Cleaning and sanitation procedures applied to processing surfaces, together with their frequency of application, are essential prerequisite measures for controlling microbiological risks in the frozen food industry. In particular, surfaces located downstream of thermal processing steps may represent a potential source of product cross-contamination if hygiene procedures are not adequately implemented, monitored, and verified. The aim of this study was to assess, under actual production conditions, the effectiveness of the cleaning and sanitation procedures implemented by Bocon S.r.l. on a frozen gnocchi production line. The study was conducted to provide evidence supporting the internal operational verification of the company’s hygiene procedures and the company's validation process under the conditions examined. The trials were carried out during the production of filled gnocchi, selected as an operational “worst-case” condition due to the possible simultaneous presence of dough and filling residues. Nine surfaces, including both food-contact and non-food-contact surfaces, were monitored. Sampling points were selected according to their position along the production line, their accessibility during cleaning operations, and their potential for residue accumulation or contamination. Microbiological analyses included the determination of total bacterial count, Enterobacteriaceae, coliforms, and Escherichia coli, as well as the detection of Listeria spp. and Listeria monocytogenes. The experimental plan consisted of three trials performed under routine operating conditions and one exploratory trial in which production was extended for up to 36 hours. In the routine trials, microbiological results were overall consistent with the company’s established criteria and showed a return to very low levels following the application of the hygiene procedures. In contrast, the 36-hour trial showed more pronounced increases in microbiological indicators. This finding was therefore interpreted as evidence of the possible effect of prolonged production activity on the hygienic conditions of the line rather than as an independent validation trial. Listeria monocytogenes was not detected in any of the samples analysed throughout the study. Overall, the three routine trials performed using the product selected as the operational “worst-case” condition provide evidence supporting the internal operational verification of the cleaning and sanitation procedures applied to the production line investigated, within the company validation process. The study also confirms the value of microbiological surface monitoring, integrated with visual inspection, monitoring of cleaning parameters, and trend analysis, as a useful tool for verifying and continuously improving the effectiveness of hygiene procedures and the company’s food safety management system.
Le procedure di detersione e sanificazione delle superfici di processo e le loro frequenze di applicazione costituiscono prerequisiti fondamentali per il controllo del rischio microbiologico nell’industria dei prodotti surgelati. In particolare, le superfici situate successivamente ai trattamenti termici delle derrate alimentari possono rappresentare una potenziale fonte di contaminazione crociata del prodotto qualora le procedure igieniche non siano adeguatamente applicate, monitorate e verificate. Il presente lavoro ha avuto l’obiettivo di verificare, in condizioni reali di produzione, l’efficacia delle procedure di detersione e sanificazione applicate presso Bocon S.r.l. a una linea di produzione di gnocchi surgelati. Lo studio è stato condotto al fine di produrre evidenze a supporto della verifica operativa interna e del processo aziendale di validazione nelle condizioni esaminate. Le prove sono state effettuate durante la lavorazione di gnocchi ripieni, selezionati come condizione di “worst case” operativo in ragione della possibile presenza concomitante di residui di impasto e ripieno. Sono state monitorate nove superfici, a contatto diretto e non a contatto con il prodotto; i punti di campionamento sono stati selezionati in funzione della posizione lungo la linea, dell’accessibilità durante le operazioni di lavaggio e del potenziale rischio di accumulo di residui o contaminazione. Le analisi microbiologiche hanno incluso la determinazione della carica batterica totale, delle Enterobacteriaceae, dei coliformi e di Escherichia coli, nonché la ricerca di Listeria spp. e Listeria monocytogenes. Il piano sperimentale ha previsto tre prove svolte in condizioni operative ordinarie e una prova esplorativa caratterizzata dal prolungamento della produzione fino a 36 ore. Nelle prove ordinarie, i risultati microbiologici sono stati complessivamente compatibili con i criteri aziendali adottati e hanno evidenziato il ritorno a valori molto bassi in seguito all’applicazione delle procedure igieniche. La prova a 36 ore ha invece mostrato incrementi più marcati degli indicatori microbiologici; tale risultato è stato pertanto considerato un’indicazione della possibile influenza del prolungamento dell’attività produttiva sulle condizioni igieniche della linea e non una prova di validazione autonoma. Nel corso delle prove non è stata rilevata la presenza di Listeria monocytogenes in nessuno dei campioni analizzati. Nel complesso, le tre prove ordinarie condotte sulla matrice selezionata come “worst case” forniscono evidenze a supporto della verifica operativa interna delle procedure di detersione e sanificazione, nell’ambito del processo aziendale di validazione. Il lavoro conferma inoltre l’utilità del monitoraggio microbiologico delle superfici, integrato con ispezione visiva, controllo dei parametri di lavaggio e analisi delle tendenze, quale strumento per verificare e migliorare continuamente l’efficacia delle procedure igieniche e il sistema di autocontrollo aziendale.
Verifica microbiologica dell’efficacia delle procedure di detersione e sanificazione in una linea produttiva di gnocchi surgelati
BRUNELLO, GIORGIA
2025/2026
Abstract
Cleaning and sanitation procedures applied to processing surfaces, together with their frequency of application, are essential prerequisite measures for controlling microbiological risks in the frozen food industry. In particular, surfaces located downstream of thermal processing steps may represent a potential source of product cross-contamination if hygiene procedures are not adequately implemented, monitored, and verified. The aim of this study was to assess, under actual production conditions, the effectiveness of the cleaning and sanitation procedures implemented by Bocon S.r.l. on a frozen gnocchi production line. The study was conducted to provide evidence supporting the internal operational verification of the company’s hygiene procedures and the company's validation process under the conditions examined. The trials were carried out during the production of filled gnocchi, selected as an operational “worst-case” condition due to the possible simultaneous presence of dough and filling residues. Nine surfaces, including both food-contact and non-food-contact surfaces, were monitored. Sampling points were selected according to their position along the production line, their accessibility during cleaning operations, and their potential for residue accumulation or contamination. Microbiological analyses included the determination of total bacterial count, Enterobacteriaceae, coliforms, and Escherichia coli, as well as the detection of Listeria spp. and Listeria monocytogenes. The experimental plan consisted of three trials performed under routine operating conditions and one exploratory trial in which production was extended for up to 36 hours. In the routine trials, microbiological results were overall consistent with the company’s established criteria and showed a return to very low levels following the application of the hygiene procedures. In contrast, the 36-hour trial showed more pronounced increases in microbiological indicators. This finding was therefore interpreted as evidence of the possible effect of prolonged production activity on the hygienic conditions of the line rather than as an independent validation trial. Listeria monocytogenes was not detected in any of the samples analysed throughout the study. Overall, the three routine trials performed using the product selected as the operational “worst-case” condition provide evidence supporting the internal operational verification of the cleaning and sanitation procedures applied to the production line investigated, within the company validation process. The study also confirms the value of microbiological surface monitoring, integrated with visual inspection, monitoring of cleaning parameters, and trend analysis, as a useful tool for verifying and continuously improving the effectiveness of hygiene procedures and the company’s food safety management system.| File | Dimensione | Formato | |
|---|---|---|---|
|
GiorgiaBrunello.pdf
Accesso riservato
Dimensione
46.25 MB
Formato
Adobe PDF
|
46.25 MB | Adobe PDF |
The text of this website © Università degli studi di Padova. Full Text are published under a non-exclusive license. Metadata are under a CC0 License
https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12608/116855