Targeted violence encompasses prejudice, stereotyping, discrimination, hate speech, extremism, and bullying and is a growing concern in schools, where adolescence is a sensitive period for group identity and peer-norm development. This systematic review, conducted as part of a preregistered project and following PRISMA guidelines, examined which pedagogical approaches school-based programs use, how they are delivered, and how they vary across developmental periods. Academic databases and grey-literature sources were searched for empirical school-based intervention or prevention studies involving adolescents aged 10–19; paired independent reviewers conducted screening and data extraction in Covidence. Seventy-four unique studies from 76 eligible reports were included, covering 23,618 participants (Mage = 13.49 years). Studies were most frequently conducted in the United States (17.6%), Italy (14.9%), and the United Kingdom (13.5%), and 48.6% focused on prejudice and discrimination. Contact-based approaches were most common (55.4%), with direct contact accounting for 43.9% of contact-based studies, followed by skills-based (31.1%) and didactic (29.7%) approaches. Programs were predominantly offline (94.6%), most often delivered by research staff (36.5%) and in weekly sessions (39.2%). Contact-based approaches predominated in early and middle adolescence, followed by skills-based approaches in early adolescence and didactic approaches in middle adolescence. Overall, findings indicate a concentration on face-to-face, contact-based, researcher-delivered programs and limited evidence for late adolescence, highlighting the need for more diverse, sustainable, school-led approaches.

Targeted violence encompasses prejudice, stereotyping, discrimination, hate speech, extremism, and bullying and is a growing concern in schools, where adolescence is a sensitive period for group identity and peer-norm development. This systematic review, conducted as part of a preregistered project and following PRISMA guidelines, examined which pedagogical approaches school-based programs use, how they are delivered, and how they vary across developmental periods. Academic databases and grey-literature sources were searched for empirical school-based intervention or prevention studies involving adolescents aged 10–19; paired independent reviewers conducted screening and data extraction in Covidence. Seventy-four unique studies from 76 eligible reports were included, covering 23,618 participants (Mage = 13.49 years). Studies were most frequently conducted in the United States (17.6%), Italy (14.9%), and the United Kingdom (13.5%), and 48.6% focused on prejudice and discrimination. Contact-based approaches were most common (55.4%), with direct contact accounting for 43.9% of contact-based studies, followed by skills-based (31.1%) and didactic (29.7%) approaches. Programs were predominantly offline (94.6%), most often delivered by research staff (36.5%) and in weekly sessions (39.2%). Contact-based approaches predominated in early and middle adolescence, followed by skills-based approaches in early adolescence and didactic approaches in middle adolescence. Overall, findings indicate a concentration on face-to-face, contact-based, researcher-delivered programs and limited evidence for late adolescence, highlighting the need for more diverse, sustainable, school-led approaches.

School-based interventions preventing targeted violence in adolescence: a systematic review

KUCUK, BEYZA NUR
2025/2026

Abstract

Targeted violence encompasses prejudice, stereotyping, discrimination, hate speech, extremism, and bullying and is a growing concern in schools, where adolescence is a sensitive period for group identity and peer-norm development. This systematic review, conducted as part of a preregistered project and following PRISMA guidelines, examined which pedagogical approaches school-based programs use, how they are delivered, and how they vary across developmental periods. Academic databases and grey-literature sources were searched for empirical school-based intervention or prevention studies involving adolescents aged 10–19; paired independent reviewers conducted screening and data extraction in Covidence. Seventy-four unique studies from 76 eligible reports were included, covering 23,618 participants (Mage = 13.49 years). Studies were most frequently conducted in the United States (17.6%), Italy (14.9%), and the United Kingdom (13.5%), and 48.6% focused on prejudice and discrimination. Contact-based approaches were most common (55.4%), with direct contact accounting for 43.9% of contact-based studies, followed by skills-based (31.1%) and didactic (29.7%) approaches. Programs were predominantly offline (94.6%), most often delivered by research staff (36.5%) and in weekly sessions (39.2%). Contact-based approaches predominated in early and middle adolescence, followed by skills-based approaches in early adolescence and didactic approaches in middle adolescence. Overall, findings indicate a concentration on face-to-face, contact-based, researcher-delivered programs and limited evidence for late adolescence, highlighting the need for more diverse, sustainable, school-led approaches.
2025
School-based interventions preventing targeted violence in adolescence: a systematic review
Targeted violence encompasses prejudice, stereotyping, discrimination, hate speech, extremism, and bullying and is a growing concern in schools, where adolescence is a sensitive period for group identity and peer-norm development. This systematic review, conducted as part of a preregistered project and following PRISMA guidelines, examined which pedagogical approaches school-based programs use, how they are delivered, and how they vary across developmental periods. Academic databases and grey-literature sources were searched for empirical school-based intervention or prevention studies involving adolescents aged 10–19; paired independent reviewers conducted screening and data extraction in Covidence. Seventy-four unique studies from 76 eligible reports were included, covering 23,618 participants (Mage = 13.49 years). Studies were most frequently conducted in the United States (17.6%), Italy (14.9%), and the United Kingdom (13.5%), and 48.6% focused on prejudice and discrimination. Contact-based approaches were most common (55.4%), with direct contact accounting for 43.9% of contact-based studies, followed by skills-based (31.1%) and didactic (29.7%) approaches. Programs were predominantly offline (94.6%), most often delivered by research staff (36.5%) and in weekly sessions (39.2%). Contact-based approaches predominated in early and middle adolescence, followed by skills-based approaches in early adolescence and didactic approaches in middle adolescence. Overall, findings indicate a concentration on face-to-face, contact-based, researcher-delivered programs and limited evidence for late adolescence, highlighting the need for more diverse, sustainable, school-led approaches.
interventions
adolescence
targeted violence
school
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
Kucuk_Beyza_Nur.pdf

accesso aperto

Dimensione 1.06 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
1.06 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118225