The present study explores adolescents’ perceptions of the presence of gender stereotypes and expectations within the family context and their possible role in parenting practices and in the development of autonomy during adolescence. In particular, attention is paid to the ways in which gender-related representations may influence parental support and control practices. The study adopted a qualitative approach and involved six focus groups and one semi-structured individual interview, with a total sample of 34 adolescents (15 males and 19 females) aged between 14 and 19 years. The data collected were subjected to thematic analysis, following the method proposed by Braun and Clarke (2006), with the aim of identifying the main themes emerging in relation to adolescents’ perceptions of gender stereotypes, family dynamics, and parenting practices. The results highlight widespread awareness of the presence of gender stereotypes and expectations in everyday life and within the family context, although these representations are recognized and interpreted differently by boys and girls. Girls show a greater tendency to recognize stereotypes as potentially limiting, whereas boys more frequently tend to minimize their persistence. Within the family context, an asymmetrical division of domestic labor also emerges, with mothers appearing to be more involved in domestic and caregiving activities, while fathers are predominantly associated with practical and instrumental roles. With regard to autonomy, parental support does not show a systematic differentiation based on the gender of the children, but appears to take different forms depending on the parental figure involved. Parental control, by contrast, appears to be influenced by gender: girls report more intensive supervision, justified by the need for protection, whereas boys are generally granted greater freedom, accompanied, however, by the expectation that they demonstrate strength and self-reliance. Overall, the study suggests that gender stereotypes do not directly determine the development of autonomy, but may contribute to shaping different relational conditions and experiential opportunities through which autonomy is progressively constructed and negotiated. The family thus emerges as a dynamic and bidirectional system in which gender expectations are transmitted, interpreted, and potentially renegotiated, also through the active role played by adolescents.
Il presente studio esplora le percezioni degli adolescenti rispetto alla presenza di stereotipi e aspettative di genere nel contesto familiare e al loro possibile ruolo nelle pratiche genitoriali e nel processo di costruzione dell’autonomia durante l’adolescenza. In particolare, l’attenzione è rivolta alle modalità attraverso cui le rappresentazioni legate al genere possono influenzare le pratiche di supporto e controllo esercitate dai genitori. La ricerca ha adottato un approccio qualitativo e ha previsto la conduzione di sei focus group e un’intervista individuale semi-strutturata, coinvolgendo complessivamente un campione di 34 adolescenti (15 maschi e 19 femmine) di età compresa tra i 14 e i 19 anni. I dati raccolti sono stati sottoposti a un’analisi tematica, secondo il metodo proposto da Braun e Clarke (2006), finalizzata a individuare i principali temi emersi in relazione alle percezioni degli adolescenti sugli stereotipi di genere, sulle dinamiche familiari e sulle pratiche educative. I risultati evidenziano una diffusa consapevolezza della presenza di stereotipi e aspettative di genere nella vita quotidiana e nel contesto familiare, sebbene tali rappresentazioni vengano riconosciute e interpretate in modo differente da ragazzi e ragazze. Le ragazze mostrano una maggiore propensione a riconoscere gli stereotipi come elementi potenzialmente limitanti, mentre i ragazzi tendono più frequentemente a minimizzarne la persistenza. Nel contesto familiare emerge inoltre una divisione asimmetrica del lavoro domestico, nel quale le madri sembrano maggiormente coinvolte nelle attività domestiche e di cura e i padri associati prevalentemente a ruoli pratici e strumentali. Per quanto riguarda l’autonomia, il supporto genitoriale non mostra una differenziazione sistematica in base al genere dei figli, ma sembra assumere caratteristiche differenti in relazione alla figura di riferimento. Il controllo genitoriale appare invece influenzato dal genere: le ragazze riferiscono una supervisione più intensa, giustificata dalla necessità di protezione, mentre ai ragazzi viene generalmente concessa una maggiore libertà, accompagnata tuttavia dall’aspettativa di dimostrare forza e autosufficienza. Nel complesso, la ricerca suggerisce che gli stereotipi di genere non determinino direttamente lo sviluppo dell’autonomia, ma possano contribuire a configurare differenti condizioni relazionali e opportunità esperienziali attraverso cui essa viene progressivamente costruita e negoziata. La famiglia emerge così come un sistema dinamico e bidirezionale, nel quale le aspettative di genere vengono trasmesse, interpretate e potenzialmente rinegoziate anche attraverso il ruolo attivo degli adolescenti.
Stereotipi di genere in famiglia e autonomia in adolescenza: uno studio qualitativo sul supporto e sul controllo genitoriali
CIVIERO, ALICE
2025/2026
Abstract
The present study explores adolescents’ perceptions of the presence of gender stereotypes and expectations within the family context and their possible role in parenting practices and in the development of autonomy during adolescence. In particular, attention is paid to the ways in which gender-related representations may influence parental support and control practices. The study adopted a qualitative approach and involved six focus groups and one semi-structured individual interview, with a total sample of 34 adolescents (15 males and 19 females) aged between 14 and 19 years. The data collected were subjected to thematic analysis, following the method proposed by Braun and Clarke (2006), with the aim of identifying the main themes emerging in relation to adolescents’ perceptions of gender stereotypes, family dynamics, and parenting practices. The results highlight widespread awareness of the presence of gender stereotypes and expectations in everyday life and within the family context, although these representations are recognized and interpreted differently by boys and girls. Girls show a greater tendency to recognize stereotypes as potentially limiting, whereas boys more frequently tend to minimize their persistence. Within the family context, an asymmetrical division of domestic labor also emerges, with mothers appearing to be more involved in domestic and caregiving activities, while fathers are predominantly associated with practical and instrumental roles. With regard to autonomy, parental support does not show a systematic differentiation based on the gender of the children, but appears to take different forms depending on the parental figure involved. Parental control, by contrast, appears to be influenced by gender: girls report more intensive supervision, justified by the need for protection, whereas boys are generally granted greater freedom, accompanied, however, by the expectation that they demonstrate strength and self-reliance. Overall, the study suggests that gender stereotypes do not directly determine the development of autonomy, but may contribute to shaping different relational conditions and experiential opportunities through which autonomy is progressively constructed and negotiated. The family thus emerges as a dynamic and bidirectional system in which gender expectations are transmitted, interpreted, and potentially renegotiated, also through the active role played by adolescents.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
CIVIERO_ALICE.pdf
accesso aperto
Dimensione
1.17 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
1.17 MB | Adobe PDF | Visualizza/Apri |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/118319