of the entire appraisal procedure. This thesis aims to replicate and critically evaluate a recent reference model from the scientific literature, which focuses on the use of quantitative indices of similarity and reliability to perform the selection of the comparables among potential candidates. The objective is to analyze its replicability, highlight its structural limitations, and test its extendibility to a complex and different market such as the land and agricultural market, while also investigating the impact of price temporal discounting methods. To this end, an experimental approach based on real transaction data is developed, applying different strategies and analytical pipelines for the selection of comparables and the management of price dynamics. For each experiment, the value estimated via MCA is compared with the observed transaction price, evaluating its accuracy and fairness through statistical error metrics and specific parameters. The analysis makes it possible to quantify the impact of selection criteria and temporal corrections on valuation precision, highlighting their respective strengths, limitations, and potential areas of application, thereby contributing to the scientific debate on quantitative methods in property valuation processes.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Adami_Eleonora.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
1.02 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.02 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/116859