This thesis analyzes the decision-making paralysis of the United Nations Security Council and its implications for the management of international conflicts. Starting from the role assigned to the Council by Article 24 of the United Nations Charter, the study examines the functioning of the collective security system and the political weight of the veto power granted to the five permanent members. The aim is to understand what happens when the lack of consensus among the major powers prevents the adoption of effective decisions and how this situation encourages the intervention of alternative actors, such as regional organizations, ad hoc coalitions or individual States. After reconstructing the origins, structure and functions of the Security Council, the thesis focuses on the power dynamics that may lead to decision-making deadlocks and on their consequences in terms of effectiveness, legitimacy and fragmentation of international security governance. The Russian-Ukrainian conflict is used as a case study to highlight the structural limits of the system, with particular attention to the role of the veto exercised by the Russian Federation. Finally, the thesis considers some possible future developments, including proposals for Security Council reform and the emergence of new models of international security governance.
La tesi analizza il fenomeno della paralisi decisionale del Consiglio di Sicurezza delle Nazioni Unite e le sue implicazioni nella gestione dei conflitti internazionali. Partendo dal ruolo attribuito al Consiglio dall’articolo 24 della Carta delle Nazioni Unite, il lavoro esamina il funzionamento del sistema di sicurezza collettiva e il peso politico del diritto di veto riconosciuto ai cinque membri permanenti. L’obiettivo è comprendere cosa accade quando l’assenza di consenso tra le grandi potenze impedisce l’adozione di decisioni efficaci e in che modo tale situazione favorisca l’intervento di attori alternativi, come organizzazioni regionali, coalizioni ad hoc o singoli Stati. Dopo aver ricostruito le origini, la struttura e le funzioni del Consiglio, l’elaborato approfondisce le dinamiche di potere che possono condurre agli stalli decisionali e le conseguenze che ne derivano in termini di efficacia, legittimità e frammentazione della governance internazionale della sicurezza. Il conflitto russo-ucraino viene utilizzato come caso di studio per mostrare i limiti strutturali del sistema, con particolare attenzione al ruolo del veto della Federazione Russa. Infine, la tesi considera alcune prospettive evolutive, tra cui le proposte di riforma del Consiglio e l’emergere di nuovi modelli di gestione della sicurezza internazionale.
La paralisi decisionale del Consiglio di Sicurezza delle Nazioni Unite e le sue implicazioni per la gestione dei conflitti nel sistema internazionale
CROSARA, MARTINA
2025/2026
Abstract
This thesis analyzes the decision-making paralysis of the United Nations Security Council and its implications for the management of international conflicts. Starting from the role assigned to the Council by Article 24 of the United Nations Charter, the study examines the functioning of the collective security system and the political weight of the veto power granted to the five permanent members. The aim is to understand what happens when the lack of consensus among the major powers prevents the adoption of effective decisions and how this situation encourages the intervention of alternative actors, such as regional organizations, ad hoc coalitions or individual States. After reconstructing the origins, structure and functions of the Security Council, the thesis focuses on the power dynamics that may lead to decision-making deadlocks and on their consequences in terms of effectiveness, legitimacy and fragmentation of international security governance. The Russian-Ukrainian conflict is used as a case study to highlight the structural limits of the system, with particular attention to the role of the veto exercised by the Russian Federation. Finally, the thesis considers some possible future developments, including proposals for Security Council reform and the emergence of new models of international security governance.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Crosara_Martina.pdf..pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
966.85 kB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
966.85 kB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/117781